VACANT UNIT PROPERTY TAX REBATE CONSULTATION J UNE 22, 2017 Vacant - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate

VACANT UNIT PROPERTY TAX REBATE CONSULTATION

JUNE 22, 2017

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

• 1. Welcome
• 2. Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Program
• 3. Provincial Amendments
• 4. Current Program Challenges And Considerations
• 5. Program Costs
• 6. Future Program Options
• 7. Next Steps

Slide 2

AGENDA

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

• The City of Vaughan, the City of Markham and the Town of Richmond Hill are considering the merits
• f the Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Program
• We are soliciting feedback from commercial, industrial and residential property owners
• There are two ways for you to provide feedback on these proposed changes:

A. Public Consultation Meetings: 1. City of Vaughan - June 22, 2017 from 7pm – 9pm, City Hall, Multi-Purpose Room, 1st floor 2. City of Markham - June 26, 2017 from 7pm to 9pm, Markham Civic Centre, Council Chambers 3. Town of Richmond Hill - July 13 from 7pm to 9pm, Rouge Woods Community Centre, Aspen Room B. Online Survey: June 5, 2017 – July 31, 2017

Slide 3

• 1. Welcome

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 4

• Introduced in 2001, the Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Program provides property

tax relief to owners of vacant commercial and industrial buildings

• Lower-tier municipalities are mandated to have a program to provide tax rebates to
• wners of commercial or industrial property that have vacant portions.
• Property owners may apply to the municipality for a tax rebate for periods of vacancy.
• For commercial or industrial buildings to be eligible, the property or a portion of

property must be vacant for a period of at least ninety (90) consecutive days

• Applications are also required to meet specific municipal evidentiary requirements

that must be satisfied for the owner to be entitled to the rebate.

• The current rebate percentage amount for vacant commercial space is 30% and vacant

industrial space is 35%

• 2. Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Program Overview

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 5

• In 2016, the Province, in consultation with municipal and business stakeholders,

undertook a review of the vacant unit property tax rebate program.

• The review was initiated in response to municipal concerns of any unintended

implications this may have for local economies.

• On November 14, 2016, the Province released its Fall Economic Statement which

provided municipalities with broader flexibility to tailor the Vacant Unit Rebate program to reflect community needs and circumstances.

• Staff report(s) for local municipal Council(s) consideration were tabled as follows;
• The City of Vaughan staff report on March 21, 2017
• The City of Markham staff report on February 21, 2017
• The Town of Richmond Hill staff report on May 1, 2017

Local Municipal Council(s) directed staff to report back in the fall of 2017 with the feedback received from the consultation meetings

• 3. Provincial Amendments

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 6

• 4. Current Program Challenges And Considerations
• Vacancy allowance, chronic vacancy and/or reduced income due to vacant space are

factors considered and adjusted for when establishing the individual property assessments for the property as established by Municipal Property Assessment Corporation (MPAC)

• When a vacancy rebate is granted, on top of the CVA considerations provided for

with the property assessment, this can be viewed as “double-dipping”

• The 90 day continuous vacancy requirement can discourage landlords from seeking

and/or accepting short-term, pop-up and/or seasonal rentals

• This is a business benefit that is largely subsidized by the residential class
• This is not a benefit which is afforded to other property classes which may experience

a form of vacancy from time-to-time, such as residential or multi-residential properties

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 7

Average Five-year Program Cost (2011 – 2015)

• 5. Program Cost

Municipality Municipal Share of Program Cost Regional Share of Program Cost Provincial Share of Program Cost Total Program Cost Vaughan $309,000 $551,000 $1,237,000 $2,097,000 Markham $216,433 $426,244 $960,351 $1,603,028 Richmond Hill $124,206 $220,048 $494,186 $838,439 Total $649,639 $1,197,292 $2,691,537 $4,538,467

• The costs above do not include administrative costs associated the Vacant Unit

Property Tax Rebate Program

• The administrative costs are equivalent to approximately 1/3 of a full time

employee (FTE)

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 8

• The City of Vaughan, the City of Markham and the Town of Richmond Hill are

considering the merits of the Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Program

• We are soliciting feedback from commercial, industrial and residential property owners
• n possible changes to the program

Options a. Status Quo Program b. Phase-out Program (1 – 3 years) c. Targeted Program “New Office Development” (3 – 5 years) d. Class Funded Program e. Eliminate Program

• 6. Future Program Options

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 9

(a). Status Quo Program

• No change to the existing program
• Property owners would still be entitled to apply for a:
• 30% rebate for eligible vacant space within commercial buildings, and
• 35% rebate for eligible vacant space within industrial buildings
• 6. Future Program Options

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 10

• 6. Future Program Options

Example Application Year Tax Year Rebate Percentage

(Com / Ind)

Year 1 2017 2018 30% / 35% Year 2 2018 2019 20% / 25% Year 3 2019 2020 10% / 15% Year 4 2020 2021 0% (exit program) (b). Phase-out Program (1 – 3 years)

• Program would be phased-out over three years with a declining benefit each year
• Program would not be offered in the fourth year and beyond

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 11

(c). Targeted Program “New Office Development”

• Maintain a targeted program for New Office Development only
• Eligible new office developments would be entitled for a define 3 - 5 year period
• 6. Future Program Options

Example Application Year Tax Year Rebate Percentage 1 2017 2018 30% 2 2018 2019 30% 3 2019 2020 30% 4 2020 2021 30% 5 2021 2022 30% 6 2022 2023 0% (exit program)

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 12

(d). Class Funded Program

• All costs of the program, as well as the rebates, will be borne by the commercial and

industrial classes alone

• Realigning cost of the program so that the residential class and multi-residential

classes are no longer burden

• The funding methodology of this option would need to be developed with both the

Region and Province

• 6. FUTURE PROGRAM OPTIONS

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 13

(e). Elimination of the Current Program

• This option would conclude the Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Program
• No program offering for 2018 application year and beyond
• 6. FUTURE PROGRAM OPTIONS

Application Year Tax Year Rebate Available 2017 2018 Yes 2018 2019 No (exit program) 2019 2020 No

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 14

• 7. NEXT STEPS
• Analysis of all feedback from in-person consultations and online survey
• Staff will summarize feedback into themes and report back to respective local municipal

Council(s) in the fall of 2017

• Each local municipal Council will formalize a recommendation that will be forwarded to

the Region of York which will aid the development of a recommendation expected to be presented to Region Council in Q4 2017.

• If Regional Council approves any changes to the vacant unit property tax rebate

program, a resolution will be sent to the Minister of Finance, indicating that the Region

• f York in consultation and agreement with its lower-tier municipalities wish to;
• “Modify” vacant unit property tax rebate program; or,
• “Eliminate” the vacant unit property tax rebate program

Vacant Unit Property Tax Rebate Consultation

Slide 15

 We also encourage you to provide further input by completing the on-line survey at:

• Vaughan.ca
• Markham.ca
• RichmondHill.ca

THANK YOU