Medical Terminology Management in Evidence Synthesis: Early Versus Late Binding
Craig Whittington, PhD, Sandra Zelman Lewis, PhD, Tobias Sayre, and Robert Battista, MBA
Medical Terminology Management in Evidence Synthesis: Early Versus - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Medical Terminology Management in Evidence Synthesis: Early Versus Late Binding Craig Whittington, PhD, Sandra Zelman Lewis, PhD, Tobias Sayre, and Robert Battista, MBA Disclosures All 3 of us are employed by Doctor Evidence . 2 Outline
Craig Whittington, PhD, Sandra Zelman Lewis, PhD, Tobias Sayre, and Robert Battista, MBA
2
The context Ontology management Why late binding is superior How researchers can benefit
3
– Direct (pairwise) meta-analyses – Network meta analyses (Bayesian, frequentist) – Cohort analyses
4
Involves application of poorly-defined term ontologies,
decisions to group terms Different variables representing what are thought to be the same construct are
together using subjective and poorly-defined criteria These bindings are not easily restorable Does not allow for transparent review of authors' source language and context.
CURRENT STANDARD PRACTICE OF DATA CAPTURE
5
Term, taxonomy, and ontology management system literature Terms are bound after these extractions: “late-binding” Terms can be unbound
Learning system based
Enables data to be captured, stored, and indexed "as is" in the literature
terms and definitions,
synonyms, and
medical ontologies
6
suggests options selected before As appropriate for specific analyses
7
8
VALUE TO HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS
9
High quality data extractions preserving
terms and definitions Granularity
VALUE TO RESEARCHERS
10
Ability to quickly review
terms and definitions in context Filtered and bound
variables, as appropriate for each analysis subgroup analysis Comparative reviews of various
creation of new
Sandra Zelman Lewis, PhD Chief Guidelines Officer slewis@doctorevidence.com Craig Whittington, PhD Global Head of Quality, Methodology, and Innovations cwhittington@doctorevidence.com
11