Modeling the chemotherapy-induced selection of drug-resistant traits - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

▶
modeling the chemotherapy induced selection of drug
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

Modeling the chemotherapy-induced selection of drug-resistant traits - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Aug 11, 2023 18 likes •391 views

Modeling the chemotherapy-induced selection of drug-resistant traits during tumor growth Doron Levy Department of Mathematics Center for Scientific Computation and Mathematical Modeling University of Maryland, College Park Thanks: NSF, NIH,

slide-1
SLIDE 1

Modeling the chemotherapy-induced selection

  • f drug-resistant traits during tumor growth

Doron Levy

Department of Mathematics Center for Scientific Computation and Mathematical Modeling University of Maryland, College Park

Thanks: NSF, NIH, UMD-NCI partership, LCB/NCI, Wolfgang Pauli Institute Guggenheim Foundation, Simons Foundation, Jayne Koskinas Ted Giovannis Foundation

Abarbanel Memorial Conference Tel Aviv University, December 2018

slide-2
SLIDE 2

Joint work with

★

Heyrim Cho Maryland

★

Matt Becker Johns Hopkins APL

★

Cristian Tomasetti Johns Hopkins

★

Michael Gottesman, MD NCI/NIH

★

Orit Lavi NCI/NIH

★

Jim Greene Rutgers

slide-3
SLIDE 3

Outline

★

Drug Resistance in Cancer

  • Mechanisms of MDR
  • Mathematics & Drug Resistance

★

Heterogeneity and Resistance

  • Selection process – a continuous trait
  • Heterogeneity in space (non-radially symmetric case)
  • Drug combinations (including cell-cycle and non-cell-cycle specific)
  • Competition between healthy cells and cancer cells
slide-4
SLIDE 4

Mechanisms of MDR

Gillet & Gottesman, 2010

slide-5
SLIDE 5

Mathematics and Drug Resistance

Lavi, Gottesman, Levy. The dynamics of drug resistance: A mathematical perspective. Drug Resistance Updates 15, 2012, 90-97.

★

Q1: What is the optimal protocol for drug scheduling in terms of dose and timing? Goal: maximize the control of the tumor while minimizing toxicity (Norton & Simon / Goldie & Coldman,…)

★

Q2: Continuous infusion vs. short pulses (Gardner, Panetta, Smieja,…)

★

Q3: When several drugs are available, how many drugs should be used? Should they be used in combination or sequentially? (Komarova & Wodarz,…)

slide-6
SLIDE 6

Tumor heterogeneity

★

Experiment: sequence the genome of cells that are sampled from different locations within the tumor

★

Result: the genomes of these cells are different

★

Conclusion: tumors are heterogeneous

★

What does it mean? Different things to different people

★

For us: heterogeneity in response to drugs

slide-7
SLIDE 7

The genome is not everything!

★

There is more to the dynamics than the genome

★

Genetics vs. epigenetics

★

Example: AMIGOS experimental data (TNBCs, 3D, Peyton lab)

slide-8
SLIDE 8

The ultimate goal

★

Assumptions (science fiction):

  • We can know the initial data (mapping the entire tumor with regards to

the level of resistance)

  • We can fully control the treatment (which drug and how much of it

arrives at what area)

  • We can fully (and dynamically) know what the cells are doing without

the treatment and in response to the treatment

★

Question: What is the optimal treatment?

★

A preliminary question: What is “optimal”?

slide-9
SLIDE 9

Modeling Tumor Heterogeneity

(Greene, Lavi, Gottesman, DL, Cancer Research 2013, BMB 2014, Trends in Mol. Med. 2014)

Following Lorz, Lorenzi, Clairambault, Perthame, et al. 2013 (Calsina & Cuadrado,

Champagnat, Desvillettes, Diekmann, …)

After some scaling…. And assuming

ρ(t) = Z 1 n(x, t) dx. ∂n(x, t) ∂t = ⇣ f(ρ(t))[r(x)(1 − θ(x)) − h(D(t), x)] − g(ρ(t))d(x) ⌘ n(x, t) + f(ρ(t)) Z 1 θ(y)r(y)M(y, x)n(y, t) dy. ∂n(x, t) ∂t = (r(x)(1 − θ) − c(x) − G(ρ(τ))d(x)) n(x, t) + θ Z 1 r(y)M(y, x)n(y, t)dy D(t) ≡ 1, θ(x) ≡ θ

Resistance level is assumed to be a continuous parameter

slide-10
SLIDE 10

Modeling Tumor Heterogeneity

★

Under these assumptions + rescaling time

★

Case I: Trait-based growth

★

Case II: Density-dependent model

★

Case III: The full selection-mutation model

∂n(x, t) ∂t = (r(x)(1 − θ) − c(x) − G(ρ(τ))d(x)) n(x, t) + θ Z 1 r(y)M(y, x)n(y, t)dy

τ = Z t f(ρ(s)) ds

∂n(x, t) ∂t = [r(x) − c(x) − d(x)]n(x, t). ∂n(x, t) ∂t = [r(x) − c(x) − G(ρ)d(x)]n(x, t).

Lorz - cancer cells Lorz - a specific form

  • f the eq. for healthy cells
slide-11
SLIDE 11

Case I: Trait-Based Growth

★

Only two different growth phenomena: extinction or unbounded growth

★

Yet - a selection model: a selection of the traits with the maximum net growth rate (the x’s that maximize r(x)-c(x)-d(x))

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 x r(x) c(x) d(x) 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 10 20 30 40 50 60

x

n(x,t)/ρ(t)

t=0 t=1.3442 t=25

∂n(x, t) ∂t = [r(x) − c(x) − d(x)]n(x, t).

ρ(t) → ∞, n(x, t) ρ(t) → X

i

aiδ(x − xi)

<latexit sha1_base64="85D5pPO+bYK3s+8uads8MAEiGoA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="85D5pPO+bYK3s+8uads8MAEiGoA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="85D5pPO+bYK3s+8uads8MAEiGoA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="85D5pPO+bYK3s+8uads8MAEiGoA=">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</latexit>
slide-12
SLIDE 12

Case II: Density Dependent Model

★

Assumption:

★

Theorem: The density remains bounded. The limit distribution is a collection of Dirac masses

∂n(x, t) ∂t = [r(x) − c(x) − G(ρ)d(x)]n(x, t). lim

ρ→∞ G(ρ) = ∞

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 −5 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45

x n(x,t)

t=0 t=0.15557 t=0.53721 t=2 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 −0.4 −0.3 −0.2 −0.1 0.1 0.2 0.3

x

r(x)−c(x) G(ρ)d(x) at t=0 G(ρ)d(x) at t=0.15557 G(ρ)d(x) at t=0.53721 G(ρ)d(x) at t=2

ρ(t) ≤ ρM, n(x, t) → X

i

aiδ(x − xi)

<latexit sha1_base64="ps1jqDEGiNhDbeULd6A1XT5YSL8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ps1jqDEGiNhDbeULd6A1XT5YSL8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ps1jqDEGiNhDbeULd6A1XT5YSL8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ps1jqDEGiNhDbeULd6A1XT5YSL8=">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</latexit>
slide-13
SLIDE 13

Case III: Selection/Mutation Model

★

Assumption:

★

Theorem: The density remains bounded.

★

The Dirac masses are replaced by distributions with nonzero variance

★

Hence: a continuum of traits that are stable for all time.

★

This is interpreted as tumor heterogeneity

lim

ρ→∞ G(ρ) = ∞

∂n(x, t) ∂t = (r(x)(1 − θ) − c(x) − G(ρ(τ))d(x)) n(x, t) + θ Z 1 r(y)M(y, x)n(y, t)dy

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 −5 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

x n(x,10)

ε=0.01 θ=0.1, ρf=2.9313 θ=0.4, ρf=2.917 θ=0.7, ρf=2.9089 θ=1, ρf=2.9025

Increasing the mutation ratio:

✦

increases heterogeneity

✦

smaller tumor size

slide-14
SLIDE 14

Adding space: The Lorz et al model

(radially symmetric, BMB 2015)

∂tn(t,r, θ) = [R(t,r, θ) − D(ρ(t,r)) − µ1(θ)c1(t,r)] n(t,r, θ) − αs∆s(t,r) +

  • γs +

1 p(θ)n(t,r, θ)dθ

  • s(t,r) = 0,

− αc1∆c1(t,r) +

  • γc1 +

1 µ1(θ)n(t,r, θ)dθ

  • c1(t,r) = 0,

− αc2∆c2(t,r) +

  • γc2 + µ2

1 n(t,r, θ)dθ

  • c2(t,r) = 0.

R(t,r, θ) = R(t,r, θ; s, c2) = p(θ) 1 + µ2c2(t,r)s(t,r).

ρ(t,r) =

  • n(t,r, θ)dθ,

∂rs(t,r = 0) = 0, s(t,r = 1) = S1, ∂rci(t,r = 0) = 0, ci(t,r = 1) = Ci(t), i = 1, 2.

Cytotoxic drug Cytostatic drug Nutrients Cancer cells Boundary conditions

slide-15
SLIDE 15

An improved radially-symmetric model

(Cho-DL, BMB 2017)

Cytotoxic drug Cytostatic drug Nutrients Cancer cells

∂tn(t,r, θ) = [((1 − w)R(t,r, θ) − D(ρ(t,r)) − C(t,r, θ))] n(t,r, θ) + αn(ρ(t,r))∆n(t,r, θ) + w

  • R(t,r, ϑ)M(θ, ϑ)n(t,r, ϑ)dϑ,

− αs(ρ(t,r))∆s(t,r) +

  • γs +

1 p(θ)n(t,r, θ)dθ

  • s(t,r) = 0,

− αc1(ρ(t,r))∆c1(t,r) +

  • γc1 +

1 µ1(θ)n(t,r, θ)dθ

  • c1(t,r) = 0,

− αc2(ρ(t,r))∆c2(t,r) +

  • γc2 + µ2

1 n(t,r, θ)dθ

  • c2(t,r) = 0.

(10

★

Cell diffusion, Mutations

★

Diffusion depends on cell density

★

The effect of the cytotoxic drug depends on the dosage µ1 = µ1(θ, c1)

<latexit sha1_base64="y4phSAWbtnc+VK02FohM7z3/LTo=">ACA3icbVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vqDvdDBahgpSkCLoRCm5cVrAPaEKYTCft0MmDmRuhIbf8WNC0Xc+hPu/BunaRbaeuByD+fcy8w9fiK4Asv6Nkorq2vrG+XNytb2zu6euX/QUXEqKWvTWMSy5xPFBI9YGzgI1kskI6EvWNcf38z87gOTisfRPUwS5oZkGPGAUwJa8swjJ0w9G1/jvNcGDEg5h69plnVq26lQMvE7sgVSg5ZlfziCmacgioIo1betBNyMSOBUsGnFSRVLCB2TIetrGpGQKTfLb5jiU60McBLXRHgXP29kZFQqUno68mQwEgtejPxP6+fQnDlZjxKUmARnT8UpAJDjGeB4AGXjIKYaEKo5PqvmI6IJBR0bBUdgr148jLpNOq2VbfvLqrNRhFHGR2jE1RDNrpETXSLWqiNKHpEz+gVvRlPxovxbnzMR0tGsXOI/sD4/AHzwJW6</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="y4phSAWbtnc+VK02FohM7z3/LTo=">ACA3icbVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vqDvdDBahgpSkCLoRCm5cVrAPaEKYTCft0MmDmRuhIbf8WNC0Xc+hPu/BunaRbaeuByD+fcy8w9fiK4Asv6Nkorq2vrG+XNytb2zu6euX/QUXEqKWvTWMSy5xPFBI9YGzgI1kskI6EvWNcf38z87gOTisfRPUwS5oZkGPGAUwJa8swjJ0w9G1/jvNcGDEg5h69plnVq26lQMvE7sgVSg5ZlfziCmacgioIo1betBNyMSOBUsGnFSRVLCB2TIetrGpGQKTfLb5jiU60McBLXRHgXP29kZFQqUno68mQwEgtejPxP6+fQnDlZjxKUmARnT8UpAJDjGeB4AGXjIKYaEKo5PqvmI6IJBR0bBUdgr148jLpNOq2VbfvLqrNRhFHGR2jE1RDNrpETXSLWqiNKHpEz+gVvRlPxovxbnzMR0tGsXOI/sD4/AHzwJW6</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="y4phSAWbtnc+VK02FohM7z3/LTo=">ACA3icbVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vqDvdDBahgpSkCLoRCm5cVrAPaEKYTCft0MmDmRuhIbf8WNC0Xc+hPu/BunaRbaeuByD+fcy8w9fiK4Asv6Nkorq2vrG+XNytb2zu6euX/QUXEqKWvTWMSy5xPFBI9YGzgI1kskI6EvWNcf38z87gOTisfRPUwS5oZkGPGAUwJa8swjJ0w9G1/jvNcGDEg5h69plnVq26lQMvE7sgVSg5ZlfziCmacgioIo1betBNyMSOBUsGnFSRVLCB2TIetrGpGQKTfLb5jiU60McBLXRHgXP29kZFQqUno68mQwEgtejPxP6+fQnDlZjxKUmARnT8UpAJDjGeB4AGXjIKYaEKo5PqvmI6IJBR0bBUdgr148jLpNOq2VbfvLqrNRhFHGR2jE1RDNrpETXSLWqiNKHpEz+gVvRlPxovxbnzMR0tGsXOI/sD4/AHzwJW6</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="y4phSAWbtnc+VK02FohM7z3/LTo=">ACA3icbVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vqDvdDBahgpSkCLoRCm5cVrAPaEKYTCft0MmDmRuhIbf8WNC0Xc+hPu/BunaRbaeuByD+fcy8w9fiK4Asv6Nkorq2vrG+XNytb2zu6euX/QUXEqKWvTWMSy5xPFBI9YGzgI1kskI6EvWNcf38z87gOTisfRPUwS5oZkGPGAUwJa8swjJ0w9G1/jvNcGDEg5h69plnVq26lQMvE7sgVSg5ZlfziCmacgioIo1betBNyMSOBUsGnFSRVLCB2TIetrGpGQKTfLb5jiU60McBLXRHgXP29kZFQqUno68mQwEgtejPxP6+fQnDlZjxKUmARnT8UpAJDjGeB4AGXjIKYaEKo5PqvmI6IJBR0bBUdgr148jLpNOq2VbfvLqrNRhFHGR2jE1RDNrpETXSLWqiNKHpEz+gVvRlPxovxbnzMR0tGsXOI/sD4/AHzwJW6</latexit>
slide-16
SLIDE 16

T T y Type to enter text

Linear vs. nonlinear uptake functions

★

Avoids the asymptotic delta at the boundary Linear (Lorz et al) Nonlinear (Cho-DL)

  • − αs(ρ(t,r))∆s(t,r) +
  • γs +

1 p(θ)n(t,r, θ)dθ

  • s(t,r) = 0,

− αc1(ρ(t,r))∆c1(t,r) +

  • γc1 +

1 µ1(θ)n(t,r, θ)dθ

  • c1(t,r) = 0,
  • 1
  • p(θ) = a1θ + a2,

µ1(θ) = b1θ + b2

<latexit sha1_base64="Gd1WEg/Wudt/0QESPTAdYvnSDGI=">ACJnicbVDLSgMxFM34rPVdekmWISKUmaKoJtCwY3LCvYBnTLcSdM2NPNockcopV/jxl9x46Ii4s5PMX0o2nogcHLOuST3+LEUGm37w1pZXVvf2Extpbd3dvf2MweHVR0livEKi2Sk6j5oLkXIKyhQ8nqsOAS+5DW/dzPxaw9caRGF9ziIeTOATijagEaycsU45yLXY5wRosUPGd2OQevcEHdfj+BFnWDxHO+U0X/J+N7BS+TtfP2FHSZOHOSJXOUvczYbUsCXiITILWDceOsTkEhYJPkq7ieYxsB50eMPQEAKum8PpmiN6apQWbUfKnBDpVP09MYRA60Hgm2QA2NWL3kT8z2sk2L5uDkUYJ8hDNnuonUiKEZ10RltCcYZyYAgwJcxfKeuCAoam2bQpwVlceZlUC3nHzjt3l9lSYV5HihyTE5IjDrkiJXJLyqRCGHkz2RMXq0n68V6s95n0RVrPnNE/sD6/AKkHaNh</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Gd1WEg/Wudt/0QESPTAdYvnSDGI=">ACJnicbVDLSgMxFM34rPVdekmWISKUmaKoJtCwY3LCvYBnTLcSdM2NPNockcopV/jxl9x46Ii4s5PMX0o2nogcHLOuST3+LEUGm37w1pZXVvf2Extpbd3dvf2MweHVR0livEKi2Sk6j5oLkXIKyhQ8nqsOAS+5DW/dzPxaw9caRGF9ziIeTOATijagEaycsU45yLXY5wRosUPGd2OQevcEHdfj+BFnWDxHO+U0X/J+N7BS+TtfP2FHSZOHOSJXOUvczYbUsCXiITILWDceOsTkEhYJPkq7ieYxsB50eMPQEAKum8PpmiN6apQWbUfKnBDpVP09MYRA60Hgm2QA2NWL3kT8z2sk2L5uDkUYJ8hDNnuonUiKEZ10RltCcYZyYAgwJcxfKeuCAoam2bQpwVlceZlUC3nHzjt3l9lSYV5HihyTE5IjDrkiJXJLyqRCGHkz2RMXq0n68V6s95n0RVrPnNE/sD6/AKkHaNh</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Gd1WEg/Wudt/0QESPTAdYvnSDGI=">ACJnicbVDLSgMxFM34rPVdekmWISKUmaKoJtCwY3LCvYBnTLcSdM2NPNockcopV/jxl9x46Ii4s5PMX0o2nogcHLOuST3+LEUGm37w1pZXVvf2Extpbd3dvf2MweHVR0livEKi2Sk6j5oLkXIKyhQ8nqsOAS+5DW/dzPxaw9caRGF9ziIeTOATijagEaycsU45yLXY5wRosUPGd2OQevcEHdfj+BFnWDxHO+U0X/J+N7BS+TtfP2FHSZOHOSJXOUvczYbUsCXiITILWDceOsTkEhYJPkq7ieYxsB50eMPQEAKum8PpmiN6apQWbUfKnBDpVP09MYRA60Hgm2QA2NWL3kT8z2sk2L5uDkUYJ8hDNnuonUiKEZ10RltCcYZyYAgwJcxfKeuCAoam2bQpwVlceZlUC3nHzjt3l9lSYV5HihyTE5IjDrkiJXJLyqRCGHkz2RMXq0n68V6s95n0RVrPnNE/sD6/AKkHaNh</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Gd1WEg/Wudt/0QESPTAdYvnSDGI=">ACJnicbVDLSgMxFM34rPVdekmWISKUmaKoJtCwY3LCvYBnTLcSdM2NPNockcopV/jxl9x46Ii4s5PMX0o2nogcHLOuST3+LEUGm37w1pZXVvf2Extpbd3dvf2MweHVR0livEKi2Sk6j5oLkXIKyhQ8nqsOAS+5DW/dzPxaw9caRGF9ziIeTOATijagEaycsU45yLXY5wRosUPGd2OQevcEHdfj+BFnWDxHO+U0X/J+N7BS+TtfP2FHSZOHOSJXOUvczYbUsCXiITILWDceOsTkEhYJPkq7ieYxsB50eMPQEAKum8PpmiN6apQWbUfKnBDpVP09MYRA60Hgm2QA2NWL3kT8z2sk2L5uDkUYJ8hDNnuonUiKEZ10RltCcYZyYAgwJcxfKeuCAoam2bQpwVlceZlUC3nHzjt3l9lSYV5HihyTE5IjDrkiJXJLyqRCGHkz2RMXq0n68V6s95n0RVrPnNE/sD6/AKkHaNh</latexit>

p(θ) = a1 1 + a2θ5 , µ1(θ, c1) = b1 1 + θ2+0.5c1

<latexit sha1_base64="3GekV3FLdAXnv8uOvGmxNYJ6Qao=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="3GekV3FLdAXnv8uOvGmxNYJ6Qao=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="3GekV3FLdAXnv8uOvGmxNYJ6Qao=">ACSnicbZBLSyNBFIWro+MjzmjUpZvCIChK6AqKboSAG5cRJiqkM83tSrUprH5YdVsITf8+N67c+SNmMwtF3FhJ94CvCwWHc+6hqr4gVdKg6z46tZnZH3PzC4v1pZ+/lcaq2vnJsk0Fz2eqERfBmCEkrHoUQlLlMtIAqUuAiuTyb5xa3QRibxbxynYhDBVSxDyQGt5Tcg3fZwJB26DH1Qg08B58VOdsFv10mf/KDotij3s1NBkPqRZnPqs4e9nOcdkKytb/SnvXbR3YuCj8RtNtudOhXwWrRJNU0/UbD94w4VkYuQKjOkzN8VBDholV6Koe5kRKfBruBJ9K2OIhBnkUxQF3bLOkIaJtidGOnXfN3KIjBlHgd2MAEfmczYxv8v6GYZHg1zGaYi5uVFYaYoJnTClQ6lFhzV2ArgWtq3Uj4CSwYt/bqFwD5/+as4b7eY2Jn+81Ou8KxQDbIJtkmjBySDjklXdIjnNyRv+SJPDv3zj/nxXktV2tO1VknH6Y2+wbH1LDs</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="3GekV3FLdAXnv8uOvGmxNYJ6Qao=">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</latexit>

R(t,r, θ) = R(t,r, θ; s, c2) = p(θ) 1 + µ2c2(t,r)s(t,r).

slide-17
SLIDE 17

T T y Type to enter text

Linear vs. nonlinear uptake functions

no drug

  • n-off cytostatic drug

t θ

100 200 1 0.5 1 2 3 4 5

t θ

100 200 1 0.5 1 2 3

t θ

100 200 1 0.5 0.2 0.4 0.6

t θ

100 200 1 0.5 0.2 0.4 0.6

(a) (b)

Linear Nonlinear

slide-18
SLIDE 18

Relapse & emerging resistance

(one figure to remember)

dosage 1

t θ

C1(t) = 2 200 400 600 1 0.5 0.05 0.1

t θ

C1(t) = 6 100 200 1 0.9 1 2

t θ

C1(t) = 8 100 200 1 0.9 0.5 1

dosage 2 dosage 1

t θ

C1(t) = 2 100 200 1 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.3

t θ

C1(t) = 6 100 200 1 0.5 0.05 0.1

t θ

C1(t) = 8 100 200 1 0.5 0.05 0.1

t θ

C1(t) = 7Cb(t) 100 200 1 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.3

t θ

C1(t) = 16Cb(t) 100 200 1 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.3

t θ

C1(t) = 21Cb(t) 100 200 1 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.3

(a) (b) (c)

Linear Nonlinear Continuous On-Off Nonlinear Continuous

slide-19
SLIDE 19

Diffusion of nutrients & drug

0.5 1 1 0.5 0.5 1 1 0.5 0.5 1 1 0.5 0.5 1 1 0.5 0.5 1 1 0.5 0.5 1 1 0.5

Resistance vs. r Increased diffusion of nutrients high drug diffusion low drug diffusion no cell diffusion

★

The drug and the nutrients diffuse from the boundary (r=1)

★

With a high diffusion of the nutrient, the cancer cell growth near the center (r=0) is expedited

★

This increases the heterogeneity in particular when the drug permeability is low

slide-20
SLIDE 20

Diffusion of nutrients & drug

100 200 1 0.5 0.05 0.1 0.15 100 200 1 0.5 0.04 0.08 100 200 1 0.5 0.04 0.08 100 200 1 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.3 100 200 1 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.3 100 200 1 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.3

high drug diffusion low drug diffusion Resistance vs. time Increased diffusion of nutrients no cell diffusion

★

The phenotype heterogeneity becomes relatively large when the resource is more permeable compared to the drug (upper-right corner)

slide-21
SLIDE 21

Emerging tumor heterogeneity

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 2 4 6 8 10

θ

Q(t, θ) 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 2 4 6 8 10

θ r

n(t, r, θ)

¯ αs = 0.8 θ

0.5 1 1 0.5

r ¯ αs = 8 θ

0.5 1 1 0.5

¯ β [ · ]= 0, αn = 0 ¯ αn = 10−4 ¯ αn = 10−3 ¯ αn = 10−2

★

Increased cell diffusion results with a bi-modal distribution

★

Different levels of resistance in different locations

slide-22
SLIDE 22

The role of mutations

t = 50 t = 100 t = 150

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0.05 0.1 0.15

θ

¯ αs = ¯ αc1 = 0.08 q(θ, t)

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0.05 0.1 0.15

θ

q(θ, t)

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0.05 0.1 0.15

θ

q(θ, t) θ θ

0.5 0.5 0.4 0.8

A continuous process: asymmetric Gaussian mutation kernel

★

Increased variance

★

Regularized distribution

★

Concentration near the point where the maximum growth rate is achieved

★

The phenotype distribution is shifted towards the higher resistance levels due to the asymmetry in the kernel

slide-23
SLIDE 23

The role of mutations

θ θ θ

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0.05 0.1 0.15

θ

¯ αs = 0.8, ¯ αc1 = 0.08 q(θ, t)

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

0.05

0.1 0.15

θ

q(θ, t)

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0.05 0.1 0.15

θ

q(θ, t)

θ θ

0.5 0.5 0.4 0.8

A jump process: mutations occurring at certain resistance levels

★

Dashed line - without mutations. Solid lines - with mutations.

★

Piecewise-linear mutation kernel

★

Cancer cells accumulate before crossing the bottleneck trait values

M(θ, θ) = nD

i=1 K(θ)(θ − θi−1) χ(θ,θ) Ωi×Ωi ,

θ ≥ θ, 0,

  • therwise,
slide-24
SLIDE 24

The full 2D problem (Cho-DL JTB 2018)

p(t, x) = k k − 1ρk−1(t, x), k > 1

<latexit sha1_base64="70vlFfvaVTLR2teojb1g2WqPndM=">ACG3icbZDLSsNAFIYnXmu9RV26GSxChVqSIuhGKbhxWcFeoIlMpm0QyYXZyZiCXkPN76KGxeKuBJc+DZO0y09cDAx/+fw5nzOzGjQhrGt7awuLS8slpaK69vbG5t6zu7HRElHJM2jljEew4ShNGQtCWVjPRiTlDgMNJ1/MuJ370nXNAovJHjmNgBGobUoxhJQ30RlyVNfhwBM+h5XGEUz9L/WMzs/gous1p6tegdZcgF/oX5kCvGHUjLzgPZgEVUFRroH9aboSTgIQSMyRE3zRiaeIS4oZycpWIkiMsI+GpK8wRAERdprflsFDpbjQi7h6oYS5+nsiRYEQ48BRnQGSIzHrTcT/vH4ivTM7pWGcSBLi6SIvYVBGcBIUdCknWLKxAoQ5VX+FeIRURFLFWVYhmLMnz0OnUTeNunl9Umk2ijhKYB8cgCowSlogivQAm2AwSN4Bq/gTXvSXrR37WPauqAVM3vgT2lfP9Tanrs=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="70vlFfvaVTLR2teojb1g2WqPndM=">ACG3icbZDLSsNAFIYnXmu9RV26GSxChVqSIuhGKbhxWcFeoIlMpm0QyYXZyZiCXkPN76KGxeKuBJc+DZO0y09cDAx/+fw5nzOzGjQhrGt7awuLS8slpaK69vbG5t6zu7HRElHJM2jljEew4ShNGQtCWVjPRiTlDgMNJ1/MuJ370nXNAovJHjmNgBGobUoxhJQ30RlyVNfhwBM+h5XGEUz9L/WMzs/gous1p6tegdZcgF/oX5kCvGHUjLzgPZgEVUFRroH9aboSTgIQSMyRE3zRiaeIS4oZycpWIkiMsI+GpK8wRAERdprflsFDpbjQi7h6oYS5+nsiRYEQ48BRnQGSIzHrTcT/vH4ivTM7pWGcSBLi6SIvYVBGcBIUdCknWLKxAoQ5VX+FeIRURFLFWVYhmLMnz0OnUTeNunl9Umk2ijhKYB8cgCowSlogivQAm2AwSN4Bq/gTXvSXrR37WPauqAVM3vgT2lfP9Tanrs=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="70vlFfvaVTLR2teojb1g2WqPndM=">ACG3icbZDLSsNAFIYnXmu9RV26GSxChVqSIuhGKbhxWcFeoIlMpm0QyYXZyZiCXkPN76KGxeKuBJc+DZO0y09cDAx/+fw5nzOzGjQhrGt7awuLS8slpaK69vbG5t6zu7HRElHJM2jljEew4ShNGQtCWVjPRiTlDgMNJ1/MuJ370nXNAovJHjmNgBGobUoxhJQ30RlyVNfhwBM+h5XGEUz9L/WMzs/gous1p6tegdZcgF/oX5kCvGHUjLzgPZgEVUFRroH9aboSTgIQSMyRE3zRiaeIS4oZycpWIkiMsI+GpK8wRAERdprflsFDpbjQi7h6oYS5+nsiRYEQ48BRnQGSIzHrTcT/vH4ivTM7pWGcSBLi6SIvYVBGcBIUdCknWLKxAoQ5VX+FeIRURFLFWVYhmLMnz0OnUTeNunl9Umk2ijhKYB8cgCowSlogivQAm2AwSN4Bq/gTXvSXrR37WPauqAVM3vgT2lfP9Tanrs=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="70vlFfvaVTLR2teojb1g2WqPndM=">ACG3icbZDLSsNAFIYnXmu9RV26GSxChVqSIuhGKbhxWcFeoIlMpm0QyYXZyZiCXkPN76KGxeKuBJc+DZO0y09cDAx/+fw5nzOzGjQhrGt7awuLS8slpaK69vbG5t6zu7HRElHJM2jljEew4ShNGQtCWVjPRiTlDgMNJ1/MuJ370nXNAovJHjmNgBGobUoxhJQ30RlyVNfhwBM+h5XGEUz9L/WMzs/gous1p6tegdZcgF/oX5kCvGHUjLzgPZgEVUFRroH9aboSTgIQSMyRE3zRiaeIS4oZycpWIkiMsI+GpK8wRAERdprflsFDpbjQi7h6oYS5+nsiRYEQ48BRnQGSIzHrTcT/vH4ivTM7pWGcSBLi6SIvYVBGcBIUdCknWLKxAoQ5VX+FeIRURFLFWVYhmLMnz0OnUTeNunl9Umk2ijhKYB8cgCowSlogivQAm2AwSN4Bq/gTXvSXrR37WPauqAVM3vgT2lfP9Tanrs=</latexit>

G(t, x, θ) = g(t, x, θ)h(p, g), h(p, g) = 1 − H(p − ˜ p)H(g)

<latexit sha1_base64="zd/FMKhZNVQ53k+PCJYM65c13c=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="zd/FMKhZNVQ53k+PCJYM65c13c=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="zd/FMKhZNVQ53k+PCJYM65c13c=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="zd/FMKhZNVQ53k+PCJYM65c13c=">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</latexit>

R(t, x, θ; s, c2) = φ(θ) 1 + µ2c2(t, x)s(t, x), C(t, x, θ; c1) = µ1(θ, c1)c1(t, x)

<latexit sha1_base64="KrXV9yDv7hGU6UwUzkw8IDgXOkQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="KrXV9yDv7hGU6UwUzkw8IDgXOkQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="KrXV9yDv7hGU6UwUzkw8IDgXOkQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="KrXV9yDv7hGU6UwUzkw8IDgXOkQ=">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</latexit>

g(t, x, θ) = R(t, x, θ) − D(t, x, θ) − C(t, x, θ)

<latexit sha1_base64="7YqX7u9hY9mVo9S+Y421X0iMGJM=">ACLnicbZDLSgMxFIYzXmu9jbp0EyxChVpmiqAboVAFl1XsBdqhZNJMG5q5kJwRy9AncuOr6EJQEbc+hmk7C9v6Q+DnO+dwcn43ElyBZb0bS8srq2vrmY3s5tb2zq65t19XYSwpq9FQhLpEsUED1gNOAjWjCQjvitYwx1UxvXGA5OKh8E9DCPm+KQXcI9TAhp1zOteHgr4sYDb0GdATvAlvpsjp/hqgVRmScfMWUVrIrxo7NTkUKpqx3xtd0Ma+ywAKohSLduKwEmIBE4FG2XbsWIRoQPSYy1tA+Iz5STc0f4WJMu9kKpXwB4Qv9OJMRXaui7utMn0FfztTH8r9aKwbtwEh5EMbCAThd5scAQ4nF2uMsloyCG2hAquf4rpn0iCQWdcFaHYM+fvGjqpaJtFe3bs1y5lMaRQYfoCOWRjc5RGd2gKqohip7QC/pAn8az8WZ8Gd/T1iUjnTlAMzJ+fgEAgaMA</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="7YqX7u9hY9mVo9S+Y421X0iMGJM=">ACLnicbZDLSgMxFIYzXmu9jbp0EyxChVpmiqAboVAFl1XsBdqhZNJMG5q5kJwRy9AncuOr6EJQEbc+hmk7C9v6Q+DnO+dwcn43ElyBZb0bS8srq2vrmY3s5tb2zq65t19XYSwpq9FQhLpEsUED1gNOAjWjCQjvitYwx1UxvXGA5OKh8E9DCPm+KQXcI9TAhp1zOteHgr4sYDb0GdATvAlvpsjp/hqgVRmScfMWUVrIrxo7NTkUKpqx3xtd0Ma+ywAKohSLduKwEmIBE4FG2XbsWIRoQPSYy1tA+Iz5STc0f4WJMu9kKpXwB4Qv9OJMRXaui7utMn0FfztTH8r9aKwbtwEh5EMbCAThd5scAQ4nF2uMsloyCG2hAquf4rpn0iCQWdcFaHYM+fvGjqpaJtFe3bs1y5lMaRQYfoCOWRjc5RGd2gKqohip7QC/pAn8az8WZ8Gd/T1iUjnTlAMzJ+fgEAgaMA</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="7YqX7u9hY9mVo9S+Y421X0iMGJM=">ACLnicbZDLSgMxFIYzXmu9jbp0EyxChVpmiqAboVAFl1XsBdqhZNJMG5q5kJwRy9AncuOr6EJQEbc+hmk7C9v6Q+DnO+dwcn43ElyBZb0bS8srq2vrmY3s5tb2zq65t19XYSwpq9FQhLpEsUED1gNOAjWjCQjvitYwx1UxvXGA5OKh8E9DCPm+KQXcI9TAhp1zOteHgr4sYDb0GdATvAlvpsjp/hqgVRmScfMWUVrIrxo7NTkUKpqx3xtd0Ma+ywAKohSLduKwEmIBE4FG2XbsWIRoQPSYy1tA+Iz5STc0f4WJMu9kKpXwB4Qv9OJMRXaui7utMn0FfztTH8r9aKwbtwEh5EMbCAThd5scAQ4nF2uMsloyCG2hAquf4rpn0iCQWdcFaHYM+fvGjqpaJtFe3bs1y5lMaRQYfoCOWRjc5RGd2gKqohip7QC/pAn8az8WZ8Gd/T1iUjnTlAMzJ+fgEAgaMA</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="7YqX7u9hY9mVo9S+Y421X0iMGJM=">ACLnicbZDLSgMxFIYzXmu9jbp0EyxChVpmiqAboVAFl1XsBdqhZNJMG5q5kJwRy9AncuOr6EJQEbc+hmk7C9v6Q+DnO+dwcn43ElyBZb0bS8srq2vrmY3s5tb2zq65t19XYSwpq9FQhLpEsUED1gNOAjWjCQjvitYwx1UxvXGA5OKh8E9DCPm+KQXcI9TAhp1zOteHgr4sYDb0GdATvAlvpsjp/hqgVRmScfMWUVrIrxo7NTkUKpqx3xtd0Ma+ywAKohSLduKwEmIBE4FG2XbsWIRoQPSYy1tA+Iz5STc0f4WJMu9kKpXwB4Qv9OJMRXaui7utMn0FfztTH8r9aKwbtwEh5EMbCAThd5scAQ4nF2uMsloyCG2hAquf4rpn0iCQWdcFaHYM+fvGjqpaJtFe3bs1y5lMaRQYfoCOWRjc5RGd2gKqohip7QC/pAn8az8WZ8Gd/T1iUjnTlAMzJ+fgEAgaMA</latexit>

✓ ˜ p = k k − 1 ◆

<latexit sha1_base64="wT4hwCExk52bi2K5R5kxNMXAuic=">ACEXicbVDJSgNBEO1xjXEb9eilMQjxYJgJgl6EgBePEcwCmRB6OjVJk56F7hohDPMLXvwVLx4U8erNm39jZzlo4oOCx3tVNXzEyk0Os63tbK6tr6xWdgqbu/s7u3bB4dNHaeKQ4PHMlZtn2mQIoIGCpTQThSw0JfQ8kc3E7/1AEqLOLrHcQLdkA0iEQjO0Eg9u+xJCLBMPRSyD1mS02vqBYrxbJRno3M3p54SgyGe9eySU3GmoMvEnZMSmaPes7+8fszTECLkmndcZ0EuxlTKLiEvOilGhLGR2wAHUMjFoLuZtOPcnpqlD4NYmUqQjpVf09kLNR6HPqmM2Q41IveRPzP6QYXHUzESUpQsRni4JUozpJB7aFwo4yrEhjCthbqV8yEweaEIsmhDcxZeXSbNacZ2Ke3dRqlXncRTIMTkhZeKS1Ijt6ROGoSTR/JMXsmb9WS9WO/Wx6x1xZrPHJE/sD5/AGPKnKw=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="wT4hwCExk52bi2K5R5kxNMXAuic=">ACEXicbVDJSgNBEO1xjXEb9eilMQjxYJgJgl6EgBePEcwCmRB6OjVJk56F7hohDPMLXvwVLx4U8erNm39jZzlo4oOCx3tVNXzEyk0Os63tbK6tr6xWdgqbu/s7u3bB4dNHaeKQ4PHMlZtn2mQIoIGCpTQThSw0JfQ8kc3E7/1AEqLOLrHcQLdkA0iEQjO0Eg9u+xJCLBMPRSyD1mS02vqBYrxbJRno3M3p54SgyGe9eySU3GmoMvEnZMSmaPes7+8fszTECLkmndcZ0EuxlTKLiEvOilGhLGR2wAHUMjFoLuZtOPcnpqlD4NYmUqQjpVf09kLNR6HPqmM2Q41IveRPzP6QYXHUzESUpQsRni4JUozpJB7aFwo4yrEhjCthbqV8yEweaEIsmhDcxZeXSbNacZ2Ke3dRqlXncRTIMTkhZeKS1Ijt6ROGoSTR/JMXsmb9WS9WO/Wx6x1xZrPHJE/sD5/AGPKnKw=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="wT4hwCExk52bi2K5R5kxNMXAuic=">ACEXicbVDJSgNBEO1xjXEb9eilMQjxYJgJgl6EgBePEcwCmRB6OjVJk56F7hohDPMLXvwVLx4U8erNm39jZzlo4oOCx3tVNXzEyk0Os63tbK6tr6xWdgqbu/s7u3bB4dNHaeKQ4PHMlZtn2mQIoIGCpTQThSw0JfQ8kc3E7/1AEqLOLrHcQLdkA0iEQjO0Eg9u+xJCLBMPRSyD1mS02vqBYrxbJRno3M3p54SgyGe9eySU3GmoMvEnZMSmaPes7+8fszTECLkmndcZ0EuxlTKLiEvOilGhLGR2wAHUMjFoLuZtOPcnpqlD4NYmUqQjpVf09kLNR6HPqmM2Q41IveRPzP6QYXHUzESUpQsRni4JUozpJB7aFwo4yrEhjCthbqV8yEweaEIsmhDcxZeXSbNacZ2Ke3dRqlXncRTIMTkhZeKS1Ijt6ROGoSTR/JMXsmb9WS9WO/Wx6x1xZrPHJE/sD5/AGPKnKw=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="wT4hwCExk52bi2K5R5kxNMXAuic=">ACEXicbVDJSgNBEO1xjXEb9eilMQjxYJgJgl6EgBePEcwCmRB6OjVJk56F7hohDPMLXvwVLx4U8erNm39jZzlo4oOCx3tVNXzEyk0Os63tbK6tr6xWdgqbu/s7u3bB4dNHaeKQ4PHMlZtn2mQIoIGCpTQThSw0JfQ8kc3E7/1AEqLOLrHcQLdkA0iEQjO0Eg9u+xJCLBMPRSyD1mS02vqBYrxbJRno3M3p54SgyGe9eySU3GmoMvEnZMSmaPes7+8fszTECLkmndcZ0EuxlTKLiEvOilGhLGR2wAHUMjFoLuZtOPcnpqlD4NYmUqQjpVf09kLNR6HPqmM2Q41IveRPzP6QYXHUzESUpQsRni4JUozpJB7aFwo4yrEhjCthbqV8yEweaEIsmhDcxZeXSbNacZ2Ke3dRqlXncRTIMTkhZeKS1Ijt6ROGoSTR/JMXsmb9WS9WO/Wx6x1xZrPHJE/sD5/AGPKnKw=</latexit>

Cancer cells Pressure Effective growth Cytostatic drug Cytotoxic drug Homeostatic pressure

Follows Perthame, Quirós, Vázquez, Arch. Rat. Mech., 2014

∂tn(t, x, θ) = G(t, x, θ)n(t, x, θ) + νn∆n(t, x, θ) + νpr · (n(t, x, θ)rp(t, x))

<latexit sha1_base64="kl5rvo+OIDVitF38qsK9ESYBpM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ck8pdC+ekZH4nUmSP+ZG7r8lEyk=">AB2XicbZDNSgMxFIXv1L86Vq1rN8EiuCozbnQpuHFZwbZCO5RM5k4bmskMyR2hDH0BF25EfC93vo3pz0JbDwQ+zknIvSculLQUBN9ebWd3b/+gfugfNfzjk9Nmo2fz0gjsilzl5jnmFpXU2CVJCp8LgzyLFfbj6f0i7+gsTLXTzQrMr4WMtUCk7O6oyaraAdLMW2IVxDC9YaNb+GS7KDUJxa0dhEFBUcUNSaFw7g9LiwUXUz7GgUPNM7RtRxzi6dk7A0N+5oYkv394uKZ9bOstjdzDhN7Ga2MP/LBiWlt1EldVESarH6KC0Vo5wtdmaJNChIzRxwYaSblYkJN1yQa8Z3HYSbG29D7odOn4MoA7ncAFXEMIN3MEDdKALAhJ4hXdv4r15H6uat6tDP4I+/zBzjGijg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="79lbLUeEKeSTWvKqDivbnVd0ARI=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="79lbLUeEKeSTWvKqDivbnVd0ARI=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="0VktnM2T82Z3CEgeihG9VBywHow=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="kl5rvo+OIDVitF38qsK9ESYBpM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="kl5rvo+OIDVitF38qsK9ESYBpM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="kl5rvo+OIDVitF38qsK9ESYBpM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="kl5rvo+OIDVitF38qsK9ESYBpM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="kl5rvo+OIDVitF38qsK9ESYBpM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="kl5rvo+OIDVitF38qsK9ESYBpM=">ACgHicbZFtaxNBEMf3zqcan1J96ZvBICQY2zsRKoJQVNCXFUxbyIVjbjNplu7tLbtzYjyOfxevPDCG6SK+jVgYU/v/nP7s5MYbXynCS/ovjGzVu37+zd7d27/+Dho/7+41Nf1U7SRFa6cucFetLK0IQVazq3jrAsNJ0Vlx82+bNv5LyqzFdeWZqVeGHUQknkgPL+j8yiY4U6b3gNZshj+D7OeEmMI3gHn3YAroiBDngBmanzxqwh+0ia8eqKrsEGg8FCI2RyXjEMu742a7d4NMr7g+Qg2QZcF2krBqKNk7z/M5tXsi7JsNTo/TRNLM+aTXNS07qX1Z4syku8oGmQBkvys2Y7wDU8D2QOi8qFYxi29O+KBkvV2URnCXy0ndzG/i/3LTmxZtZo4ytmYzcPbSoNXAFm23AXDmSrFdBoHQq/BXkEh1KDjvrhSGk3Zavi9NXB2nQX14Pjt+349gT8UzMRSpOBLH4rM4ERMhxe9oEI2jl3EcD+PDON1Z46iteSL+ifjtHxA6utY=</latexit>
slide-25
SLIDE 25

The nutrients and the drugs

∈

νs

s (t,

x

) =

  • γs +

1

0 ϕ(θ)

n

(t,

x,

θ)

dθ

  • s

(t,

x

)

,

νc

1

c

1

(t,

x

) =

  • γc

1 +

1

0 µ1

(θ)

n

(t,

x,

θ)

dθ

  • c

1

(t,

x

)

,

νc

2

c

2

(t,

x

) =

  • γc

2 + µ2

1 n

(t,

x,

θ)

dθ

  • c

2

(t,

x

)

. s

(t,

x

)

|

∂0 = S

, c

i

(t,

x

)

|

∂0 =

C

i

, i

=1 , 2

. Cytotoxic drug Cytostatic drug Nutrients Boundary conditions

(following Peng, Trucu, Lin, Thompson, Chaplain, BMB 2016)

slide-26
SLIDE 26

Is this a good model for tumor growth? The emergence of a necrotic core

★

The tumor at t=20 for different motility constants

★

The population increases up to and becomes restricted by the homeostatic pressure after which it starts to expand in space

Increased velocity Increased diffusion

(a) (νn, νp) = (10−6, 10−5) (b) (νn, νp) = (10−5, 10−6) (c) (νn, νp) = (10−4, 10−6)

<latexit sha1_base64="2FRImCFaMe8NiRJCGHVJGn9yOW0=">ACcnicfZHdSsMwGIbT+jfn31Q8UdDoEDqox3b9EQYeOLhBKeDdY40S7ewNC1JKoyC/D2PMqPECzGaFOcUPEl7e7/lI8saPGZXKcd4Mc2l5ZXUt57f2Nza3ins7j3IKBGYtHDEItH2kSMctJSVDHSjgVBoc/Ioz+6mfYfn4mQNOL3ahyTbogGnAYUI6WtXuHFQiXo2Z4NLY8nPW5P97gEr6HlOk/pRX1iw5moTn5S3/X7z2jdczHP+LV+fwXqHolJ1Zwd/CzUQRZNXsFV69foSTkHCFGZKy4zqx6qZIKIoZmeS9RJIY4REakI6WHIVEdtNZBN4rp0+DCKhF1dw5s5PpCiUchz6mgyRGsrF3tT8q9dJVHDVTSmPE0U4/joSBhUEZzmD/tUEKzYWAuEBdV3hXiIBMJK/1Jeh+AuPvm3eKiUXafs3lWLjUoWRw4cgTNgARdcga4BU3QAhi8GwfGsXFifJiH5qmZWca2cw+FGm/QlpSLB0</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="2FRImCFaMe8NiRJCGHVJGn9yOW0=">ACcnicfZHdSsMwGIbT+jfn31Q8UdDoEDqox3b9EQYeOLhBKeDdY40S7ewNC1JKoyC/D2PMqPECzGaFOcUPEl7e7/lI8saPGZXKcd4Mc2l5ZXUt57f2Nza3ins7j3IKBGYtHDEItH2kSMctJSVDHSjgVBoc/Ioz+6mfYfn4mQNOL3ahyTbogGnAYUI6WtXuHFQiXo2Z4NLY8nPW5P97gEr6HlOk/pRX1iw5moTn5S3/X7z2jdczHP+LV+fwXqHolJ1Zwd/CzUQRZNXsFV69foSTkHCFGZKy4zqx6qZIKIoZmeS9RJIY4REakI6WHIVEdtNZBN4rp0+DCKhF1dw5s5PpCiUchz6mgyRGsrF3tT8q9dJVHDVTSmPE0U4/joSBhUEZzmD/tUEKzYWAuEBdV3hXiIBMJK/1Jeh+AuPvm3eKiUXafs3lWLjUoWRw4cgTNgARdcga4BU3QAhi8GwfGsXFifJiH5qmZWca2cw+FGm/QlpSLB0</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="2FRImCFaMe8NiRJCGHVJGn9yOW0=">ACcnicfZHdSsMwGIbT+jfn31Q8UdDoEDqox3b9EQYeOLhBKeDdY40S7ewNC1JKoyC/D2PMqPECzGaFOcUPEl7e7/lI8saPGZXKcd4Mc2l5ZXUt57f2Nza3ins7j3IKBGYtHDEItH2kSMctJSVDHSjgVBoc/Ioz+6mfYfn4mQNOL3ahyTbogGnAYUI6WtXuHFQiXo2Z4NLY8nPW5P97gEr6HlOk/pRX1iw5moTn5S3/X7z2jdczHP+LV+fwXqHolJ1Zwd/CzUQRZNXsFV69foSTkHCFGZKy4zqx6qZIKIoZmeS9RJIY4REakI6WHIVEdtNZBN4rp0+DCKhF1dw5s5PpCiUchz6mgyRGsrF3tT8q9dJVHDVTSmPE0U4/joSBhUEZzmD/tUEKzYWAuEBdV3hXiIBMJK/1Jeh+AuPvm3eKiUXafs3lWLjUoWRw4cgTNgARdcga4BU3QAhi8GwfGsXFifJiH5qmZWca2cw+FGm/QlpSLB0</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="2FRImCFaMe8NiRJCGHVJGn9yOW0=">ACcnicfZHdSsMwGIbT+jfn31Q8UdDoEDqox3b9EQYeOLhBKeDdY40S7ewNC1JKoyC/D2PMqPECzGaFOcUPEl7e7/lI8saPGZXKcd4Mc2l5ZXUt57f2Nza3ins7j3IKBGYtHDEItH2kSMctJSVDHSjgVBoc/Ioz+6mfYfn4mQNOL3ahyTbogGnAYUI6WtXuHFQiXo2Z4NLY8nPW5P97gEr6HlOk/pRX1iw5moTn5S3/X7z2jdczHP+LV+fwXqHolJ1Zwd/CzUQRZNXsFV69foSTkHCFGZKy4zqx6qZIKIoZmeS9RJIY4REakI6WHIVEdtNZBN4rp0+DCKhF1dw5s5PpCiUchz6mgyRGsrF3tT8q9dJVHDVTSmPE0U4/joSBhUEZzmD/tUEKzYWAuEBdV3hXiIBMJK/1Jeh+AuPvm3eKiUXafs3lWLjUoWRw4cgTNgARdcga4BU3QAhi8GwfGsXFifJiH5qmZWca2cw+FGm/QlpSLB0</latexit>

ρ = 1

<latexit sha1_base64="hidsuzb78D82gRKfs5pikXCODL0=">AB7XicbVDLSgNBEOz1GeMr6tHLYBA8hd0g6EUIePEYwTwgWcLsZJKMmZ1ZnqFsOQfvHhQxKv/482/cZLsQRMLGoqbrq7okQKi7/7a2tb2xubRd2irt7+weHpaPjptWpYbzBtNSmHVHLpVC8gQIlbyeG0ziSvBWNb2d+64kbK7R6wEnCw5gOlRgIRtFJza4Z6ZugVyr7FX8OskqCnJQhR71X+ur2NUtjrpBJam0n8BM2pQMmnxW5qeULZmA5x1FY27DbH7tlJw7pU8G2rhSObq74mMxtZO4sh1xhRHdtmbif95nRQH12EmVJIiV2yxaJBKgprMXid9YThDOXGEMiPcrYSNqKEMXUBF0Kw/PIqaVYrgV8J7i/LtWoeRwFO4QwuIArqMEd1KEBDB7hGV7hzdPei/fufSxa17x85gT+wPv8AQ8Ajrk=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="hidsuzb78D82gRKfs5pikXCODL0=">AB7XicbVDLSgNBEOz1GeMr6tHLYBA8hd0g6EUIePEYwTwgWcLsZJKMmZ1ZnqFsOQfvHhQxKv/482/cZLsQRMLGoqbrq7okQKi7/7a2tb2xubRd2irt7+weHpaPjptWpYbzBtNSmHVHLpVC8gQIlbyeG0ziSvBWNb2d+64kbK7R6wEnCw5gOlRgIRtFJza4Z6ZugVyr7FX8OskqCnJQhR71X+ur2NUtjrpBJam0n8BM2pQMmnxW5qeULZmA5x1FY27DbH7tlJw7pU8G2rhSObq74mMxtZO4sh1xhRHdtmbif95nRQH12EmVJIiV2yxaJBKgprMXid9YThDOXGEMiPcrYSNqKEMXUBF0Kw/PIqaVYrgV8J7i/LtWoeRwFO4QwuIArqMEd1KEBDB7hGV7hzdPei/fufSxa17x85gT+wPv8AQ8Ajrk=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="hidsuzb78D82gRKfs5pikXCODL0=">AB7XicbVDLSgNBEOz1GeMr6tHLYBA8hd0g6EUIePEYwTwgWcLsZJKMmZ1ZnqFsOQfvHhQxKv/482/cZLsQRMLGoqbrq7okQKi7/7a2tb2xubRd2irt7+weHpaPjptWpYbzBtNSmHVHLpVC8gQIlbyeG0ziSvBWNb2d+64kbK7R6wEnCw5gOlRgIRtFJza4Z6ZugVyr7FX8OskqCnJQhR71X+ur2NUtjrpBJam0n8BM2pQMmnxW5qeULZmA5x1FY27DbH7tlJw7pU8G2rhSObq74mMxtZO4sh1xhRHdtmbif95nRQH12EmVJIiV2yxaJBKgprMXid9YThDOXGEMiPcrYSNqKEMXUBF0Kw/PIqaVYrgV8J7i/LtWoeRwFO4QwuIArqMEd1KEBDB7hGV7hzdPei/fufSxa17x85gT+wPv8AQ8Ajrk=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="hidsuzb78D82gRKfs5pikXCODL0=">AB7XicbVDLSgNBEOz1GeMr6tHLYBA8hd0g6EUIePEYwTwgWcLsZJKMmZ1ZnqFsOQfvHhQxKv/482/cZLsQRMLGoqbrq7okQKi7/7a2tb2xubRd2irt7+weHpaPjptWpYbzBtNSmHVHLpVC8gQIlbyeG0ziSvBWNb2d+64kbK7R6wEnCw5gOlRgIRtFJza4Z6ZugVyr7FX8OskqCnJQhR71X+ur2NUtjrpBJam0n8BM2pQMmnxW5qeULZmA5x1FY27DbH7tlJw7pU8G2rhSObq74mMxtZO4sh1xhRHdtmbif95nRQH12EmVJIiV2yxaJBKgprMXid9YThDOXGEMiPcrYSNqKEMXUBF0Kw/PIqaVYrgV8J7i/LtWoeRwFO4QwuIArqMEd1KEBDB7hGV7hzdPei/fufSxa17x85gT+wPv8AQ8Ajrk=</latexit>
  • v =
  • 2

νp

G

(θ) ¯

p + νn ∞

r(t)

n

′

r

s ds + ∞

r(t)

n

r

ds,

The velocity of the boundary (radially symmetric tumor):

∂tn(t, x, θ) = G(t, x, θ)n(t, x, θ) + νn∆n(t, x, θ) + νpr · (n(t, x, θ), rp(t, x))

<latexit sha1_base64="AyB5H+zlkDw1zvNwvnR7zC51IDQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="AyB5H+zlkDw1zvNwvnR7zC51IDQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="AyB5H+zlkDw1zvNwvnR7zC51IDQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="AyB5H+zlkDw1zvNwvnR7zC51IDQ=">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</latexit>
slide-27
SLIDE 27

Relapse with resistant colonies

★

The evolution of the mean phenotype. A higher dosage results with a later relapse but with a more resistant tumor

★

The cross section of a radially symmetric tumor with different drug

  • dosages. A higher dosage (cytotoxic

drug) results with a late relapse

slide-28
SLIDE 28

Estimating the time of relapse

★

The time it takes the tumor density to reach trelapse = tK + 1 p 2νpG(θ)˜ p r ρT

M

π − r0 ! , tK ∼ 1 R(θ) − C(θ)

<latexit sha1_base64="4CLxWxEiFgnKel0REqDK+Jgd5w8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="4CLxWxEiFgnKel0REqDK+Jgd5w8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="4CLxWxEiFgnKel0REqDK+Jgd5w8=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="4CLxWxEiFgnKel0REqDK+Jgd5w8=">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</latexit>

ρT

M

<latexit sha1_base64="o3n3Fv+od9ziX5db3LVuki9vBk4=">AB83icbVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/qh69LBbBU0mKoMeCFy9ChX5BE8tmu2mXbnbD7kYoIX/DiwdFvPpnvPlv3LY5aOuDgcd7M8zMCxPOtHdb6e0sbm1vVPereztHxweVY9PulqmitAOkVyqfog15UzQjmG036iKI5DTnvh9Hbu956o0kyKtpklNIjxWLCIEWys5PtqIofZf6YtfNhtebW3QXQOvEKUoMCrWH1yx9JksZUGMKx1gPTUyQYWUY4TSv+KmCSZTPKYDSwWOqQ6yxc05urDKCEVS2RIGLdTfExmOtZ7Foe2MsZnoVW8u/ucNUhPdBkTSWqoIMtFUcqRkWgeABoxRYnhM0swUczeisgEK0yMjaliQ/BWX14n3Ubdc+vew1Wt2SjiKMZnMleHANTbiDFnSAQALP8ApvTuq8O/Ox7K15BQzp/AHzucPXKR1Q=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="o3n3Fv+od9ziX5db3LVuki9vBk4=">AB83icbVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/qh69LBbBU0mKoMeCFy9ChX5BE8tmu2mXbnbD7kYoIX/DiwdFvPpnvPlv3LY5aOuDgcd7M8zMCxPOtHdb6e0sbm1vVPereztHxweVY9PulqmitAOkVyqfog15UzQjmG036iKI5DTnvh9Hbu956o0kyKtpklNIjxWLCIEWys5PtqIofZf6YtfNhtebW3QXQOvEKUoMCrWH1yx9JksZUGMKx1gPTUyQYWUY4TSv+KmCSZTPKYDSwWOqQ6yxc05urDKCEVS2RIGLdTfExmOtZ7Foe2MsZnoVW8u/ucNUhPdBkTSWqoIMtFUcqRkWgeABoxRYnhM0swUczeisgEK0yMjaliQ/BWX14n3Ubdc+vew1Wt2SjiKMZnMleHANTbiDFnSAQALP8ApvTuq8O/Ox7K15BQzp/AHzucPXKR1Q=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="o3n3Fv+od9ziX5db3LVuki9vBk4=">AB83icbVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/qh69LBbBU0mKoMeCFy9ChX5BE8tmu2mXbnbD7kYoIX/DiwdFvPpnvPlv3LY5aOuDgcd7M8zMCxPOtHdb6e0sbm1vVPereztHxweVY9PulqmitAOkVyqfog15UzQjmG036iKI5DTnvh9Hbu956o0kyKtpklNIjxWLCIEWys5PtqIofZf6YtfNhtebW3QXQOvEKUoMCrWH1yx9JksZUGMKx1gPTUyQYWUY4TSv+KmCSZTPKYDSwWOqQ6yxc05urDKCEVS2RIGLdTfExmOtZ7Foe2MsZnoVW8u/ucNUhPdBkTSWqoIMtFUcqRkWgeABoxRYnhM0swUczeisgEK0yMjaliQ/BWX14n3Ubdc+vew1Wt2SjiKMZnMleHANTbiDFnSAQALP8ApvTuq8O/Ox7K15BQzp/AHzucPXKR1Q=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="o3n3Fv+od9ziX5db3LVuki9vBk4=">AB83icbVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/qh69LBbBU0mKoMeCFy9ChX5BE8tmu2mXbnbD7kYoIX/DiwdFvPpnvPlv3LY5aOuDgcd7M8zMCxPOtHdb6e0sbm1vVPereztHxweVY9PulqmitAOkVyqfog15UzQjmG036iKI5DTnvh9Hbu956o0kyKtpklNIjxWLCIEWys5PtqIofZf6YtfNhtebW3QXQOvEKUoMCrWH1yx9JksZUGMKx1gPTUyQYWUY4TSv+KmCSZTPKYDSwWOqQ6yxc05urDKCEVS2RIGLdTfExmOtZ7Foe2MsZnoVW8u/ucNUhPdBkTSWqoIMtFUcqRkWgeABoxRYnhM0swUczeisgEK0yMjaliQ/BWX14n3Ubdc+vew1Wt2SjiKMZnMleHANTbiDFnSAQALP8ApvTuq8O/Ox7K15BQzp/AHzucPXKR1Q=</latexit>

★

The time of relapse for different values of the initial density and the drug dosages

★

The estimate provides a lower bound for the time of relapse c1 = 3, . . . , 8

<latexit sha1_base64="rAsE+Bc0KHeweHJY87/W7wQ7Y0=">AB+XicbVBNS8NAEN3Ur1q/oh69LBbBQylJFexFKHjxWMHWQhvCZrNpl242YXdSKH/xIsHRbz6T7z5b9y2OWjrg4HezPMzAtSwTU4zrdV2tjc2t4p71b29g8Oj+zjk65OMkVZhyYiUb2AaCa4ZB3gIFgvVYzEgWBPwfhu7j9NmNI8kY8wTZkXk6HkEacEjOTbNvVdfIuvagMRJqBrTd+uOnVnAbxO3IJUYG2b38NwoRmMZNABdG67zopeDlRwKlgs8og0ywldEyGrG+oJDHTXr64fIYvjBLiKFGmJOCF+nsiJ7HW0zgwnTGBkV715uJ/Xj+DqOnlXKYZMEmXi6JMYEjwPAYcsUoiKkhCpubsV0RBShYMKqmBDc1ZfXSbdRd526+3BdbTWKOMroDJ2jS+SiG9RC96iNOoiCXpGr+jNyq0X6936WLaWrGLmFP2B9fkDEaWR8A=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="rAsE+Bc0KHeweHJY87/W7wQ7Y0=">AB+XicbVBNS8NAEN3Ur1q/oh69LBbBQylJFexFKHjxWMHWQhvCZrNpl242YXdSKH/xIsHRbz6T7z5b9y2OWjrg4HezPMzAtSwTU4zrdV2tjc2t4p71b29g8Oj+zjk65OMkVZhyYiUb2AaCa4ZB3gIFgvVYzEgWBPwfhu7j9NmNI8kY8wTZkXk6HkEacEjOTbNvVdfIuvagMRJqBrTd+uOnVnAbxO3IJUYG2b38NwoRmMZNABdG67zopeDlRwKlgs8og0ywldEyGrG+oJDHTXr64fIYvjBLiKFGmJOCF+nsiJ7HW0zgwnTGBkV715uJ/Xj+DqOnlXKYZMEmXi6JMYEjwPAYcsUoiKkhCpubsV0RBShYMKqmBDc1ZfXSbdRd526+3BdbTWKOMroDJ2jS+SiG9RC96iNOoiCXpGr+jNyq0X6936WLaWrGLmFP2B9fkDEaWR8A=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="rAsE+Bc0KHeweHJY87/W7wQ7Y0=">AB+XicbVBNS8NAEN3Ur1q/oh69LBbBQylJFexFKHjxWMHWQhvCZrNpl242YXdSKH/xIsHRbz6T7z5b9y2OWjrg4HezPMzAtSwTU4zrdV2tjc2t4p71b29g8Oj+zjk65OMkVZhyYiUb2AaCa4ZB3gIFgvVYzEgWBPwfhu7j9NmNI8kY8wTZkXk6HkEacEjOTbNvVdfIuvagMRJqBrTd+uOnVnAbxO3IJUYG2b38NwoRmMZNABdG67zopeDlRwKlgs8og0ywldEyGrG+oJDHTXr64fIYvjBLiKFGmJOCF+nsiJ7HW0zgwnTGBkV715uJ/Xj+DqOnlXKYZMEmXi6JMYEjwPAYcsUoiKkhCpubsV0RBShYMKqmBDc1ZfXSbdRd526+3BdbTWKOMroDJ2jS+SiG9RC96iNOoiCXpGr+jNyq0X6936WLaWrGLmFP2B9fkDEaWR8A=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="rAsE+Bc0KHeweHJY87/W7wQ7Y0=">AB+XicbVBNS8NAEN3Ur1q/oh69LBbBQylJFexFKHjxWMHWQhvCZrNpl242YXdSKH/xIsHRbz6T7z5b9y2OWjrg4HezPMzAtSwTU4zrdV2tjc2t4p71b29g8Oj+zjk65OMkVZhyYiUb2AaCa4ZB3gIFgvVYzEgWBPwfhu7j9NmNI8kY8wTZkXk6HkEacEjOTbNvVdfIuvagMRJqBrTd+uOnVnAbxO3IJUYG2b38NwoRmMZNABdG67zopeDlRwKlgs8og0ywldEyGrG+oJDHTXr64fIYvjBLiKFGmJOCF+nsiJ7HW0zgwnTGBkV715uJ/Xj+DqOnlXKYZMEmXi6JMYEjwPAYcsUoiKkhCpubsV0RBShYMKqmBDc1ZfXSbdRd526+3BdbTWKOMroDJ2jS+SiG9RC96iNOoiCXpGr+jNyq0X6936WLaWrGLmFP2B9fkDEaWR8A=</latexit>
slide-29
SLIDE 29

Continuous drug vs. on-off

★

Comparing constant and on-off cytotoxic drug administration with the same total drug dosage.

★

Shorter and stronger bursts, lead to the emergence of bigger tumors during the off times, expressing more resistant traits.

E [ n

(t,

x,

θ)] .

=

  • 1

0 θ n

(t,

x,

θ)

dθ

  • 1

0 n

(t,

x,

θ)

dθ

Schedule Normalized # of cells Mean phenotype

slide-30
SLIDE 30

Tumor dynamics and evolution of traits

★

Density and mean resistance level

★

Nutrients and drug are diffused from the top

★

Without the drug sensitive cells grow faster

★

As drug dosage increases, resistant cells become dominant

c=0 c=2 c=4 c=8 Initial Tumor

slide-31
SLIDE 31

Tumor dynamics and evolution of traits

★

Density and mean resistance level

★

Nutrients and drug are diffused from the top

★

Without the drug sensitive cells grow faster

★

As drug dosage increases, resistant cells become dominant

c=0 c=2 c=4 c=8 Initial Tumor

slide-32
SLIDE 32

Emergence of heterogeneity

★

The initial configuration is a uniform phenotype distribution

★

(a) density; (b) mean resistance level. t=40.

★

(c) uniform diffusion of nutrients and drug; (d) diffusion from the top.

slide-33
SLIDE 33

Tumor evolution in a highly heterogeneous nutrients environment

Collective Migration during Cancer Progression

Alexander, S., et al. (2008). Histochemistry and Cell Biology

★

No drugs

★

The environment (following Peng, Trucu, Lin, Thompson, Chaplain, BMB 2016)

★

Irregular boundary. Regular necrotic core

slide-34
SLIDE 34

MDR & continuous level of resistance

(Cho-DL, AMM 2018)

∂tnP (t, θ) = ((1 − w)R(t, θ) − D − CP (t, θ) − q) nP (t, θ) +pnQ(t, θ) + w Z

Γ

M(θ, ϑ)R(t, ϑ)nP (t, ϑ)dϑ, ∂tnQ(t, θ) = qnP (t, θ) + (−p − DQ − CQ(t, θ)) nQ(t, θ).

le θ = (θ1, ..., θM)

CP (t, θ) = Φ(C1, ..., CM) = 1 − Y

i

(1 − Ci),

R(t, θ) = ϕ(θ)s0(t) 1 + Φ(C1, ..., CM).

r Ci(t, θ) = µi(θ)ci(t),

Φ(C1, ..., CM) = X

i

Ci.

Multidrug resistance Proliferating cells Quiescent cells Cytotoxic drugs Cytostatic drugs Can be easily changed

slide-35
SLIDE 35

Competition between healthy cells & cancer cells. (Cho-DL, submitted 2018)

∂tnh(t, θ) = ⇥rh(θ) − dh(θ)ρh(t) − µh(θ)c1(t)⇤ nh − ahc(θ)ρc(t)nh + νh∆θnh, ∂tnc(t, θ) = ⇥rc(θ) − dc(θ)ρc(t) − µc(θ)c1(t) −ϕc(θ)c2(t)⇤ nc − ach(θ)ρh(t)nc + νc∆θnc.

Supercompetitor Normal cell Cancer cell death

Low competition High competition

slide-36
SLIDE 36

Examples

★

Evolution of the cancer cell distribution in the trait space

★

top: quadratic; bottom: linear

★

Combination therapy. 1st drug at t=10. 2nd drug at t=20

Cytotoxic

  • Alt. a = 0.2

Targeted

  • Alt. a = 0.8

model 1

0.5 1 1 0.5

Cytotoxic to Targeted

50 100 150 0.5 1 10 20 30 40 50 0.5 1 10 20 30 40 50 0.5 1 10 20 30 40 50 0.5 1 1 0.5

Targeted to Cytotoxic

50 100 150 0.5 1 10 20 30 40 50 0.5 1 10 20 30 40 50 0.5 1 10 20 30 40 50

model 2

0.5 1 1 0.5

Cytotoxic to Targeted

50 100 150 200 0.5 1 0.002 0.004 0.006 0.008 0.01 0.5 1 0.5 1 1.5 2 10-7 0.5 1 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 10-6 0.5 1 1 0.5

Targeted to Cytotoxic

50 100 150 200 0.5 1 0.5 1 1.5 2 10-3 0.5 1 0.5 1 1.5 2 10-7 0.5 1 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 10-5

★

Evolution of cancer cells & healthy cells

★

Single drug therapy & alternating therapy

★

Drug diffuses from the right

slide-37
SLIDE 37

Conclusion

★

Medical

  • Quantitative approach to therapy
  • Vision: the “science fiction”

★

Math

  • New challenges
  • Can potentially be useful

t

dosage 2 dosage 1

t θ

C1(t) = 2 100 200 1 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.3

t θ

C1(t) = 6 100 200 1 0.5 0.05 0.1

t θ

C1(t) = 8 100 200 1 0.5 0.05 0.1

t θ

C1(t) = 7Cb(t) 100 200 1 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.3

t θ

C1(t) = 16Cb(t) 100 200 1 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.3

t θ

C1(t) = 21Cb(t) 100 200 1 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.3

(b) (c)

The figure to remember