EDGARS
UNAUDITED CONSOLIDATED RESULTS
Q4 AND FULL YEAR 2017
25 MAY 2017
UNAUDITED CONSOLIDATED RESULTS Q4 AND FULL YEAR 2017 25 MAY 2017 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
UNAUDITED CONSOLIDATED RESULTS Q4 AND FULL YEAR 2017 25 MAY 2017 EDGARS 0 AGENDA 1. YEAR IN REVIEW 2. MACRO ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT 3. FINANCIAL REVIEW FY17 4. STRATEGY AND TURNAROUND INITIATIVES 5. WAY FORWARD 1 1. YEAR IN REVIEW
EDGARS
25 MAY 2017
1
2
BERNIE BROOKES - CEO
3
significantly reduced
reduced cash interest of ~ R600 million and gross debt of ~ R7 billion
annually, declining consumer confidence and almost no GDP growth
decreased by 2.4% while credit retail sales decreased 13.4%
R1,383 million
EDGARS
4
service being provided
year, has shown improved trends increasing by over 25%, and for the first time since 2010, credit sales in Jet have increased
JET
5
2.5 3.7 3.1 2.6 3.4 4.2
FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16 Gross finance cost, R billion
To fix this we need new owners and reduce our debt
ISSUE 1: HIGH DEBT PAYMENTS ISSUE 2: DECLINING TRADING PROFIT
1.9 1.9 1.4 1.3 1.2 1.0
FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16 Trading profit, R billion
Less debt won’t help with this we need to turn around performance
6
SUBSTANTIAL NEW MONEY INJECTION
Group’s liquidity position
MATERIAL DELEVERAGING OF THE OPERATING COMPANY
reinstated claims to a holding company
holding company
from 18.9x REDUCTION OF CASH INTEREST BURDEN
instruments
to 3.9x from 0.6x EXTENSION OF MATURITIES
2022
(1) Raised at Edcon Limited (2) Raised at New Holdco 1 (3) The Super Senior Liquidity Facility will mature in December 2017, with a one year extension
7
FX rates as at 25 March 2017: R12:48:$ and R13.45:€
1 R575m was undrawn at 25 March 2017 2 The maturity may be extended to 31 December 2019 in exchange for a cash margin uplift and provided certain refinancing conditions are satisfied
DRAWN AMOUNT (ZARm) GROSS LEVERAGE CURRENCY MATURITY BASE RATES MARGIN PIK MARGIN
Super Senior Credit Facility (Converted RCF Facility)1 1,250 0.9x ZAR 31 Dec 19
JIBAR
5.0% 3.0% Super Senior Credit Facility (Term) 2,116 1.5x ZAR 31 Dec 19
JIBAR
5.0% 3.0% Super Senior Liquidity Facility A1 576 0.4x EUR 31 Dec 17
EURIBOR
4.0% 8.0% Super Senior Liquidity Facility A22 1,779 1.3x EUR 31 Dec 17
EURIBOR
4.0% 8.0%
First ranking debt 5,721 4.1x
Capital leases 305 0.2x ZAR Other debt 205 0.1x
Total third party debt 6,231 4.5x PROFORMA ADJUSTED EBITDA 1,383
8
Note: Data excludes Legit and Zimbabwe
FY16A FY15A FY14A FY10A FY11A FY13A FY08A FY12A FY09A EBITDA, R’m 2 710 2 850 2 364 3 072 2 545 1 477 1 265 1 182 3,432
9
potential asset for sale in strategic review
range of potential trade and financial purchasers
liquidity position and intensifies focus on core department stores and value chain offerings
R637 million cash
sale
concern basis
holding company: ~200 stores across SA, Namibia, Botswana, Zambia
shareholder Metier Private Equity: ~R6 billion funds under management
Canoe, Style
Purchase consideration of R637m, sale effective 29 January 2017
Deal overview Purchaser details Transaction mechanics
10
11
NOV 15 APR 17 NOV 15 APRIL 17
+44 pts +39 pts
12
drive efficiency
processes for goods not for resale (GNFR), providing a lower cost plus a simpler and well governed strategy
with no defined property strategy: leverage existing space to enhance productivity and returns
excess use of agents and brokers; focus on local sourcing
challenges
focus on “transaction”, “efficiency” and “checklists” to focus on customer experience and reward (loyalty, NPS, aligned incentives)
to buy”, less reliance on and better planning of promotion, control of markdown, “SKU” rationalisation, focus on entry price points and decluttering of merchandising & marketing
with 3x the productivity of international brands – better fit, exclusive, less impacted by ZAR devaluation
brands – onerous contracts, capex hungry, high price perception, not “season” friendly; R64m loss in FY16
13
CUSTOMER CENTRICITY SIMPLICITY PEOPLE EMPOWERMENT
proposition per segment
follow-up
from customer feedback
review
structure, accountabilities)
14
2016 2017
OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP
GROWTH ENABLERS COST
LEAN HQ & OPERATING MODEL GNFR COGS REDUCTION PROPERTY EDGARS CHAIN: TURNAROUND/CUSTOMER CENTRICITY JET CHAIN: LEAN DISCOUNT RE-POSITIONING SPECIALTY CHAINS: STRATEGY REVIEW AND REFRESH CREDIT SALES LOYALTY PROGRAM CUSTOMER CENTRICITY IT STRATEGY AND RENEWAL PLAN SUPPLY CHAIN & LOGISTICS ROADMAP SUPPLIER ENGAGEMENT INVENTORY
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
EDGARS
15
GARETH PENNY Non-executive Chairman BERNIE BROOKES Chief Executive Officer RHIDWAAN GASANT Non-executive Director DAPHNE MOTSEPE Non-executive Director GRANT PATTISON Non-executive Director KEITH WARBURTON Non-executive Director MARTI P MURRAY Non-executive Director
16
RICHARD VAUGHAN - CFO
17 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
(1)
2 3
06-2014 08-2014 10-2014 12-2014 02-2015 04-2015 06-2015 08-2015 10-2015 12-2015 02-2016 04-2016 06-2016 08-2016 10-2016 12-2016
Real GDP (y-o-y %) Unemployment rate (%)
GDP GROWTH AND UNEMPLOYMENT RATE
4 5 6 7 8 9 03-2016 04-2016 05-2016 06-2016 07-2016 08-2016 09-2016 10-2016 11-2016 12-2016 01-2017 02-2017 03-2017
4 5.5 7 8.5 10 11.5
12-2014 02-2015 04-2015 06-2015 08-2015 10-2015 12-2015 02-2016 04-2016 06-2016 08-2016 10-2016 12-2016 02-2017 04-2017
EXCHANGE RATES PRIVATE SECTOR CREDIT EXTENSION (Y-O-Y %) REPO AND PRIME RATE EXCHANGE RATES
04-2016 05-2016 06-2016 07-2016 08-2016 09-2016 10-2016 11-2016 12-2016
USDZAR EURZAR
Source: SARB & StatsSA
18
4.0% 4.5% 5.0% 5.5% 6.0% 6.5% 7.0% Q2:2015 Q3:2015 Q4:2015 Q1:2016 Q2:2016 Q3:2016 Q4:2016 Q1:2017 Q2:2017 Q3:2017 Q4:2017
INFLATION
Q1:2015 Q2:2015 Q3:2015 Q4:2015 Q1:2016 Q2:2016 Q3:2016 Q4:2016 Q1:2017
0% 5% 10% 15% 06-2015 07-2015 08-2015 09-2015 10-2015 11-2015 12-2015 01-2016 02-2016 03-2016 04-2016 05-2016 06-2016 07-2016 08-2016 09-2016 10-2016 11-2016 Retail trade sales Textiles,footwear and leather goods 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 12-2014 02-2015 04-2015 06-2015 08-2015 10-2015 12-2015 02-2016 04-2016 06-2016 08-2016 10-2016 12-2016
FNB/BER CONSUMER CONFIDENCE INDEX RETAIL SALES
HOUSEHOLD DEBT TO GROSS DISPOSABLE INCOME RATIO
Source: SARB & StatsSA
19
RICHARD VAUGHAN - CFO
20
Underlying consumer demand weak on back of subdued growth in consumers disposable income, tight credit conditions, low consumer confidence, more restrictive fiscal policy and increased competition Deliberate competitive entry price points, clearance of aged inventory, aggressive markdowns and higher input costs in the first half of FY17 Transaction with creditors finalised, balance sheet post 1 February 2017 no longer laden with debt, new ownership and Group, appointment of new Board and sale of Legit business (excl. Botswana) effective 29 January 2017
SALES PROFITS STRATEGY
Q4:FY17 FY17 Retail sales ↓ 10.6% ↓ 6.7% Cash sales ↓ 9.7% ↓ 2.4% Credit sales ↓ 12.3% ↓ 13.4% LFL sales ↓ 9.9% ↓ 6.7% Q4:FY17 FY17 Gross profit ↑ 0.4% ↓ 2.3% Proforma adjusted EBITDA ↓ 45.0%
21
decreased 14.6%
entry price points
rebates
closed
Q4:FY17 FY17 Retail sales growth (%) (9.4) (6.7) LFL sales growth (%) (10.7) (6.6) GP margin (%) 43.0 41.2 Total number of stores 212 212 Capex spend (R’m)* (9) 87 Av space (‘000sqm) 731 728
212 stores* · LSM 6-10
*Includes 1 Edgars sales store and 1 Edgars Emporium store *Landlord contributions received in Q4:FY17 net of capital expenditure.
22
increased by 0.8%
remaining categories still negative
rebates received
stores
Q4:FY17 FY17 Retail sales growth (%) (5.8) (6.3) LFL sales growth (%) (4.9) (5.7) GP margin (%) 33.5 32.4 Total number of stores 515 515 Capex spend (R’m)* (16) 70 Av space (‘000sqm) 580 582
392 stores · LSM 4-7 123 stores · LSM 4-7
*Landlord contributions received in Q4:FY17 net of capital expenditure.
23
decreased 11.1%
childrenswear and stationery
by R114 million
particularly in Boardmans, CNA and monobrands
mono-branded store
Q4:FY17 FY17 Retail sales growth (%) (15.1) (6.0) LFL sales growth (%) (11.2) (7.5) GP margin (%) 33.8 33.3 Total number of stores 565 565 Capex spend (R’m)* (8) 43 Av space (‘000sqm) 235 253
MONO-BRANDED STORES 182 stores · LSM 4-7 40 stores · LSM 7-10 196* stores · LSM 7-10 49 stores · LSM 5-10 88 stores · LSM 5-10
*Includes 11 Samsung stores
10* stores · LSM 5-8
*Remaining stores in Botswana sold effective April 2017
*Landlord contributions received in Q4:FY17 net of capital expenditure.
24
(R millions) FY17 FY16 % change Retail sales 25 343 27 147 (6.7) Gross profit 9 243 10 521 (12.2)
Gross profit margin
36.5 38.8 (2.3)pts
Other income
1 762 1 921 (8.3)
Store costs
(6 826) (6 463) 5.6
Other operating costs(1)
(4 736) (5 212) (9.1)
Share of profits of associates and insurance business
184 Trading profit (373) 767 (148.6) PROFORMA ADJUSTED EBITDA 1 383 2 514 (45.0)
(1) Includes non-recurring costs of R545 million in FY17 (FY16 – R598 million). See cost analysis – FY17
25
(R millions)
FY17 FY16 % change
Trading (loss)/ profit (373) 767 (148.6) Depreciation & amortisation 951 1 004 Net asset write off(1) 68 19 Gains on sales of written down trade receivables(2) (29) EBITDA losses from brands exited(3) 73 25 EBITDA losses/(gains) from Edgars Shoe Gallery(4) 4
(100) (142) Rand depreciation adjustment(6) 52 Non-recurring costs(7) 545 598 Adjusted EBITDA 1 168 2 294 (49.1) Brand and administration fee income from insurance business(8) Share of profits from insurance business(8) (385) (505) 600 725 PRO FORMA ADJUSTED EBITDA 1 383 2 514 (45.0)
(1) Relates to assets written off in connection with the closure of stores, net of relates proceeds where applicable. (2) Relates to gains realised on the sale of a portfolio of written down trade receivables. (3) Adjustment to remove the EBITDA gains or losses achieved from certain brands being exited such as: Express, Geox, Lucky Brand, One Green Elephant, River Island, Tom Taylor and other international brands which the Group has strategically committed to exit. (4) Adjustment to remove the EBITDA losses or gains from the Edgars Shoe Gallery retail format which the Specialty division strategically exited during fiscal 2017. (5) Adjustment to remove the EBITDA gains relating to the Legit business sold on 29 January 2017. (6) Foreign exchange gains recognised below the trading profit line which hedged the exposure in cost of sales as a result of the significant devaluation of the Rand. (7) Non-recurring costs in FY2017 related to a credit from employee restructure costs of R16 million, onerous lease charges of R223 million, a R1 million credit for the post-retirement medical aid buy-out, unrecovered costs of R8 million as a result of flood and storm damage during FY2017, R7 million brand penalty cost, a R42 million credit which reverses a penalty provision raised in FY2016, R28 million non-recurring cost incurred in respect of our agreement with Absa, R215 million transitional project related expenditure, R117 million strategic initiative costs which excludes costs incurred from the transaction with creditors and the Restructuring and R6 million of other non-recurring costs. Non-recurring costs in FY2016 related to employee restructure costs of R72 million, onerous lease charges of R123 million and R1 million lease cancellation cost, post-retirement medical aid buyout of R26 million, once-off lease adjustment of R33 million, penalty costs of R57 million, transitional project related expenditure of R70 million and strategic initiative costs of R216 million. (8) The investment in HBA prior to the Restructuring was held by Edcon Holdings Limited which was a related party company of Edcon Acquisition Proprietary Limited and the profits from the insurance business were previously consolidated by Edcon Holdings Limited. Previously Edcon Limited received a brand and administration fee from the insurance business arrangement. On 31 January 2017, in connection with the Restructuring, Edcon Holdings Limited sold its investment in HBA to Edcon Acquisition Proprietary Limited and such investment was consolidated from that date. Pro forma adjusted EBITDA is intended to show adjusted EBITDA as if Edcon Acquisition Proprietary Limited Group had always consolidated the share of profits from the insurance business instead of Edcon Holdings Limited.
26
OTHER OPERATING COSTS STORE COSTS
9.2%
restructure
the back of a reduction in proforma adjusted EBITDA
savings on outsource to strategic partner
decreased in FY17 due to improved stock control, store cost savings and renegotiated contracts
for FY17 (62.0% in FY16).
(R millions) FY17 FY16 % change
Other operating costs (excl.
non-recurring costs)
4 191 4 614 (9.2) Non-recurring costs 545 598 TOTAL 4 736 5 212 (9.1)
27
(394) (569) (35) 2 686 (943) 2 371 (561) 1 693
Working Capital
Trade receivables,
prepayments Inter group proceeds
585 (126)
Trade and
payables
OPENING CASH BALANCE OPERATING ACTIVITIES(A) FINANCING ACTIVITIES TAX CAPEX WORKING CAPITAL CLOSING CASH BALANCE (C) NET FINANCING COSTS (B)
R’m
106 (70) (673)
Inventories
243
(a) Includes R1 032 million outflow relating to transaction with creditors and Restructuring (b) Includes R8 million inflow for currency translation on cash balances
SALE LEGIT
(c) Incudes R584 million from the sale of Legit. This cash is held in Escrow following the Restructuring and will be released in July 2017
28
BERNIE BROOKES - CEO
29
2016 2017
INITIATIVE STATUS UPDATE
OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP
GROWTH ENABLERS COST LEAN HQ & OPERATING MODEL GNFR COGS REDUCTION PROPERTY EDGARS CHAIN: TURNAROUND/CUSTOMER CENTRICITY JET CHAIN: LEAN DISCOUNT RE-POSITIONING SPECIALTY CHAINS: STRATEGY REVIEW AND REFRESH CREDIT SALES LOYALTY PROGRAM CUSTOMER CENTRICITY IT STRATEGY AND RENEWAL PLAN SUPPLY CHAIN & LOGISTICS ROADMAP SUPPLIER ENGAGEMENT INVENTORY
Savings realized and locked in Savings being realized Savings being realized Savings being realized Initiatives underway – customer experience, category management, change management Initiatives underway – In-store experience, every day low price & cost savings Legit sale complete Portfolio strategy review underway Own book sales picking up ( over R400m) Strategy developed and initial value target identified NPS roll-out underway Strategy and roadmap complete. RFP’s launched Strategy and roadmap complete. Roll-out underway Review underway Review underway
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
30
EDGARS BRAND BUILDING
CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE
CATEGORY MANAGEMENT
CREDIT & FINANCIAL SERVICES
CHANGE MANAGEMENT
31
44 49 81 88
+5 pts
+7 pts
PROMOTERS DETRACTORS NPS
32
SALES GROWTH
improvements in sales and GP growth vs. Chain being realised
(Mens Formal, Maternity and Home Softs)
GP IMPROVEMENT
expansion of Food into most SA JetMarts
price items and key entry price points (strong deals planned for the quarter)
CREDIT & FINANCIAL SERVICES
COST SAVINGS
capturing synergies with Credit & Financial Services
PEOPLE
empowers employees to deliver on business results
Leadership Academy to improve leadership and functional competencies to deliver on business results
33
and FMCG
world: learning, relaxing, creating, giving”
authority
consumer frequency of visit
customer satisfaction
Key principle of Specialty strategy is to refocus the brands on core business to deliver a quality product with a clear message to a targeted customer segment
34
Active athleisure wear brand identity – Life is my Sport
CELLULAR
proposition of great deals to market
deliver exceptional customer service at all times
INTERNATIONAL BRANDS
continue to be available via their website)
that deliver brand equity, aspirational product & customer experience while strengthening and enhancing the fashion credibility of the Edgars brand
Key principle of Specialty strategy is to refocus the brands on core business to deliver a quality product with a clear message to a targeted customer segment
35
BUYING
towards SBT/SOR, review negotiation strategies
where possible PLANNING
core ranges)
MARKETING
STORE PORTFOLIO
STORE OPERATIONS
ONLINE
B2B
CNA
36
SHIFTS & SAVINGS
Summer 2017
6%
LOCAL/REGIONAL FOCUS
Africa, with a share remaining consistent at 85%
greater Durban region with capacity management, on time deliveries & improve product capabilities
cotton sector through the entire supply chain
CELROSE & EDDELS
37
EFFICIENT LOGISTICS
times, stock losses & improve Data Integrity
MINIMAL STOCK ROOM PROCESSING
IMPROVED ALLOCATION
based on sales
38
the 5 year IT transformation
business strategy
SUMMARY
CREDITOR PLAN
COMMITMENTS
OBJECTIVES PROGRESS AGAINST
COMMITMENTS
IT ROADMAP DEVELOPED
business cases in the process of being finalised
negotiations and vendor contract finalisation coming to a close end May/early June 2017
(1.5% of sales vs. 2.9%)
line with industry benchmark for in-source / out-source
3 year timeline for primary project delivery, starting with systems implementation mid-2017 after completion of vendor contracting period
39
INFRASTRUCTURE
INTEGRATION
POS
40
MERCHANDISE AND PLANNING
well as providing a better platform for divesting and acquisitions
FINANCE BUSINESS INTELLIGENCE
change and competition
41
EFFICIENT LOGISTICS
times, stock losses & improve Data Integrity
MINIMAL STOCK ROOM PROCESSING
IMPROVED ALLOCATION
based on sales
42
AGED STOCKS 0-2 MONTHS +2.4% UP ON LAST YEAR
Edgars Accessories, Cellular, Cosmetics and Studio Q AGED STOCK 3-6 MONTHS
ladies wear, Edgars Active
Cellular AGED STOCK >7 MONTHS
Edgars Footwear, Edgars Kids
Active wear in Edgars, Edgars Active, Cosmetics and Studio Q
43
CREDIT PORTFOLIO
2016 Edcon acquire ~80% of new accounts on balance sheet resulting in more control over new business credit sales with positive early signs
enhance customer experience when opening new accounts and applying for credit limit increases
FINANCIAL SERVICES PRODUCTS
future growth prospects
COMMERCIAL SALES GROWTH
sales
44
Reintroduce auto credit limit increases (ACLI) Introduce new account shadow limits Revise collections and recoveries strategies Implement new provision models Implement portfolio specific profit models Realign core insurance business Redesign new application process Redesign offered credit limit increase process (CLI) Automate gift card process Introduce Corporate accounts Redesign insurance claims process
a b c d e f g h i j k TACTICAL INITIATIVES STRATEGIC INITIATIVES
45
customers (back book) and new customers (flow). Absa’s conservative lending practices have predominantly been felt with respect to the flow as Absa has been unwilling to lend to higher risk customers and in general has made lower limits available to all new customers.
responsible for lending to the medium to high risk customers, whilst Absa will continue to lend to the low risk customers. Absa has agreed to almost double the limits it makes available to these low risk customers.
book (existing customers). Absa is happy to provide reasonable limits to these customers as they have seasoned and therefore their risk profile is well understood.
46
BERNIE BROOKES - CEO
47
completed, focus now shifted to business operations
the Edcon strategy: Customer Centricity, Empowerment and Simplicity
month of new trading year, April FY18 saw a growth in EBITDA
initiatives - credit sales higher than cash sales in April FY18 for first time since 2010
continued strategic and tactical initiatives
international brands
initiatives to be implemented
infrastructure
customers
Specialty chain into Edgars and Jet for greater synergies, efficient relationships, meeting needs of target market
6 weeks
refinance of EUR debt
EDGARS
48
chain:
more stores
service into the chains
EDGARS
49
140(2) (b) of the National Credit Act, 32 of 2005 (“NCA”) wherein the NCR asked for a declaration by the NCT that Edcon had contravened the NCA by requiring the payment of club fees in terms of its credit agreements. The Company noted the NCT’s judgment issued on the 24 April 2017 and, following consultation with Senior Counsel on the matter, filed an appeal with the High Court on 10 May 2017. At the commencement of the hearing, the parties agreed that the Tribunal will only deal with the merits of the case, and that a separate hearing process will be instituted following the judgment. The Appeal, as filed, has the effect staying the Sanctions hearing until the Appeal process has been finalised.
this regard, we note that the Tribunal did not find (and could not have found) that the selling of a Club product is unlawful in and of itself, rather, the finding was that the inclusion of Club in credit agreement is contrary to the NCA. Furthermore, we are of the view that no consumer could have been disadvantaged by choosing to purchase an option product and receiving full value for their purchase.”
50
For more information: www.edcon.co.za
25 MAY 2017 | investorrelations@edcon.co.za JET