Advanced Machine Learning CS 7140 - Spring 2018 Lecture 20: - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

advanced machine learning
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

Advanced Machine Learning CS 7140 - Spring 2018 Lecture 20: - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Advanced Machine Learning CS 7140 - Spring 2018 Lecture 20: Generative Adversarial Networks Jan-Willem van de Meent Slide credits: Ian Goodfellow Variational Autoencoders Input Hidden Mean Encoding Hidden Reconstructed Images


slide-1
SLIDE 1

Advanced Machine Learning

CS 7140 - Spring 2018

Lecture 20: Generative Adversarial Networks

Jan-Willem van de Meent Slide credits: Ian Goodfellow

slide-2
SLIDE 2

Variational Autoencoders

784 (28 x 28) 256 Input Images Hidden Units 2-50 Encoding (random) Mean
 Std Dev 256 784 (28 x 28) Hidden Units Reconstructed
 Images

slide-3
SLIDE 3

Variational Autoencoders

Assume prior:

slide-4
SLIDE 4

Objective: Evidence Lower Bound (ELBO)

Reconstruction
 log-likelihood KL between approximate 
 posterior and prior Log marginal likelihood KL between approximate posterior and posterior

<latexit sha1_base64="xCnLHJxvOenf3Kf6H0xnPDc3fOI=">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</latexit>
slide-5
SLIDE 5

Generative Adversarial Networks

x sampled from data Differentiable function D D(x) tries to be near 1 Input noise z Differentiable function G x sampled from model D D tries to make D(G(z)) near 0, G tries to make D(G(z)) near 1

slide-6
SLIDE 6

Implicit Generative Models

z x

  • Can generate samples x ~ pG(x)
  • Cannot evaluate density pG(x)
  • Requirement: G(z ; θ) is differentiable
<latexit sha1_base64="RPJ/9dykIGmaIKoms+rtG6vULy0=">AGOnicfZRLa9wEICVNtum7itpj72Y7iWBJdhpSAKlEFpCckxDXhAviyzPekXkRyQ5L6F/lp/QP9Brb6W30lt7qOx16NoylcFIM98pBkpzBkV0vO+zj14ON979HjhifP02fMXLxeXh2LrOAEjkjGMn4aYgGMpnAkqWRwmnPAScjgJDz/VOpPLoELmqWH8iaHYLjlI4pwdKIRovj4FJdazcQNHz0e5ytVxgosCR04QkxTRYx/oR2jur0nl6vFShA4U/sP7u5U5L53AzkBiY0PSKN729Fi31v1quHaE7+e9FE9kdL83dBlJEigVQShoU4871cDhXmkhIGJptCQI7JOY7hzExTnIAYqupAtNvQHvpDNc5SCSlpmCmciATLiSUsYdGUkokJDLwZthYOVeklAkHjtGkVJtpxgjGpjhVZioKWQFaHex+1MobLwb+GubuoVwiGrC3/IG5msDMQdIa2RrfeBvbNlMXvCcwT/IK7EyGw4pXJEsSbCpTnAJRJ+Z8zG1EgWHciMqCBPV97XWFjxFjU2ld4JZ5bVWKmgkWHVG7uZwcqNGujGgm67fN1a2EUXNu2+juxlN42LDraw2MKGuAXxdobQGRNyQVmWvsZz9BVn4ztoGyGqWtcumTmxkfY8phPuvF8Qi32oFWZA12yBeZxgU+cgy4FjmfHy0l1ROWE0oVKoWq9tK5r+38ro28F2dLMpy38Yqh1tkSRkVWM2z87uUMKjJlfusgOLeRObFq4DzFtgfcAlad47v/262ZPjtVXfW/U/r/e39+qXbwG9QW/RMvLRJtpGe2gfHSGCvqCf6Df607vrfet97/2Yog/mapvXqDF6v/4CPnVJ8w=</latexit>
slide-7
SLIDE 7

Maximum Likelihood

θ∗ = arg max

θ

Ex∼pdata log pmodel(x | θ)

slide-8
SLIDE 8

Objective: Minimax Game

  • Generator G(z) generates fake images.
  • Discriminator D(x) classifies real images as 1 


and fake images as 0.

  • Objective for G: Maximize probability that G fools D.
  • Objective for D: Minimize probability that D is fooled.
<latexit sha1_base64="pXpRo69NxwuPNk2867tQLRln0Yw=">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</latexit>
slide-9
SLIDE 9

Exercise

  • Suppose that we could evaluate pDATA(x) and pG(x)
  • Can you express D(x) in terms of pDATA(x) and pG(x)?
<latexit sha1_base64="pXpRo69NxwuPNk2867tQLRln0Yw=">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</latexit>

SOLUTION:

<latexit sha1_base64="h/1wASbY8y+dyFEiXmgpamckOK4=">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</latexit>
slide-10
SLIDE 10

Learning Implicit Densities

z x

(Goodfellow et al, 2014)

<latexit sha1_base64="AJj8C+410yR+WN7/krBHC3cmF3I=">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</latexit>

Data: Discriminator: Implicit Density:

<latexit sha1_base64="eqEfZNa4Jph6NrhGYjdfoawyxIg=">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</latexit>

Generator:

<latexit sha1_base64="h/1wASbY8y+dyFEiXmgpamckOK4=">AGLHicfZTLbtQwFEDd0oESXlNYshkxmyJGVKqthukqlCVZan6kprRyHuzFh1EmM7fVn+Jb4A8RVsEGKH2ME3EKdBTOKAI0VXvuf6Pu2IMyqV73+Zm7+10Ll9Z/Gud+/+g4ePukuPj2SWCwKHJGOZOImwBEZTOFRUMTjhAnASMTiOzl5b/fE5CEmz9EBdcRgmeJLSMSVYFVuj7smb5fBcX5rn3queF4FJpqPdKjgUkmiY6ywMRVhvJ5d/9T3XvT4aPcPOr2/RW/XD1XCqhj6q1N1pa+BjGckTSBVhWMrTwOdqLFQlDAwXphL4Jic4QmcFmKE5BDXZbA9Grag2Cox1mqICU1M40TmWA1dTYtLOu7ZFo4BlF3W20OtT0lBknad0qSoznhTGMi3aUkek4YjkYvb+7bQ/WH85CFY3TAMREFdEsOkPiq8JTARAWiGba4NgfdNleC4g7+QbzEbjYAULkiWJDiNdXgOxJwW9QkhlbkAm4gOo0T3A2OMA9+ghU2p98JZ5aXROqwFWLa+iV3NYDbRArpyoOu2s64d7H0bFqop2DF0olftNM5b2NxhcxcSDiSaEUKrT+CSsix18hnP0OWcjF2nbIapemyPZMUdj7FzIp+243xKHXa/0Zl9Y8dlsBikuCiz2HGQWCVCXvpLqiaMpQJXWlN64VTf9vVeibznZMfSjtP4r0jnFIErFyMOu1cyeUiLjO2SxbsImoYzeNawF5A6wKbMnivQuar5srHK2uBP5K8G6tv7VdvXyL6Cl6hpZRgDbQFnqL9tAhIugT+o5+ol+dD53Pna+dbzfo/Fxl8wTVufHb9nRJI=</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="OCgvdeXGiLuIpmIA79ayQpjilTo=">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</latexit>

Key Idea: Use classifier to 
 estimate ratio 


  • f densities
slide-11
SLIDE 11

Understanding the Loss

= JSD(pDATA(x) || pG(x)) log4

<latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">AIO3icpZVLb9QwEMfDUtgSXi0cuURUqnbFtkpK1fZSqQIqKsShlL6k9WrlOLPZqHnVcUpby3wy+Ah8AM7cEDfEDScbCqSOK0QZKXE8vxm5j/2GvHvpcw0/x8rXV96sbN9vQt/fadu/fuz8w+2E+ilBLYI5Ef0UMbJ+B7Iewxj/lwGFPAge3DgX30PLMfnABNvCjcZWcxDALsht7I5jJqeFsa/S6g4hL+UvRMxChDn8huoY+v27oC2hEMeGW4EtCR5tDjk74qTBQ4gVGPEQMTlCuIMZFp3c1JWYDyPWl5/IvYiW2c5FV0fUc8dsoCOkz6Pj4xQ7jRnOLzIUfrWY2bhjLRSO9Uc3UmOcq7+Wiy/81lIOP7/knL3S8hL5o0nMjQvBJfC/t1ylNRdlHyVrirzr4qKRVvXc2/+6q1c4UtCvUeyu1j+eq+I7BoLRq5vWR/OzJmLZv4Y6sAqBnMb2uTZHs5OfUBORNIAQkZ8nCR9y5SqOKbMIz5IuWkCMSZH2IW+HIY4gGTA8xMhjIp1xrwURQyCEnFjeMgCTAbK5MZnFRnyVgmBlpNW0wOeBbFgcRzw6qXHQhdRw6M5OnMlXH9lMQfOflM8HN3srTnrW0KmoIBacgrDWzJ391wKUAYGsLfeslTWViVMa+/AHMjMsU0MhHckCgIcOrLDgIi+XB8EYZJSyArhyA74nCWEUOAJKn1yu47KxlPBZU+VBeZNUMfOSlhWqITOFOi8Kda5gh03YiNQTaoqp410zhtYFOFTVWIKhCtK4TGnBAnh+FSj2jEp3yUhN6peYo+zkL68h2sRIzHzXg89hR2p7YzOyJrlzKBqRtguc8oioFiFtHs0L3z2Nj3Ao8lvLAL1csLr/aS9nqyTVFtyuxt23xTKCSx/bwxq2undqj8r6hyWZUNmEur2GTjGsC4BhYLnJHyvrPqt5s62F9atMxF683y3MZWcfNa4+0x1pHs7RVbUPb0ra1PY20PrW+t362frU/tr+0v7a/TdDWtcLnoVZ52j9+Ayp5BMc=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JGHt+tahfEyx/NQp7MyqDK6RA38=">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</latexit>

' 1 2Ex⇠pDATA(x) ï log pDATA(x) pDATA(x) + pG(x) ò ï ò

<latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">AIO3icpZVLb9QwEMfDUtgSXi0cuURUqnbFtkpK1fZSqQIqKsShlL6k9WrlOLPZqHnVcUpby3wy+Ah8AM7cEDfEDScbCqSOK0QZKXE8vxm5j/2GvHvpcw0/x8rXV96sbN9vQt/fadu/fuz8w+2E+ilBLYI5Ef0UMbJ+B7Iewxj/lwGFPAge3DgX30PLMfnABNvCjcZWcxDALsht7I5jJqeFsa/S6g4hL+UvRMxChDn8huoY+v27oC2hEMeGW4EtCR5tDjk74qTBQ4gVGPEQMTlCuIMZFp3c1JWYDyPWl5/IvYiW2c5FV0fUc8dsoCOkz6Pj4xQ7jRnOLzIUfrWY2bhjLRSO9Uc3UmOcq7+Wiy/81lIOP7/knL3S8hL5o0nMjQvBJfC/t1ylNRdlHyVrirzr4qKRVvXc2/+6q1c4UtCvUeyu1j+eq+I7BoLRq5vWR/OzJmLZv4Y6sAqBnMb2uTZHs5OfUBORNIAQkZ8nCR9y5SqOKbMIz5IuWkCMSZH2IW+HIY4gGTA8xMhjIp1xrwURQyCEnFjeMgCTAbK5MZnFRnyVgmBlpNW0wOeBbFgcRzw6qXHQhdRw6M5OnMlXH9lMQfOflM8HN3srTnrW0KmoIBacgrDWzJ391wKUAYGsLfeslTWViVMa+/AHMjMsU0MhHckCgIcOrLDgIi+XB8EYZJSyArhyA74nCWEUOAJKn1yu47KxlPBZU+VBeZNUMfOSlhWqITOFOi8Kda5gh03YiNQTaoqp410zhtYFOFTVWIKhCtK4TGnBAnh+FSj2jEp3yUhN6peYo+zkL68h2sRIzHzXg89hR2p7YzOyJrlzKBqRtguc8oioFiFtHs0L3z2Nj3Ao8lvLAL1csLr/aS9nqyTVFtyuxt23xTKCSx/bwxq2undqj8r6hyWZUNmEur2GTjGsC4BhYLnJHyvrPqt5s62F9atMxF683y3MZWcfNa4+0x1pHs7RVbUPb0ra1PY20PrW+t362frU/tr+0v7a/TdDWtcLnoVZ52j9+Ayp5BMc=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JGHt+tahfEyx/NQp7MyqDK6RA38=">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</latexit>

L(G, D) = 1 2Ex⇠pDATA(x) [log D(z)] 1 2Ez⇠p(z) [log(1 G(D(z)))] ï ò

<latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JGHt+tahfEyx/NQp7MyqDK6RA38=">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</latexit>

GAN loss minimizes the Jensen-Shannon divergence

ï ò 1 2Ex⇠pG(x) ï log pG(x) pDATA(x) + pG(x) ò

<latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="esghpin5a41uOnv75ZuI+ZnNSaY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JGHt+tahfEyx/NQp7MyqDK6RA38=">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</latexit>
slide-12
SLIDE 12

Problem: Saturation

<latexit sha1_base64="vYCaIt6nm8KZv3nxsR5Txc/7z8=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="GPuh4BdZblFJB1Rk3hQx+SvRV4=">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</latexit>

Question: What happens to the gradient w.r.t. θ 
 when the discriminator D(x) = 0

<latexit sha1_base64="QUp4/J5B3SqIfPAf7asqcyvJkg=">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</latexit>
slide-13
SLIDE 13

Problem: Saturation

<latexit sha1_base64="vYCaIt6nm8KZv3nxsR5Txc/7z8=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="GPuh4BdZblFJB1Rk3hQx+SvRV4=">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</latexit>

Question: What happens to the gradient w.r.t. θ 
 when the discriminator D(x) = 0

<latexit sha1_base64="MTDTeKm4qgsBWghIm1NqYsrm4TE=">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</latexit>
slide-14
SLIDE 14

Non-Saturating GAN Loss

<latexit sha1_base64="SelI6tVAxPK3cvcjiWqSPVygy4=">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</latexit>
  • Use different loss for generator parameters θ
  • Αvoid 0 gradient issue when D(x) = 0, 


(but loss no longer takes form of JS divergence)

slide-15
SLIDE 15

DCGAN Architecture

(Radford et al 2015) Most “deconvs” are batch normalized

slide-16
SLIDE 16

LSUN Bedrooms

(Radford et al 2015)

slide-17
SLIDE 17

Vector Space Arithmetic

  • +

=

Man with Glasses Man Woman Woman with Glasses (Radford et al, 2015)

slide-18
SLIDE 18

GANs vs VAEs

  • VAEs learn a generative model and an inference model
  • GANs learn a generator and a discriminator
  • VAEs assume an explicit likelihood
  • GANs assume an implicit likelihood
  • VAEs do inference, but yield blurry images
  • GANs don’t do inference, but yield crisper images
slide-19
SLIDE 19

Next Frame Video Prediction

Ground Truth MSE Adversarial

(Lotter et al 2016)

slide-20
SLIDE 20

Next Frame Video Prediction

(Mathieu et al. 2015)

Mean Squared Error Mean Absolute Error Adversarial

slide-21
SLIDE 21

Is the Divergence Important?

x Probability Density

q∗ = argminqDKL(pq) p(x) q∗(x)

x Probability Density

q∗ = argminqDKL(qp) p(x) q∗(x)

(Goodfellow et al 2016) Variational Inference (and VAEs) Expectation Propagation (and GANs)

slide-22
SLIDE 22

Using GANs for ML estimation

<latexit sha1_base64="lvtDegNo+dm9/Idmu25IFHpKxPM=">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</latexit>

Generator loss minimizes reconstruction loss

<latexit sha1_base64="pMGiR/pM6eProgO2qglsF1a/w8=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="pMGiR/pM6eProgO2qglsF1a/w8=">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</latexit>

Conclusion: GANs and VAEs not different due divergence

slide-23
SLIDE 23

Using GANs for ML estimation

<latexit sha1_base64="lvtDegNo+dm9/Idmu25IFHpKxPM=">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</latexit>

Generator loss minimizes reconstruction loss

<latexit sha1_base64="pMGiR/pM6eProgO2qglsF1a/w8=">AG43icfZRba9RAFICzta413lp9GVxQVrYlqSWti+FUikVlFJLb7CzLpPJ2WxoMokzk96G6R/wTXwT3/Rf+Ef8N06yETeZ6ASwznfucyck/HSKOTCcX61Zu7M3m3fm7tvP3j46PGT+YWnJzJGIFjkQJO/MwhyikcCxCEcFZygDHXgSn3vnr3H56AYyHCT0S1ykMYhzQcBQSLRquNB6vIwEXAn59p1aTIeFzIn0scBqEV3IK7XUuU6gihetx3NkIDJvT/WJfvlr1so92hLBQdxMO40xJ2SiCkejrTxJ0bDRimMh/oZ18yXo6HYKFwVgMbITyzJMYrpL72sKzeCjplqs+7E9S1LyHdCkvtbSYWbV9ON91VpxidUzBLYWuVa6D4cLsT+QnJIuBChJhzvuk4qBxEyEJAJdVcYhxeQcB9DXIsUx8IEsOqc6FeuRO5CjhAqgpOImcxjLMaGMod5VUvGOjGwatpSOZB5FB94GNCqlxcr20Y+jPQUFZVJ34syUPJwb0dJp7f+queubqgawsAvCXfT6emnDgQMgJbI5lrPXd80mTRjaQR/ISfH8moYULgkSRxj6uvRAqL6+nwQUJ4xyDcikRfLrquUMuAJqn0Ku42mjVdKSlQpsOh9HbuewvKNaujagG6aYt0Y2McmDIkx6MkzqxfNM4a2MxgMxNiBsTqFUJjTkh5GCXU2M9oi7mZGQmjaYsd5yEhfT42IqbjZjwdhwZ7WOvMocrHZrALIix7jNKUmBYJCz/6S5DMY7COBRclnZleoX0/17aXk+2q6pDmb89T+4qgyReVAxm9ezMCSXMr3L5LhuwgFWxSeMawLQGlgeck/q+c+u3mymcrK64zor7fq27vVPefHPWc+uFtWi51oa1b2xDqxji7Sy1tfW9aPNrQ/tT+3v0zQmVbp8yqrPa39AhCI=</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="pMGiR/pM6eProgO2qglsF1a/w8=">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</latexit>

Conclusion: GANs and VAEs not different due divergence

slide-24
SLIDE 24

Applications of GANs

slide-25
SLIDE 25

What is in this Image?

(Yeh et al., 2016)

slide-26
SLIDE 26

Generative Modeling Reveals a Face

(Yeh et al., 2016)

slide-27
SLIDE 27

Image-to-Image Translation

(Liu et al., 2017) Day to Night

slide-28
SLIDE 28

CycleGAN

(Zhu et al., 2017) Horse to Zebra

slide-29
SLIDE 29

CycleGAN

(Zhu et al., 2017)

Zebras Horses

horse zebra zebra horse

Summer Winter

summer winter winter summer Photograph Van Gogh Cezanne Monet Ukiyo-e

Monet Photos

Monet photo photo Monet

slide-30
SLIDE 30

CycleGAN

(Zhu et al., 2017)

Zebras Horses

horse zebra zebra horse

Summer Winter

summer winter winter summer Photograph Van Gogh Cezanne Monet Ukiyo-e

Monet Photos

Monet photo photo Monet

slide-31
SLIDE 31

CycleGAN

(Zhu et al., 2017)

X Y G F DY DX

G

F ˆ Y X Y

  • X

Y

  • G

F ˆ X

(a) (b) (c)

cycle-consistency

loss

cycle-consistency loss

DY DX

ˆ y ˆ x

x y

slide-32
SLIDE 32

Which of These are Real?

vue.ai

✓ ✓

slide-33
SLIDE 33

Celebrities Who Have Never Existed

(Karras et al., 2017) “never before wholly perceived in reality”