Teddy Mosomothane
17 May 2016
Presentation Retaining Value and Quality in a changing healthcare - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Public Hearing Presentation Retaining Value and Quality in a changing healthcare landscape Teddy Mosomothane 17 May 2016 Embracing the opportunity to contribute We appreciate the inquiry process as partly leading towards recommendations
Teddy Mosomothane
17 May 2016
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
We appreciate the inquiry process as partly leading towards recommendations on:
support the goal of achieving accessible, affordable, innovative and quality private health care;
competition policy and competition law in achieving pro-competitive outcomes in health care. Bankmed intends to share some insights primarily from a closed medical scheme perspective in the banking industry.
2
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
1. About Bankmed 2. Insights on risk pooling successes resulting in better value 3. Investment by employer groups in health and wellness 4. Targeted focus on quality of healthcare 5. The challenge of behaviour change 6. An opportunity for collaboration and a phased response to necessary change 7. Bankmed’s recent change of administrator 8. Conclusion
3
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Collaboration among bankers, going back to 1914 Not-for-profit restricted medical scheme in the banking industry Healthcare funding to more than 50 financial institutions 107 553 principal members, 216 262 beneficiaries (31/12/2015) Market share:
(and 2.31% of beneficiaries)
members (5.20% of beneficiaries)
4
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Vision
To be the Medical Scheme of Choice for the Banking Industry
Mission
To be an affordable Medical Scheme that guarantees best-of-class member experience, value and quality
5
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Integrated digital strategy Innovation / Research & Development Value to members
6
7
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
8
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Better value
vs
vs industry average of
Benefit Options
Compared to an average Open scheme Global Credit Rating – 2015 (Highest in the Industry) Solvency Ratio (2015) vs Industry Average (2014) Non-healthcare Expense Ratio
(Administration, Managed Healthcare & General Administration expenses)
A fair spread of benefits providing for low to high Healthcare needs and affordability
9
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Bankmed retained an AA+ credit rating in 2015, the highest rating a medical scheme can attain. Rating assigned by Global Credit Ratings (GCR). Bankmed is one of only two South African medical schemes with an AA+ credit rating. Attributes contributing to the AA+ rating according to GCR:
profile
investment returns at reasonable risk levels
10
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
1. Background about Bankmed 2. Insights on risk pooling successes resulting in better value 3. Investment by employer groups in health and wellness 4. Targeted focus on quality of healthcare 5. The challenge of behaviour change 6. An opportunity for collaboration and a phased response to necessary change 7. Bankmed’s recent change of administrator 8. Conclusion
11
Bankmed benchmarking - 2016
12
Bankmed benchmarking - 2016
13
Bankmed benchmarking - 2016
Cost Benefit Value PMB Plan
22% Basic Plan
15% 28% Core Saver Plan
1% 25% Traditional Plan
3% 36% Comprehensive Plan
19% 38% Plus Plan
6% 32%
11% 33%
14
Bankmed benchmarking - 2016
– Bankmed members would (on average) be 33% worse off on an equivalent open membership medical scheme option – The calculations of relative value have been prepared by Willis Towers Watson using the Bankmed 2015 membership and claims profile – The value differential has increased each year from 2013 to 2016
– The value differential of 33% can be only partly explained by the younger age profile
– The unexplained value differential (18%) is due to the compulsory nature of the Bankmed membership
15
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Employers Groups can protect the Bankmed risk pool from the loss of younger / healthier members to a large degree by retaining the condition
Bankmed This will enable the Employer Groups to offer their employees access to affordable private healthcare
16
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
1. Background about Bankmed 2. Insights on risk pooling successes resulting in better value 3. Investment by employer groups in health and wellness 4. Targeted focus on quality of healthcare 5. The challenge of behaviour change 6. An opportunity for collaboration and a phased response to necessary change 7. Bankmed’s recent change of administrator 8. Conclusion
17
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Aligned health and wellness strategies Sharing of information on the health of the organization Monitor performance of the health and wellness initiatives
18
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Demographic overview Claims & Utilization Clinical Review HIV/AIDS Personal Health Assessment (PHA) and Individual Stress Assessment (ISA)
19
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
57,04% 55,46% 42,96% 44,54%
0,00% 10,00% 20,00% 30,00% 40,00% 50,00% 60,00% Female Male
Employer Client: X Bankmed
20
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
0,06% 23,34% 32,06% 17,56% 11,48% 4,81% 10,68% 0,04% 22,89% 33,10% 17,34% 11,32% 4,57% 10,74%
0,00% 5,00% 10,00% 15,00% 20,00% 25,00% 30,00% 35,00%
0 - 19 20 - 29 30 - 39 40 - 49 50 - 59 60 - 65 66+
Bankmed Employer Client: X
21
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
43,41% 28,30% 14,37% 10,41% 2,87% 0,53% 0,11% 44,77% 29,15% 14,08% 9,25% 2,29% 0,40% 0,06%
0,00% 5,00% 10,00% 15,00% 20,00% 25,00% 30,00% 35,00% 40,00% 45,00% 50,00% M+0 M+1 M+2 M+3 M+4 M+5 M+6+ Bankmed Employer Client: X
22
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
6,32% 37,77% 55,91% 5,70% 26,47% 67,84%
0,00% 10,00% 20,00% 30,00% 40,00% 50,00% 60,00% 70,00% 80,00%
R0 - R5 000 R5 001 - R10 000 R10 000+ Bankmed Employer Client: X
23
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
7,75% 18,00% 10,90% 25,87% 37,49% 8,97% 15,55% 10,51% 25,22% 39,75%
0,00% 5,00% 10,00% 15,00% 20,00% 25,00% 30,00% 35,00% 40,00% 45,00%
>1 yr 1-3 yrs 3-5 yrs 5-10 yrs > 10 yrs Bankmed Employer Client: X
24
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Percentage Utilisation X 2014 Bankmed 2014 Mammogram coverage 24.29% 29.92% Cervical Cytology coverage 38.31% 42.71% Bone Densitometry coverage 4.84% 8.81% PSA Screening 29.84% 45.61% Colorectal Cancer Screening 1.67% 3.11% Glaucoma Screening 9.39% 15.53% HCT Coverage 3.71% 6.27% Beneficiaries Visiting Dentists (|>2yrs) 22.20% 36.15% PHA Coverage 7.57% 19.94%
25
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
1,95% 3,71% 2,10% 2,79% 11,32% 11,70% 10,94% 9,53% 4,65% 5,36% 3,73% 4,57%
0,00% 2,00% 4,00% 6,00% 8,00% 10,00% 12,00% 14,00%
Diabetes Hyperlipidaemia Hypertension Employer Client: X Female Employer Client: X Male Bankmed Female Bankmed Male
26
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
36,10% 41,01% 37,42% 26,63% 28,66% 25,20%
0,00% 5,00% 10,00% 15,00% 20,00% 25,00% 30,00% 35,00% 40,00% 45,00% Female >90 Male >100
Employer Client: X 2014 Bankmed 2014 Employer Client: X 2013
27
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
28
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
29
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Employer Client: X 2013 Employer Client: X 2014 Bankmed 2014 Females 789 (78.27%) 807 (77.29%) 2 209 (70.06%) Males 219 (21.72%) 237 (22.70%) 944 (29.93%) Total 1 008 1 044 3 153 Post Exposure Prophylaxis (monthly average) 3.33 1.08 6.16 Deceased 5 6 22
30
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
2 348 1 709 9 998
2 000 4 000 6 000 8 000 10 000 12 000
Employer Client: X 2014 Bankmed 2014 Employer Client: X 2013
31
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
2,08% 1,11% 2,09% 1,32% 1,89% 1,67%
0,00% 0,50% 1,00% 1,50% 2,00% 2,50% Female Male
Employer Client: X 2014 Bankmed 2014 Employer Client: X 2013
32
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
78,79% 34,78% 68,52% 60,00% 50,00% 71,74%
0,00% 10,00% 20,00% 30,00% 40,00% 50,00% 60,00% 70,00% 80,00% 90,00% Female Male
Employer Client: X 2014 Bankmed 2014 Employer Client: X 2013
33
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
925 233 369 386 1311 1749
200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
34
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
Social stressors e.g. friends, social isolation, religious… Health-related stressors e.g. chronic illness Environmental stressors e.g. crime, pollution, living… Children or family stressors Personal relationship difficulties Personal financial stressors Work-related stressors and job stress
38% 41% 47% 50% 50% 59% 64%
Most significant stressors reported
35
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Procedure Type Admissions 2013 Admissions 2014 Cost / Admission (2014) Caesarean Delivery 545 545 R25 083 Dental Procedures 459 471 R8 692 Ophthalmic Biopsies and Excisions 399 461 R10 356 Stomach and Duodenal Procedures 570 448 R21 097 Urinary Functional Procedures 330 420 R16 060
36
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Procedure Type Admissions 2013 Admissions 2014 Cost / Admission (2014) Pneumonia 402 349 R17 994 Maternity 332 367 R30 192 Major Depression 203 198 R18 708 Paediatric/Neonates 74 72 R31 767 Cardiac Failure N/A 60 R37 963
37
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
2013 2014 Rank Condition
Claimants Rank Condition
Claimants 1 Hypertension 7 130 1 Hypertension 7 127 2 Hyperlipidaemia 3 983 2 Hyperlipidaemia 4 125 3 Coronary Artery Disease 2 702 3 Coronary Artery Disease 2 753 4 Hypothyroidism 2 079 4 Depression 2 177 5 Depression 1 969 5 Hypothyroidism 2 129
38
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
37,06% 53,50% 63,81%
0,00% 10,00% 20,00% 30,00% 40,00% 50,00% 60,00% 70,00%
2012 2013 2014
39
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
32,02% 42,98% 47,71%
0,00% 10,00% 20,00% 30,00% 40,00% 50,00% 60,00%
2012 2013 2014
40
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
262 187 75 75 49 283 204 83 71 54
50 100 150 200 250 300
Breast Cancer Prostate Cancer GIT Dermatological Cancer Lymph Nodes & Lymphoma
2013 2014
41
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
11,32% 4,65% 1,95% 9,89% 41,01% 11,70% 5,36% 3,71% 5,36% 28,66%
0,00% 5,00% 10,00% 15,00% 20,00% 25,00% 30,00% 35,00% 40,00% 45,00%
Hyperlipidaemia Hypertension Diabetes Smoking Obesity
Female Male
42
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Focussed approach at Wellness Experiences Days (Dietician) Online Stress Assessment (early ID of at risk for depression) Quarterly Wellness Forums (align Bankmed Wellness Strategy with Employer Group Strategy) On-going screening (not limited to Wellness Experience Days): employer driven competition amongst BUs. CEO to lead by example Regional Strategy for increasing screening Call centre strategy Move from fragmented to integrated wellness offering
43
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
1. Background about Bankmed 2. Insights on risk pooling successes resulting in better value 3. Investment by employer groups in health and wellness 4. Targeted focus on quality of healthcare 5. The challenge of behaviour change 6. An opportunity for collaboration and a phased response to necessary change 7. Bankmed’s recent change of administrator 8. Conclusion
44
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Benchmarking exercise in the funding industry Highlights key quality issues in the SA medical scheme industry Drives improvement in the delivery of evidence-based medicine 18 participating Schemes in the 2014 HQA Comprised of 88 benefit options Represented 6,78 million beneficiaries (77,21% medical scheme population) Four categories are evaluated, namely:
45
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
1. Background about Bankmed 2. Insights on risk pooling successes resulting in better value 3. Investment by employer groups in health and wellness 4. Targeted focus on quality of healthcare 5. The challenge of behaviour change 6. An opportunity for collaboration and a phased response to necessary change 7. Bankmed’s recent change of administrator 8. Conclusion
46
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Individual member’s responsibility Opportunity to embrace innovative interventions Regulatory obstacles Prevention better than cure Shift away from hospicentricity Flexibility in response to unintended consequences
47
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
1. Background about Bankmed 2. Insights on risk pooling successes resulting in better value 3. Investment by employer groups in health and wellness 4. Targeted focus on quality of healthcare 5. The challenge of behaviour change 6. An opportunity for collaboration and a phased response to necessary change 7. Bankmed’s recent change of administrator 8. Conclusion
48
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Lessons on collaboration Acknowledging current reality Carrying forward successful practices Interim dispensations in a changing landscape
49
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
1. Background about Bankmed 2. Insights on risk pooling successes resulting in better value 3. Investment by employer groups in health and wellness 4. Targeted focus on quality of healthcare 5. The challenge of behaviour change 6. An opportunity for collaboration and a phased response to necessary change 7. Bankmed’s recent change of administrator 8. Conclusion
50
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Strong business case, based on a combination
successful bidder – which was a new administrator.
51
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
The tender process itself was triggered by the following factors and considerations: Good Governance: considered good governance practice to occasionally test the market with a view to evaluating whether or not the Scheme (and ultimately the members) is / are getting the best value via key outsourced service providers. The Scheme also identified a need for a more “Integrated service offering” An opportunity for the Scheme to refresh its “Service delivery” requirements, and evaluate proposals from competing bidders An opportunity to secure a “Competitive price” for the refreshed service delivery offering, in the best interest of the Scheme and its members
52
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Used independent Tender Administrator Robust process Compliance with procurement policy Expert independent input when required Clear rationale for selection of invited bidders Closed tender (3 major players) invited based on the rationale referred to above A cross-functional Tender Sub-committee Compliance with relevant regulatory notices
53
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
1. Background about Bankmed 2. Insights on risk pooling successes resulting in better value 3. Investment by employer groups in health and wellness 4. Targeted focus on quality of healthcare 5. The challenge of behaviour change 6. An opportunity for collaboration and a phased response to necessary change 7. Bankmed’s recent change of administrator 8. Conclusion
54
The average Bankmed member is currently better off financially by an amount of
versus if the member joined the average
Acknowledgement of an unsustainable system Some issues not unique to South Africa Acknowledgement of other socio-economic factors Acknowledgement of positives Medical schemes “price takers” A call for stakeholders to rise above the inherent tension and work together The tone about medical schemes must change Solutions located in common interests and diverse insights Interim dispensations should be part of the solution
55