Presentation Outline (1) K (1) Key ey Sources of TF Information: - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Project Executed by: Partner:

Session 7: SUPP SUPPOR ORTING TING THE TF THE TFA A IMPLEMENT IMPLEMENTATION TION THR THROU OUGH GH RESEAR RESEARCH

Jakarta, Indonesia 24-25 April 2018 Wenguo Cai, Director, International Programs Alex Larouche-Maltais, Senior Trade and Investment Expert The Conference Board of Canada

Presentation Outline

(1) K (1) Key ey Sources of TF Information: Using Right Tools (2) Trade Facilitation Research: Data Collection and Methodologies (3) Group Exercise: Research and Training Needs on Trade Facilitation for Government Agencies and the Private Sector

(1) Key Sources for TF Info & Tools

➢ Inte

Interna nation tional al Or Orga ganiza nization tions s (WT (WTO, , WCO CO, , UNCT UNCTAD AD, , IT ITC, , UNECE UNECE, , WB WB, , APE APEC, , ASE ASEAN, AN, etc etc)

➢ Government Agencies (trade, customs,

etc)

➢ Private Sector (chambers, business

associations, customs brokers, logistics companies, etc)

➢ Academic (research institutes,

universities, etc)

➢ Others (i.e. web search)

WTO TFA: Information and Tools

➢ Trad

ade e Fac acili ilita tatio tion n Ag Agree eeme ment nt ht http tps://www s://www.wto .wto.or .org/en g/engli lish sh/tr /trato top_e/tr p_e/trad ad fa_e/tr a_e/trad adfa_e.ht a_e.htm

➢ Implemen

Implementa tation tion st statu tus: s: fac act sh t shee eets ts

➢ No

Notifica tificatio tions ns of

• f WT

WTO O me memb mber ers

➢ Contact points and profiles ➢ Publications, papers, briefing notes ➢ Donors and technical assistance ➢ Dedicated website on trade facilitation

http://www.tfafacility.org/

WCO: TF Information and Tools

➢ WCO

CO website: bsite: www www.w .wco coomd

• md.or

.org

➢ HS c

HS cod

• de & HS

e & HS no nomen mencla latur ture e 20 2017 17

➢ Research papers, briefing notes, etc

➢ Capacity building and technical

assistance

➢ Training package and E-learning ➢ WCO implementation of WTO TFA ➢ Revise

vised d Kyot

• to
• Con

Conven ention tion

➢ WCO

CO on

• n-line

line se service vices s (HS (HS da data taba base se, , CEN, CEN, TEN, TEN, etc etc)

UNCTAD: TF Information and Tools

➢ UNCT

UNCTAD AD website: bsite: www www.unc .unctad.or tad.org

➢ Na

National tional tr trad ade e fac acil ilita itation tion roa

• adma

dmap

➢ Trad

ade e fac acil ilita itation tion tec techn hnical ical no notes tes

➢ Training package and E-learning on TF ➢ Studies and publications ➢ Port management series ➢ Tran

ansp spor

• rt

t an and tr d trad ade e logist logistics ics

➢ Cus

Custo toms ms au auto toma mation tion so softw ftwar are e – ACY CYCUD CUDA+++ A+++ an and A d ACY CYCUD CUDA/w A/wor

• rld

ld

➢ Oth

Other ers? s??? ??

ITC: TF Information and Tools

➢ IT

ITC C webs bsite: ite: www www.i .int ntrac acen en.or .org

➢ UN

UN Trad ade e Pr Promo

• motion

tion Ass Assista istanc nce e bo body dy un unde der r UNC UNCTAD AD/WT /WTO

➢ Also

Also ver ery y ac activ tive e in tr in trad ade e fac acil ilita itation tion

➢ SMEs

SMEs & & WT WTO O TF TFA A – A T A Training aining Man Manua ual

➢ Many training packages and E-learning ➢ Studies and publications ➢ Market information and trade

intelligence

➢ Trademap, E-Trade, etc ➢ Oth

Other ers? s??? ??

UNECE: TF Information and Tools

➢ UNECE

UNECE webs bsite: ite: www www.une .unece ce.or .org

➢ Guide

Guide to to dr drafting afting na nation tional al tr trad ade e fac acili ilita tatio tion n roa

• adm

dmaps ps

➢ Trad

ade e fac acil ilita itation tion rec ecomme

• mmend

ndation tions s

➢ Trad

ade e fac acil ilita itation tion implemen implementa tation tion gu guide ide

➢ National trade facilitation bodies ➢ Studies and publications ➢ Training packages and technical

assistance

➢ UN Centre for Trade Facilitation and E-

Business housed by UNECE: https://www.unece.org/cefact/

WB: TF Information and Tools

➢ Wor

• rld

ld Bank w Bank website: bsite: ww www.w .wor

• rldbank.or

ldbank.org

➢ Trade

ade facilita acilitation tion supp suppor

• rt

t pr prog

• gram

am

➢ Trade f

ade facilita acilitation tion and lo and logis gistics tics

➢ Wor

• rld

ld Bank logistics Bank logistics perf perfor

• rmance inde

mance index

➢ Studies and publications, particularly

country case studies

➢ Training and technical assistance ➢ Big customs & trade facilitation projects ➢ Grants & loans for custom modernization

programs

APEC: TF Information and Tools

➢ APE

APEC C website: bsite: ww www.a .apec.or pec.org

➢ Simplified busines

Simplified business s tr travel el – APE APEC C car cards ds

➢ Fas

aster ter Cus Customs toms clear learance ance

➢ E-comme

commerce and ce and pa paper perless less tr trading ading

➢ More consistent customs valuation ➢ Lower cost of trade in electrical and

telecom equipment

➢ Research and best practices ➢ Open regionalism/voluntary liberalization ➢ Market access information (database,

APEC trade portals)

ASEAN: TF Information and Tools

➢ ASEA

ASEAN N website: bsite: www www.asean.or .asean.org

➢ ASEAN Economic Community ➢ ASEAN Trade Facilitation

Framework

➢ ASEAN Customs integration ➢ ASEAN Trade Depository ➢ ASEAN Single Window

ASEAN: TF Information and Tools

➢ ASEA

ASEAN N website: bsite: www www.asean.or .asean.org

➢ ASEAN Economic Community ➢ ASEAN Trade Facilitation

Framework

➢ ASEAN Customs integration ➢ ASEAN Trade Depository ➢ ASEAN Single Window

Government Agencies: Canada

➢ Global

Global Af Affair airs s Canada: Canada: www www.inter .interna national.gc.c tional.gc.ca

❖ FT

FTA A rela elated inf ted infor

• rma

mation on tion on tr trade ade fac acil ilita itation, tion, inc including luding TF TFA

➢ Canadian Border Service Agency:

www.cbsa-asfc.gc.ca

❖ Operational side of trade

facilitation, including TFA

Government Agencies: Indonesia

➢ Ministr

Ministry y of

• f Trade,

ade, Indonesia: Indonesia: http://www http://www.k .kemen emenda dag.go g.go.id/ .id/

❖ FT

FTA A rela elated inf ted infor

• rma

mation on tion on tr trade ade fac acil ilita itation, tion, inc including luding TF TFA

➢ DG of Customs and Exercise, MoF:

http://www.beacukai.go.id

❖ Operational side of trade

facilitation, including TFA

Private Sector Associations

➢ Inter

Interna national tional Cha Chamber mber of

• f Commer

Commerce ce – res esour

• urces

ces for busine

• r business

ss www www.iccw .iccwbo bo.o .org

➢ Can

Canadian adian Cha Chamber mber of

• f Commer

Commerce ce – www www.c .cham hamber ber.ca .ca

➢ Can

Canadian adian Man Manuf ufactur acturer ers s and and Exp Expor

• rter

ters s www www.cm .cme-mec. mec.ca ca

➢ Indone

Indonesian sian Cha Chamber mber of

• f Commer

Commerce ce and and Industr Industry y (KADI (KADIN) N) www www.kadin .kadin-indon indonesi esia.or a.or.i .id

➢ Indone

Indonesian sian Emplo Employer ers s Ass Associa

• ciation

tion (APINDO) (APINDO) www www.a .apindo pindo.or .or.id .id

➢ Sec

Sector toral al bus busines iness s as asso socia ciations tions or

• r

companies companies (customs (customs br brok

• ker

ers, s, tr transp anspor

• rt

t

• pe
• perator

tors, s, etc etc)

Academic Institutions

➢ Resear

esearch h Instit Institutes utes

❖ The

he Con Confer erenc ence e Boa Board d of

• f Cana

Canada, da, Ottaw Ottawa a (www www.conf .confer erenc enceboar

• ard.ca

d.ca) )

❖ Centr

Centre e for St

• r Strate

tegic gic and Int and Inter erna nati tional

• nal

Studies Studies, , Jaka akarta ta www www.csi .csis. s.or

• r.id

.id

❖ Inter

Interna national tional Cen Centr tre e for T

• r Trade

ade and and Sus Sustaina tainable ble De Developme elopment nt www www.ic .icst std.or d.org

❖ Wor

• rld

ld Trade ade Insti Institut tute e (W (WTI) TI), , Ber Bern

❖ Res

esear earch h Instit Institute ute for ASEA

• r ASEAN

N & & Eas East t Asia Asia

➢ Univ

Univer ersities sities

❖ Car

Carleton leton Univ Univer ersit sity y – Cen Centr tre e for

• r Trade

ade Polic

• licy

y and and Law Law – ww www.ct .ctpl.ca pl.ca

❖ any un

any univ iver ersit sities ies in in Indo Indonesia??? nesia???

(2) Data Collection and Research Methodologies

➢ Da

Data S ta Sour

• urces

ces

❖ Fir

First st-han hand d da data: ta:

✓ Bu

Busine siness ss sur surveys eys

✓ Questionn

Questionnair aires es

✓ Inte

Interviews, views, etc etc

❖ Second

Second-han hand d da data: ta:

✓ Inte

Interna nationa tional l or

• rga

ganiz nizations tions (WT (WTO, , WCO CO, , WB WB, , ADB ADB, , UN UNCT CTAD AD, , IT ITC, , etc etc

✓ Go

Gover ernm nmen ent s t sta tatisti tistics cs

✓ Bu

Busine siness ss ass assoc

• cia

iation tion rep epor

• rts/stud

ts/studies ies

✓ Co

Comp mpan any r y rep epor

• rts/co

ts/commu mmunic nications tions

✓ Med

Media ia rep epor

• rts;

ts; an and

✓ Academic

cademic resea esearch h pa paper pers s

Data Collection and Research Methodologies

➢ Rele

elevant TF inf vant TF infor

• rma

mation on tion on Indone Indonesia sia fr from

• m a f

a few ew donor donors pr s projects

• jects

❖ Trade

ade Facilita acilitation tion Ag Agreem eement ent Facility acility – www www.tf .tfaf afacil acility ity.or .org – Indone Indonesia sia Pages ges

❖ EU

EU – tec technical hnical ass assistance istance for de

• r developing

eloping the the comp computeriz uterized ed sy system stem for t

• r the

he ASE ASEAN AN Cus Customs toms Trans ansit it Sy System stem (A (ACTS CTS) ) fr from EU

• m EU-

funded funded ARISE ARISE and and ARISE+ ARISE+

❖ EU

EU-Indone Indonesia sia Trade ade Sup Suppor port t Facility acility und under er ARISE+ ARISE+ 2018 2018-2022 2022

❖ USA

USAID ID – Bor Border der and and r rela elated ted agen gencies cies ca capac pacity ity building building

❖ JICA

JICA – tr training aining and and ca capac pacity ity building building

❖Can

Canada ada – Trade ade and and Priva Private te Sec Sector tor Assistance Assistance Pr Project

• ject (TPSA)

(TPSA)

Research Methodology on Trade Facilitation

➢ Qua

Quantit ntitativ tive e ver ersu sus s qua qualit litativ tive

➢ Indica

Indicator tors s and and meas measur uremen ements ts

➢ Asse

Assess ss costs costs and benefit and benefits s of

• f t

trade ade facili acilita tati tion

• n measur

measures es

➢ Trade

ade Facilita acilitation tion Audit: udit: sta status, tus, cos costs ts and and ben benefit efits For

• r examp

xample: le: Wor

• rld Bank

ld Bank method methodolog

• logy

❖ Esta

Establishment blishment of

• f na

national tional customs customs website bsite

❖ Pub

Publica lication tion of

• f impo

import t expo xport t pr proce

• cedur

dures, es, bor border der pr procedur

• cedures,

es, fees and c ees and char harges, ges, aver erage ge released eleased time, time, clear learance ance time, time, changed r hanged regula gulations, tions, etc etc

❖ Rules

ules and pr and procedur

• cedures

es for Expo

• r Exports

ts and Impor and Imports ts

❖ Trade

ade facilita acilitation tion infr infrastr astructur ucture e and ser and services vices (por (port, t, road,

• ad, rail,

ail, war arehouse, ehouse, telecoms, telecoms, etc.) etc.)

❖ Use of

Use of the IC the ICT f T for e

• r expor

xport t and and im impor port

❖ Trea

eatme tment nt of

• f goo

goods ds in in tr tran ansit, sit, et etc. c.

(3) Research and Training Needs for Indonesia on Trade Facilitation

➢ Gr

Grou

• up

p Discussion Discussion

➢ Gr

Grou

• up

p Ex Exer ercise cise

Q&A and Discussion Thank you for your participation.