Administrative Leadership Meeting Randy Woodson Chancellor - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

SLIDE 1

Administrative Leadership Meeting

Randy Woodson

Chancellor Tuesday, July 10, 2018

SLIDE 2

Upcoming ALMs

September 18, 2018 Employee Engagement Titmus November 20, 2018 Strategic Plan Report Card Titmus

SLIDE 3

Continued Positive Trajectory for Student Success

• Largest incoming freshman class in history
• Transfer student pipeline
• Increasing graduation rates

SLIDE 4

Think and Do the Extraordinary Campaign Momentum Strong

• Campaign Progress: $1.33 billion
• Fitts-Woolard Hall named in honor of

largest private alumni gift to building

• Park Foundation makes additional

commitment

SLIDE 5

Questions?

SLIDE 6

UNDERSTANDING OUR RANKINGS

Administrative Leadership Meeting • July 10, 2018

Warwick Arden, Executive Vice Chancellor and Provost

SLIDE 7

Importance of Rankings

Shapes perceptions of NC State for

• Prospective and current students
• Prospective and current faculty and staff
• Other institutions and prospective partners
• Funding agencies (including other countries)
• Public at large

Can be a tool for measuring strategic success

SLIDE 8

Limitations of Rankings

Multiple rankings, with different audiences, methodologies and results Not all universities participate No agreement in Higher Ed about what to measure and how to rank institutions Lag current data by a year or two

SLIDE 9

Types of Indicators

Student Selectivity Instructional Impact Institutional Resources Reputational Student Success Faculty Productivity: Research $ Faculty Productivity: Bibliometric Faculty Productivity: Awards

SLIDE 10

Data Sources

SLIDE 11

NC State and Peers – Fall 2016

Institution Land Grant Medical School Vet School Total Students % UG Students Student/ Faculty Ratio Colorado State University X X 33,058 78% 18/1 Georgia Institute of Technology 26,839 58% 20/1 Iowa State University X X 36,350 84% 19/1 Michigan State University X X X 50,344 78% 17/1 NC State University X X 33,755 71% 13/1 Ohio State University X X X 59,482 77% 19/1 Penn State University-Main Campus X X 47,789 87% 16/1 Purdue University-Main Campus X X 40,451 74% 12/1 Rutgers University X 50,146 72% 13/1 Texas A & M University X X X 65,302 78% 21/1 University of Arizona X X 43,625 78% 22/1 University of California-Davis X X X 36,441 81% 20/1 University of Florida X X X 52,367 66% 20/1 University of Illinois-Urbana/Champaign X X 46,951 72% 20/1 University of Maryland-College Park X 39,083 73% 17/1 University of Wisconsin-Madison X X X 43,336 73% 18/1 Virginia Polytechnic Institute X X 33,170 78% 14/1 Data from 2016-17 Common Data Set

SLIDE 12

DOMESTIC RANKINGS

SLIDE 13

Comparison of Domestic Rankings

To help prospective undergraduate students find the right college To help prospective graduate students find programs To improve the performance

• f American research

universities Primary source of information on R&D expenditures at U.S. universities PURPOSE:

• Reputation
• Student Success
• Reputation
• Faculty Productivity

(Research Expenditures and Awards)

• Faculty Productivity

(Research Expenditures) DOMINANT: INDICATORS:

SLIDE 14

U.S. News and World Report: Undergraduate Rankings

• Purpose: To help prospective students

and their families find the right college

• Population (National Universities):

Universities that offer a full ranges of undergraduate majors, plus master’s and doctoral programs, and emphasize faculty research; 230 individually-ranked schools

• Frequency: Annual

– 2018 edition released September 2017

colleges.usnews.rankingsandreviews.com/best-colleges

SLIDE 15

U.S. News: Undergraduate Rankings NC State Overall Rank 2011 to 2018 Editions

111 101 106 101 95 89 92 81

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

SLIDE 16

U.S. News and World Report: Undergraduate Rankings 2018 Edition Methodology

Category % of rank 2018 Ranking Metric Subfactor Weight Overall Weight Undergraduate Academic Reputation 22.5% Peer assessment (ave spring 2016 and 2017 surveys) 66.7% 15% High school counselor rating score (ave. spring 2015, 2016, 2017 surveys) 33.3% 7.5% Graduation & Retention 22.5% Freshman retention (ave. 2012-15 cohorts) 20% 4.5% 6 Year graduation rate (ave. 2007-10 cohorts) 80% 18% Graduation Rate Performance 7.5% 6 Year graduation rate (2010 cohort) 100% 7.5% Predicted 6 year graduation rate Faculty Resources 20% Class size index (fall 2016) 40% 8% Student/faculty ratio (fall 2016) 5% 1% % Full time faculty (2016-17 academic year) 5% 1% Faculty compensation (ave. 2015-16 and 2016-17 academic years) 35% 7% % Full time faculty with terminal degree (2016-17 academic year) 15% 3% Student Selectivity 12.5%

• Ave. Math SAT, Ave. Verbal SAT, Composite ACT (fall 2016 cohort)

65% 8.125% % Entering freshmen in top 10% of HS class (fall 2016 cohort) 25% 3.125% Acceptance rate (fall 2016 admission) 10% 1.25% Financial Resources 10% Educational expenditures per student (ave. FY 2015 and FY 2016) 100% 10% Alumni Giving 5% Alumni giving rate (ave. 2014-15 and 2015-16 academic years) 100% 5%

SLIDE 17

20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Overall Rank Peer Assessment High School Counselor Faculty Resources Graduation and Retention Student Selectivity Financial Resources

• Grad. Rate

Performance Alumni Giving

2016 2017 2018

U.S. News: Undergraduate Rankings NC State - Category Ranks 2016 to 2018 Editions

SLIDE 18

81 80 128 81 70 138 64 97 86 68 46 64 69 94 140 86 83 97

Overall Rank Peer Assessment High School Counselor Graduation and Retention

• Grad. Rate

Performance Faculty Resources Student Selectivity Financial Resources Alumni Giving

U.S. News: Undergraduate Rankings 2018 Edition - Category Ranks

15% 7.5% 22.5% 7.5% 20% 12.5% 10% 5%

NC State vs. 16 Peers (average)

(Column widths represent category weight)

SLIDE 19

U.S. News: Undergraduate Rankings Faculty Resources - NC State

% of Rank Subfactor Weight Overall Weight Metric 2016 2017 2018 Rank: 178 Rank: 157 Rank: 138 Score Score Score 20% 40% 8% % Classes with < 20 students Class Size Indicator Rank used in 2017+ 28.3% 227 194 % Classes with ≥ 50 students 16.8% 5% 1% Student/faculty ratio 16/1 14/1 13/1 5% 1% % Full time faculty 93.9% 95.1% 94.8% 35% 7% Faculty compensation (x 1,000) $118.00 $127.57 $132.61 15% 3% Faculty with terminal degree 90.7% 92.4% 91.9%

SLIDE 20

U.S. News: Undergraduate Rankings – 2018 Edition: Faculty Resources

Weight of Metric Rank Tie School 30 * University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill 34 * Georgia Institute of Technology 42 * University of Florida 46 * University of Wisconsin-Madison 46 * University of California-Davis 52 * University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign 52 * Pennsylvania State University 54 * Ohio State University 56 * Purdue University 61 * University of Maryland-College Park 69 * Texas A & M University 69 * Virginia Polytechnic and State University 69 * Rutgers University-New Brunswick 81 * Michigan State University 81 * North Carolina State University 115 * Iowa State University 124 * Colorado State University 124 * University of Arizona 8% 1% 1% 7% 3% Faculty resources rank Class Size Indicator Rank Student/ faculty ratio % Full Time Faculty Faculty Compensation Rank Faculty with Terminal Degree 94 186 13/1 92% 52 86% 178 271 20/1 97% 35 81% 89 157 20/1 93% 65 89% 106 263 20/1 89% 27 92% 124 208 18/1 94% 87 91% 83 220 20/1 100% 35 94% 166 271 16/1 96% 35 81% 166 274 19/1 88% 81 98% 74 220 12/1 95% 57 98% 128 176 17/1 88% 119 91% 106 233 13/1 73% 62 99% 184 294 21/1 92% 28 89% 166 278 14/1 96% 65 90% 210 280 17/1 95% 94 90% 138 194 13/1 95% 126 92% 194 281 19/1 94% 77 93% 145 194 22/1 94% 94 89% 128 239 18/1 99% 103 100% Note: Shading indicates values that are below NC State’s for a given metric

SLIDE 21

U.S. News: Undergraduate Rankings Specialized Lists – 2016 v. 2018

Best Value Colleges Best Colleges for Veterans Best Business Programs Best Engineering Programs

• 2016: 50
• 2018: 46
• 2016: 72
• 2018: 44
• 2016: 93
• 2018: 91
• 2016: 31
• 2018: 34

SLIDE 22

U.S. News and World Report: Graduate Edition

• Purpose: To help prospective graduate

students find programs

• Population: Varies by program/discipline
• Frequency: Annual (in most disciplines)

– 2019 edition released March 2018

grad-schools.usnews.rankingsandreviews.com/best-graduate-schools

SLIDE 23

U.S. News: Graduate Edition NC State – Public Affairs, Science, Social Sciences and Humanities, Education, Business and Health 2017 Edition vs. 2019 Edition

45 48 75 56 60 52 54 15 48 101 52 51 52 34 78 3 44 43 85 52 68 53 52 16 55 112 47 46 92 74 75 3

SLIDE 24

U.S. News: Graduate Edition NC State - Engineering 2017 Edition vs. 2019 Edition

27 26 10 37 21 24 36 34 29 12 15 35 6 24 30 8 34 21 23 26 32 27 16 18 38 4

* Joint department with UNC-CH

SLIDE 25

Center For Measuring University Performance

• Purpose: To improve the performance of

American research universities

• Population: Institutions with $40+ million in

annual federal research expenditures; 160 institutions met the criteria

• Frequency: Annual report on The Top

American Research Universities

– 2016 edition released Fall 2017

mup.asu.edu/Top-Universities

SLIDE 26

Center For Measuring University Performance 2016 Report

Category* Data Source Total research expenditures NSF Higher Education Research and Development (HERD) Survey, FY 2014 Federal research expenditures NSF Higher Education Research and Development (HERD) Survey, FY 2014 Endowment assets NACUBO-Commonfund Study of Endowment, endowment market value as of June 30, 2015 Annual giving Council for Aid to Education’s Voluntary Support of Education (VSE) Survey, FY 2015 National Academy members National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine membership directories for 2015 Faculty awards Directories or web-based listings for multiple agencies or organizations. Years vary (2014-15 to 2015-16). Doctorates awarded NCES IPEDS Completions Survey, doctoral degrees awarded between July 1, 2014 and June 30, 2015. Postdoctoral appointees NSF/Division of Science Resource Statistics (SRS) Survey of Graduate Students and Postdoctorates in Science and Engineering, Fall 2014 SAT Scores NCES IPEDS Survey, SAT scores for Fall 2014.

*All categories have equal weight.

SLIDE 27

Center For Measuring University Performance 2016 Report: NC State

Category Top American Research Universities 2016 Edition Year's Value Rank Among Publics Rank Among All Rank 27 53* Total research expenditures x $1000 (FY 2014) $440,392 27 44 Federal research expenditures x $1000 (FY 2014) $177,722 44 70 Endowment assets x $1000 (FY 2015) $983,979 32 89 Annual giving x $1000 (FY 2015) $119,150 41 72 National academy members (2015) 20 31 58 Faculty awards (2014-15 to 2015-16) 11 33 58 Doctorates granted (FY 2015) 512 23 31 Postdoctoral appointees (Fall 2014) 473 18 38 Median SAT (Fall 2014) 1245 27 114

Notes *6 institutions share 53rd on the overall list with NC State University Source: http://mup.asu.edu/

Top 25 Top 26-50

SLIDE 28

Category Top American Research Universities Edition 2013 2014 2015 2016 Overall rank among all institutions 60 52 51 53 Number of measures in top 25 among all Number of measures in top 26-50 among all 2 4 4 3 Overall rank among public institutions 43 25 27 27 Number of measures in top 25 among public 3 2 2 Number of measures in top 26-50 among public 8 5 7 7 Value Public Rank National Rank Value Public Rank National Rank Value Public Rank National Rank Value Public Rank National Rank Total research expenditures x $1000 $374,446 33 54 $400,046 33 52 $413,524 31 49 $440,392 27 44 Federal research expenditures x $1000 $152,790 48 78 $171,464 44 72 $174,440 44 70 $177,722 44 70 Endowment assets x $1000 $635,326 40 108 $769,404 37 97 $885,055 34 93 $983,979 32 89 Annual giving x $1000 $100,324 40 64 $131,378 24 46 $117,535 35 66 $119,150 41 72 National Academy members 19 30 56 18 30 58 20 30 57 20 31 58 Faculty awards 12 30 50 14 24 44 12 27 48 11 33 58 Doctorates granted 446 26 37 488 21 31 494 21 31 512 23 31 Postdoctoral appointees 318 29 54 371 26 48 490 18 36 473 18 38 Median SAT 1185 57 220 1185 57 216 1225 36 151 1245 27 114

Center For Measuring University Performance NC State: 2013-2016 Reports

SLIDE 29

Center for Measuring University Performance 2016 Report – Ranks among Public Institutions

27 27 44 32 41 31 33 23 18 27 18 21 22 31 30 23 25 18 26 41

Overall Public Rank Total Research Federal Research Endowment Annual Giving National Academy Members Faculty Awards Doctorates Postdocs Median SAT

*Average among 15 peers. No median SAT listed for University of Arizona.

*

NC State vs. 16 Peers (average)

(all categories have equal weight)

SLIDE 30

NSF Higher Education Research and Development (HERD) Survey

• Purpose: Primary source of information on

R&D expenditures at U.S. colleges and universities

• Population: Institutions that expended at

least $150,000 in separately accounted for R&D in the fiscal year.

• Frequency: Annual

– FY 2016 edition released November 2017

ncsesdata.nsf.gov/herd/2016/

SLIDE 31

NC State FY 2011-16 NSF Higher Education R&D Expenditures By Source of Funds

Rank listed is among Public Institutions

* FY 2011 rankings included all national institutions, all others include public institutions only

FY 2011 Rank: 57* FY 2012 Rank: 44 FY 2013 Rank: 33 FY 2014 Rank: 29 FY 2015 Rank: 30 FY 2016 Rank: 30 All R&D expenditures $378,154 $404,225 $417,468 $446,112 $468,293 $489,918 Federal government $155,293 $174,758 $177,118 $181,449 $199,862 $202,336 State and local government $95,505 $78,766 $76,662 $100,625 $99,165 $95,214 Institution funds $82,621 $101,161 $110,943 $111,905 $115,230 $119,551 Business $40,750 $44,032 $46,415 $49,876 $52,836 $71,018 Nonprofit organizations $3,823 $531 $5,809 $2,088 $1,114 $1,197 All other sources $162 $177 $521 $169 $86 $602 $0 $50,000 $100,000 $150,000 $200,000 $250,000 $300,000 $350,000 $400,000 $450,000 $500,000

R&D Research Expenditure Dollars (in the thousands)

SLIDE 32

Georgia Tech Rank: 15 Rutgers Rank: 18 U of Illinois Rank: 19 Purdue Rank: 22 U of Maryland Rank 24 Virginia Tech Rank: 26 NC State Rank: 30 Colorado State Rank: 45 Iowa State Rank: 47 All R&D expenditures $790,706 $630,212 $625,180 $606,302 $539,388 $521,773 $489,918 $331,862 $328,385 Federal government $568,430 $321,432 $335,056 $229,093 $369,285 $195,859 $202,336 $232,108 $125,397 State and local government $7,491 $85,762 $32,205 $85,626 $17,300 $58,517 $95,214 $17,683 $43,876 Institution funds $152,516 $167,361 $177,548 $191,074 $134,026 $219,322 $119,551 $49,005 $124,116 Business $46,477 $26,151 $39,355 $47,810 $6,345 $40,349 $71,018 $10,464 $23,215 Nonprofit organizations $10,936 $26,551 $22,257 $44,020 $9,376 $3,729 $1,197 $15,053 $8,915 All other sources $4,856 $2,952 $18,759 $8,679 $3,056 $3,997 $602 $7,549 $2,866

$0 $100,000 $200,000 $300,000 $400,000 $500,000 $600,000 $700,000 $800,000

R&D Research Expenditure Dollars (in the thousands)

NSF Higher Education R&D Expenditures at NC State & Peer Institutions without Medical Schools By Source of Funds: FY 2016 Rank listed is among Public Institutions

NC State

SLIDE 33

GLOBAL RANKINGS

SLIDE 34

Comparison of Global Rankings

To help students make informed comparisons of leading universities around the world Judge world class universities across all of their core missions – teaching, research, knowledge transfer and international outlook The initial purpose of ARWU was to find the global standing of top Chinese universities; now recognized for its scientifically sound, stable and transparent methodology To allow students to compare universities around the world based on academic research and reputation

PURPOSE:

• Reputation
• Faculty Productivity

(Bibliometrics)

• Reputation
• Faculty Productivity

(Bibliometrics)

• Faculty Productivity

(Bibliometrics and Awards)

• Faculty Productivity

(Bibliometrics)

• Reputation

DOMINANT: INDICATORS:

SLIDE 35

QS (Quacquarelli Symonds) World University Rankings

• Purpose: To allow students to compare

universities around the world based on academic research and reputation

• Population: Considers over 1,000 universities

based on six performance indicators

• Frequency: Annual

– 2019 edition released June 2018

www.topuniversities.com/qs-world-university-rankings

Academic Reputation 40% Employer Reputation 10% Faculty to Student Ratio 20% Citations Per Faculty 20% International Student Ratio 5% International Faculty Ratio 5%

SLIDE 36

35.7 32 12.7 35.2 47 64.6 38.3

10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Overall Academic Reputation Employer Reputation Faculty to Student Ratio Citations Per Faculty International Faculty Ratio International Student Ratio 2017 2018 2019

QS World University Rankings NC State - Category Scores 2017 to 2019 Editions

40% 10% 20% 20% 5% 5%

SLIDE 37

QS World University Rankings 2019 Edition - Category Scores

40% 10% 20% 20% 5% 5%

NC State vs. 16 Peers (average)

(Column widths represent category weight)

35.7 32 12.7 35.2 47 64.6 38.3 50 56.6 43 38.1 54.3 40.3 39.2

Overall Score Academic Reputation Employer Reputation Faculty to Student Ratio Citations Per Faculty International Faculty Ratio International Student Ratio

SLIDE 38

279 100 200 300 400 500 600

QS World University Rankings 2019 Edition - Overall Rank NC State, 16 Peers and UNC-CH

SLIDE 39

50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 Times Higher Ed ARWU

Times Higher Education (2018 Edition) ARWU (2017 Edition) Overall Ranks NC State, 16 Peers and UNC-CH

Note: Plotted mid-points if rank range was listed for an institution. 251-300 201-300

SLIDE 40

U.S. News and World Report: Best Global University

• Purpose: To allow students to compare

universities around the world based on academic research and reputation

• Population: Top 250 universities in Clarivate

Analytics' global reputation survey and institutions that published the highest number

• f ​articles over 5 years; 1,250 institutions
• Frequency: Annual

– 2018 edition released October 2017

www.usnews.com/education/best-global-universities

Reputation 25% Bibliometric 75%

SLIDE 41

U.S. News: Best Global University

NC State – 2016 v. 2018 Editions

Category Indicator Weight (2018) Source 2016 2018 Global Rank 212 222 Global Score 57.4 56.9 Reputation Global research reputation rank 12.5% Thomson Reuters‘/ Clarivate Analytics‘ Academic Reputation Survey 188 146 Regional research reputation rank 12.5% 57 54 Bibliometric Publications rank 10% From Web of Science for the five-​year period 2018: from 2011 to 2015 2016: from 2009 to 2013 162 170 Books rank 2.5% 175 168 Conferences rank 2.5% 146 140 Normalized citation impact rank 10% 429 505 Total citations rank 7.5% 183 191 Number of publications that are among the 10 percent most cited rank 12.5% 190 177 % of total publications that are among the 10 percent most cited rank 10% 427 419 International collaboration rank 5% - 2016 10% - 2018 571 571 % of total publications with international collaboration rank 5% 782 Number of highly cited papers among top 1% most cited in respective field rank 5% 219 % of total publications that are among the top 1% of most highly cited papers rank 5% 496 School-Level Number of Ph.D.s awarded rank (2016: 5% of total; 2018: N/A) Publically available data sources 184 Number of Ph.D.s awarded per academic staff member rank (2016: 5% of total; 2018: N/A) 182

SLIDE 42

Subject 2016 Global Rank 2018 Global Rank Agricultural Sciences 38 46 Biology and Biochemistry 182 229 Chemistry 116 121 Engineering 121 114 Environment/Ecology 119 96 Materials Science 66 51 Mathematics 55 55 Plant and Animal Sciences 35 31

U.S. News: Best Global University

NC State – 2016 v. 2018 Editions Subject Rankings

SLIDE 43

QUESTIONS?

SLIDE 44

APPENDIX

SLIDE 45

Comparison of Domestic Rankings

U.S. News UG - National Universities U.S. News Graduate Center for Measuring University Performance NSF HERD Purpose/ About

• To help prospective undergraduate

students and their families find the right college

• To help prospective graduate students

find programs

• To improve the performance of

American research universities

• Primary source of information on R&D

expenditures at U.S. colleges and universities Population

• U.S. universities that offer a full ranges
• f UG majors, plus master’s and

doctoral programs, and emphasize faculty research

• Varies by discipline/program
• Only includes U.S. institutions
• U.S. institutions with $40+ million in

annual federal research expenditures

• U.S. institutions that expended at least

$150,000 in separately budgeted R&D in the fiscal year Frequency

• Annual
• Most recent: 2018 edition, released

September 2017

• Annual to every few years, varies by

discipline/program

• Most recent: 2019 edition, released

March 2018

• Annual
• Most recent: 2016 report, released Fall

2017

• Annual
• Most recent: FY 2016 edition, released

November 2017 Indicators

• Academic Reputation
• Retention & Graduation
• Graduation Rate Performance
• Faculty Resources
• Student Selectivity
• Financial Resources
• Alumni Giving
• Varies by discipline/program
• Total Research Expenditures
• Federal Research Expenditures
• Endowment Assets
• Annual Giving
• National Academy Members
• Faculty Awards
• Doctorates Granted
• Postdoctoral Appointees
• SAT Scores
• R&D expenditures by field of research

and source of funds

• Also gathers info on types of research

and expenses and headcounts of R&D personnel Data Sources

• Reputation Surveys
• Common Data Set
• Varies by discipline/program
• NSF Surveys
• IPEDS Surveys
• NACUBO Endowment Study
• CAE VSE Survey
• National Academies directories
• Award-granting orgs listings
• National Science Foundation

SLIDE 46

U.S. News: Undergraduate Rankings - NC State Trends - 2011 to 2018 Editions

SLIDE 47

Weight of Metric Rank Tie School Overall score 30 * UNC-CH 71 34 * Georgia Tech 68 42 *

• U. of Florida

65 46 *

• U. of Wisconsin

64 46 * UC-Davis 64 52 *

• U. of Illinois

63 52 * Penn State 63 54 * Ohio State 62 56 * Purdue 61 61 *

• U. of Maryland

60 69 * Texas A & M 57 69 * Virginia Tech 57 69 * Rutgers 57 81 * Michigan State 54 81 * NCState 54 115 * Iowa State 47 124 * Colorado State 45 124 *

• U. of Arizona

45

U.S. News: UG Rankings NC State, Peers and UNC-CH 2018 Edition

Note: Shading indicates values that are below NC State’s for a given metric 15% 7.5% 4.5% 18% 7.5% Peer Assessment HS Counselor assessment Graduation & retention rank Average .freshman retention Average 6-yr graduation Predicted 6-yr graduation Actual 6-yr graduation Over/ under performance 4 4.5 28 97% 90.25% 89% 90% 1 4.2 4.5

41

97%

83.75%

90% 86%

• 4

3.7 3.9

34

96%

87.25%

83% 87% 4 3.9 4.2

49

93%

84.25%

86% 85%

• 1

4 4

41

95%

83.5%

83% 85% 2 3.9 3.9

47

94%

84.5%

82% 85% 3 3.7 3.9

41

93%

85.75%

65% 86% 21 3.8 4.1

49

94%

83.25%

78% 84% 6 3.8 4.2

92

92%

73.75%

70% 77% 7 3.6 4

38

95%

85.5%

84% 87% 3 3.4 4.0

70

92%

79.25%

71% 80% 9 3.6 4.1

73

91%

83.25%

76% 80% 4 3.5 4.1

49

93%

79.75%

74% 84% 10 3.6 3.8

77

92%

78%

68% 78% 10 3.2 3.5

81

94%

76%

72% 78% 6 3.3 3.5

104

87%

70.5%

68% 74% 6 3.6 3.7

170

81%

66.75%

63% 60%

• 3

3 3.5

133

87%

60.5%

63% 67% 4 8% 1% 1% 7% 3% Faculty resources rank Class Size Indicator Rank Student/ faculty ratio % Full Time Faculty Faculty Compensation Rank Faculty with Terminal Degree 94 186 13/1 92% 52 86% 178 271 20/1 97% 35 81% 89 157 20/1 93% 65 89% 106 263 20/1 89% 27 92% 124 208 18/1 94% 87 91% 83 220 20/1 100% 35 94% 166 271 16/1 96% 35 81% 166 274 19/1 88% 81 98% 74 220 12/1 95% 57 98% 128 176 17/1 88% 119 91% 106 233 13/1 73% 62 99% 184 294 21/1 92% 28 89% 166 278 14/1 96% 65 90% 210 280 17/1 95% 94 90% 138 194 13/1 95% 126 92% 194 281 19/1 94% 77 93% 145 194 22/1 94% 94 89% 128 239 18/1 99% 103 100%

Academic Reputation Graduation and Retention Graduation Rate Performance Faculty Resources

SLIDE 48

Weight of Metric Rank Tie School Overall score 30 * UNC-CH 71 34 * Georgia Tech 68 42 *

• U. of Florida

65 46 *

• U. of Wisconsin

64 46 * UC-Davis 64 52 *

• U. of Illinois

63 52 * Penn State 63 54 * Ohio State 62 56 * Purdue 61 61 *

• U. of Maryland

60 69 * Texas A & M 57 69 * Virginia Tech 57 69 * Rutgers 57 81 * Michigan State 54 81 * NCState 54 115 * Iowa State 47 124 * Colorado State 45 124 *

• U. of Arizona

45

U.S. News: UG Rankings NC State, Peers and UNC-CH 2018 Edition

Note: Shading indicates values that are below NC State’s for a given metric

Student Selectivity Financial Resources Alumni Giving

8.125% 3.125% 1.25% Selectivity rank SAT/ACT 25-75% Freshmen top 10% Acceptance rate 39 1190-1410 73% 27% 22 1320-1500 87% 26% 47 1180-1370 73% 46% 57 1050-1330 100% 42% 52 1234-1420 54% 53% 60 1280-1480 49% 60% 104 1090-1300 36% 56% 52 1160-1410 63% 54% 84 1080-1330 43% 56% 47 1210-1420 71% 48% 96 1110-1350 41% 57% 80 1070-1310 66% 66% 124 1100-1320 40% 71% 110 990-1260 30% 66% 64 1170-1350 50% 46% 140 980-1270 22% 87% 160 970-1220 28% 79% 148 1020-1250 21% 78% 10% 5% Financial resources rank Educational expenditures per student Alumni giving rank Average alumni giving 27 $66,662 51 17% 55 $47,917 26 23.8% 49 $51,996 86 11.6% 61 $46,560 67 13.3% 32 $63,519 162 7.2% 61 $46,803 127 8.4% 52 $49,250 67 13.8% 76 $39,756 63 14.3% 87 $35,636 41 18.7% 87 $36,011 152 7.7% 87 $35,733 47 17.4% 114 $31,143 92 11.2% 76 $39,599 140 8% 103 $33,356 140 8% 97 $35,086 86 11.5% 147 $27,742 79 12.3% 158 $26,473 102 10.5% 87 $36,112 162 7.2%

SLIDE 49

Research Private Support 2014 *** Total Research x $1000 2014 *** Control Rank (Public) 2014 *** Federal Research x $1000 2014 *** Control Rank (Public) 2015 *** Endowment Assets x $1000 2015 *** Control Rank (Public) 2015 *** Annual Giving x $1000 2015 *** Control Rank (Public) 752,836 11 416,177 12 3,633,887 6 359,798 6 598,531 19 336,172 14 1,530,658 21 177,235 19 955,601 6 601,933 3 2,988,806 11 301,177 10 984,830 5 522,251 7 2,792,622 12 330,454 8 652,341 17 279,920 22 1,555,703 20 215,580 14 735,273 12 266,877 25 9,856,983 3 255,179 11 720,248 13 510,422 8 1,858,977 16 119,118 42 502,457 23 227,857 30 2,397,902 14 172,219 22 699,689 16 327,697 16 1,013,936 30 185,840 17 702,912 15 461,896 10 1,854,222 17 155,658 26 575,864 20 286,595 20 767,940 44 190,184 16 472,235 26 328,828 15 482,628 68 122,694 37 627,076 18 355,116 13 710,802 47 127,846 34 492,501 24 247,970 26 2,673,652 13 131,499 31 440,392 27 177,722 44 983,979 32 119,150 41 502,486 22 198,092 37 817,759 41 86,391 60 297,293 48 115,285 57 786,205 43 105,512 49 300,572 47 206,958 33 281,355 99 41,342 92 Institution Public Rank Number of Measures in Top 25 Public Number of Measures in Top 26-50 Public Ohio State 1 9

• U. of Illinois

1 9 UNC-CH 1 9

• U. of Wisconsin

1 9

• U. of Florida

9 8 1 Texas A&M 13 8 Georgia Tech 14 7 1 Purdue 15 6 3 UC-Davis 15 6 3 Penn State 18 6 2

• U. of Arizona

18 6 2

• U. of Maryland

18 6 2 Rutgers 21 5 4 Michigan State 23 4 4 NC State 27 2 7 Virginia Tech 28 2 6 Iowa State 42 6 Colorado State 46 5 Note: Shading indicates values that are below NC State’s for a given metric

Center for Measuring University Performance NC State, Peers and UNC-CH - 2016 Report

SLIDE 50

Faculty Advanced Training Undergraduate 2015 *** Control Academy Members 2015 *** Control Rank (Public) 2015 *** Faculty Awards 2015 *** Control Rank (Public) 2015 *** Doctorates Awarded 2015 *** Control Rank (Public) 2014 *** Postdocs 2014 *** Control Rank (Public) 2014 *** Median SAT 2014 *** Control Rank (Public) 32 16 17 21 832 4 629 15 1300 12 56 9 30 6 829 5 525 17 1300 12 38 15 19 17 519 22 802 8 1320 9 77 7 30 6 857 3 767 9 1280 17 25 26 23 10 754 8 644 13 1265 22 27 22 14 25 740 9 386 25 1195 53 31 18 21 12 526 21 217 51 1400 1 27 22 19 17 717 11 358 28 1205 49 45 11 12 30 553 18 765 10 1205 49 27 22 19 17 673 14 365 27 1190 56 31 18 9 48 528 20 451 20 N/A N/A 26 25 20 14 654 15 437 23 1315 10 39 14 20 14 597 16 345 31 1215 43 13 34 11 33 577 17 450 21 1170 66 20 31 11 33 512 23 473 18 1245 27 13 34 10 40 488 25 226 49 1215 43 8 47 6 66 336 42 331 32 1150 80 9 41 11 33 251 59 297 37 1130 98 Institution Public Rank Number of Measures in Top 25 Public Number of Measures in Top 26-50 Public Ohio State 1 9

• U. of Illinois

1 9 UNC-CH 1 9

• U. of Wisconsin

1 9

• U. of Florida

9 8 1 Texas A&M 13 8 Georgia Tech 14 7 1 Purdue 15 6 3 UC-Davis 15 6 3 Penn State 18 6 2

• U. of Arizona

18 6 2

• U. of Maryland

18 6 2 Rutgers 21 5 4 Michigan State 23 4 4 NC State 27 2 7 Virginia Tech 28 2 6 Iowa State 42 6 Colorado State 46 5 Note: Shading indicates values that are below NC State’s for a given metric

Center for Measuring University Performance NC State, Peers and UNC-CH - 2016 Report

SLIDE 51

Comparison of Global Rankings

QS (Quacquarelli Symonds) THE (Times Higher Education) Academic Ranking of World Universities (ARWU/Shanghai Rankings) U.S. News Global Purpose/ About

• To help students make informed

comparisons of leading universities around the world

• Judge world class universities across all of

their core missions – teaching, research, knowledge transfer and international outlook

• From the Center for World-Class

Universities at Shanghai Jiao Tong University; the initial purpose of ARWU was to find the global standing of top Chinese universities

• To allow students to compare

universities around the world based on academic research and reputation Population

• Highlights move than 1,000

universities based on six performance indicators

• Research-intensive universities that also

teach undergraduates; for 2018, must have a research output of at least 1,000 articles between 2012 and 2016; 1,000 universities ranked

• More than 1300 universities are ranked

by ARWU every year and the best 500 are individually ranked

• Top 250 universities in Clarivate

Analytics' global reputation survey

• AND institutions that published the

highest number of ​articles over last 5 years Frequency

• Annual
• Most recent: 2019 edition released

June 2018

• Annual
• Most recent: 2018 edition released September

2017

• Annual
• Most recent: 2017 edition, released

February 2018

• Annual
• Most recent: 2018 edition, released

October 2017 Indicators

• Academic Reputation 40%
• Employer Reputation 10%
• Faculty to Student Ratio 20%
• Citations Per Faculty 20%
• International Faculty Ratio 5%
• International Student Ratio 5%
• Teaching (the learning environment) 30%
• Research (volume, income & reputation) 30%
• Citations (research influence) 30%
• Int’l outlook (staff, students & research) 7.5%
• Industry income (knowledge transfer) 2.5%
• Quality of education (alumni who won

Nobel and Fields Medals) 10%

• Quality of faculty (Nobel and Fields

Medal winners, highly-cited researchers) 40%

• Research output (citations, papers

published in high-impact journals) 40%

• Per capita academic performance 10%
• Global Research Reputation 12.5%
• Regional Research Reputation 12.5%
• Bibliometics (publications, books,

conferences, citations, international collaboration) 75% Data Sources

• Surveys
• Scopus
• Institutions provide and sign off their

institutional data for use in the rankings

• Multiple, including highlycited.com

(Thompson Reuters) and Web of Science

• Surveys
• Web of Science

SLIDE 52

QS World University Rankings

NC State: 2017 to 2019 Editions

Indicator Weight 2017 2018 2019 Score Rank Score Rank Score Rank Overall Score and Rank 38 277 40.3 263 35.7 279 Academic Reputation 40% 36.2 279 41.3 250 32 254 Employer Reputation 10% 30.2 401+ 21.5 401+ 12.7 501+ Faculty Student 20% 29.1 436 36 361 35.2 432 Citations 20% 50.1 228 46.7 264 47 265 International Faculty 5% 40.1 343 60.8 261 64.6 265 International Students 5% 51.8 294 40 355 38.3 362

SLIDE 53

Peers - Overall Rank 2012 2014* 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019**

• U. of Wisconsin

38 37 41 54 53 55 53 Georgia Tech 88 99 107 84 71 70 69

• U. of Illinois

56 56 63 59 66 69 71 UNC-CH 57 54 62 79 78 80 83 Ohio State 105 113 109 99 88 86 89 Penn State 101 107 112 101 95 93 95 UC-Davis 100 85 95 85 85 118 100 Purdue 95 99 102 89 92 105 100

• U. of Maryland

117 116 122 126 131 129 126 Michigan State 174 171 195 164 160 149 141

• U. of Florida

169 179 192 180 185 178 180 Texas A&M 165 153 165 159 160 195 203

• U. of Arizona

183 212 215 216 233 230 246 NC State 291 304 388 309 277 263 279 Rutgers 260 255 279 269 301 283 283 Virginia Tech 337 316 355 338 361 367 338 Colorado State 365 394 441+ 411+ 386 481+ 450 Iowa State 319 321 348 355 421+ 471+ 489

* No rankings given for 2013 ** Table ordered by 2019 rankings

QS World University Rankings

NC State, Peers and UNC-CH: 2012 to 2019 Editions

SLIDE 54

Times Higher Education NC State, Peers and UNC-CH 2018 Edition

Institution 2017 World Rank Tie 2017 USA Rank Tie 2017 Score

• U. of Wisconsin

28 21 39.7 UNC-CH 33 23 36.9

• U. of Illinois

37 26 36.2

• U. of Maryland

53 32 31.8 Purdue 77 38 28 Rutgers 79 39 27.8 Ohio State 80 Y 40 Y 27.7 Georgia Tech 85 Y 43 Y 27.1 Penn State 85 Y 43 Y 27.1 UC-Davis 85 Y 43 Y 27.1

• U. of Florida

88 Y 46 27

• U. of Arizona

99 Y 48 25.9 Michigan State 101-150 Y 49-60 Y

• Texas A&M

101-150 Y 49-60 Y

• Colorado State

201-300 Y 71-99 Y

• Iowa State

201-300 Y 71-99 Y

• NC State

201-300 Y 71-99 Y

• Virginia Tech

301-400 Y 100-119 Y

• Institution

2018 Rank Tie Georgia Tech 33

• U. of Illinois

37

• U. of Wisconsin

43 UC-Davis 54 Y UNC-CH 56 Y Purdue 60

• U. of Maryland

69 Ohio State 70 Y Penn State 77 Michigan State 83 Y

• U. of Florida

143 Y Texas A&M 159 Y

• U. of Arizona

161 Rutgers 172 NC State 251-300 Y Iowa State 301-350 Y Virginia Tech 301-350 Y Colorado State 351-400 Y

Academic Ranking of World Universities NC State, Peers and UNC-CH 2017 Edition

SLIDE 55

U.S. News: Best Global University - NC State, Peers and UNC-CH - 2018 Edition

Weight of Metric Global Rank School Global score 31

• U. of Wisconsin

74.9 34 UNC-CH 74.5 46 Ohio State 72.6 50

• U. of Maryland

71.8 51

• U. of Illinois

71.6 52 UC-Davis 71.5 66 Penn State 70.2 71 Georgia Tech 69.4 77

• U. of Arizona

68.7 81 Michigan State 67.5 95

• U. of Florida

66.3 97 Rutgers 66.2 102 Purdue 63.8 118 Texas A & M 66.9 204 Iowa State 57.6 222 NC State 56.9 250 Colorado State 54.7 250 Virginia Tech 54.7 12.5% 12.5% 10% 2.5% 2.5% 10% Global research reputation rank Regional research reputation rank Publications rank Books rank Conferences rank Normalized citation impact rank 28 17 35 32 167 107 41 23 51 84 419 62 53 28 36 52 110 137 83 43 92 54 95 75 23 19 68 78 45 191 55 41 43 65 214 163 39 26 45 47 71 251 34 25 150 139 15 220 87 39 103 66 158 149 69 37 108 97 163 149 88 47 41 41 156 384 85 40 84 33 220 237 46 34 98 92 32 337 75 46 94 100 74 414 178 68 215 224 238 369 146 54 170 168 140 505 230 71 281 254 411 401 138 58 204 224 84 525 7.5% 12.5% 10% 5%

5%

5% 5%

Total citations rank # of publications among the 10% most cited rank % of publications among the 10% most cited rank International collaboration rank

% of total publications w/ international collaboration rank

Number of highly cited papers among top 1% most cited rank % of total publications that are among the top 1% rank

28 28 104 443 748 31 140 34 31 45 777 843 26 57 33 32 119 372 727 34 193 70 70 74 90 535 65 89 68 62 132 232 662 75 253 38 38 133 141 592 45 198 50 49 204 313 706 64 291 133 112 105 119 573 112 121 91 90 143 89 534 83 159 95 94 160 222 657 114 264 54 57 376 215 650 62 310 87 84 220 258 677 97 269 106 101 277 282 689 129 382 111 109 391 121 577 139 450 204 211 365 195 636 207 338 191 177 419 571 782 219 496 268 257 338 448 794 297 630 233 228 474 611 749 234 272 Note: Shading indicates values that are below NC State’s for a given metric