Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Market Square - - PDF document

harrisburg pennsylvania harrisburg pennsylvania market
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Market Square - - PDF document

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Market Square Plaza Nicole Renno Structural Option 17 North Second Street Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Market Square Plaza Introduction Background


slide-1
SLIDE 1

1

Nicole Renno

Penn State University Architectural Engineering Senior Thesis Presentation

Market Square Plaza

17 North Second Street Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Market Square Plaza

Project Background Structural Redesign

  • Loads
  • Gravity System
  • Lateral System
  • Connections

Building Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Location

17 North 2nd Street Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Market Square Plaza Walnut Street Parking garage Hilton Hotel 2nd Street Walnut Street

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Architecture & Overview:

18 stories, 240’ tall 270,000 square feet of usable space Construction – July 2003 to Spring 2005 $28 million estimated cost Function: Retail, parking, and office space

  • 1st Floor – Retail and restaurant space
  • 2nd Floor – Transfer trusses span 65’ over Hilton

Hotel Ballroom to create a large, open space

  • 3rd to 10th Floors – Parking levels accessed from

adjacent existing parking garage

  • 11th to 18th Floors – Open plan office space

n1

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Typical Floorplan: 132’ x 154’

TYPICAL EXTERIOR & INTERIOR BAYS MEMBERS CONTRIBUTING TO MAIN LATERAL RESISTING SYSTEMS 132’−1" 99’−9" 154’ 22’ 32’−4" 132’

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Design Codes

Original Design – ASCE 7-95 Redesign – ASCE 7-02

Load Changes

Gravity Loads

  • Parking level decreased from 50 psf to 40 psf

Lateral Loads

  • Large increases since ASCE 7-95
  • Overall drift >1.5 times allowable when analyze

according to ASCE 7-02

  • Building site increased from 70 mph wind zone to 90

mph wind zone

  • Site Classification Category A eliminated from code
slide-2
SLIDE 2

2

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Gravity Redesign

Increase Efficiency of Floor System by considering:

  • Direction of framing
  • Number of beams per bay
  • Beam sizes
  • Number of shear studs

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Gravity Redesign: Parking Levels

Original Redesign

W14x22 [9] C=1" W14x22 [9] C=1" W14x22 [9] C=1" W21x44 [17] C=34" W16x26 [14] C=34" W21x44 [17] C=34" W16x26 [14] C=34" W21x44 [17] C=34" W16x26 [14] C=34" W21x44 [17] C=34" W16x26 [14] C=34" 30’−6" 26’ W21x44 [17] C=34" W24x62 [36] 36’−6" W24x68 [26] C=34" W16x26 [14] C=34" W24x76 [32] C=34" 30’−6" 26’ 36’−6" W18x35 [12] C=1−12" W14x22 [9] C=1" W18x35 [12] C=1−12" W16x31 [12] C=2" W16x31 [12] C=2" W18x40 [14] C=1" W21x44 [16] C=1" W21x48 [16] C=1"

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Gravity Redesign: Office Levels

W16x26 [10] W21x44 [17] W16x26 [10] W21x44 [17] W16x26 [10] W21x44 [17] W16x26 [10] W21x44 [17]

Original Redesign

W24x76 [32] W16x26 [10] W24x62 [57] 30’−6" 26’ W21x44 [17] W24x62 [36] 36’−6" 30’−6" 26’ 36’−6" W18x35 [29] C=34" W18x40 [43] C=34" W21x44 [39] C=34" W16x31 [40] C=1−14" W16x26 [46] C=1−12" W16x26 [46] C=1−12" W16x31 [40] C=1−14" W16x26 [16] W16x26 [16] W16x26 [16] W16x26 [16]

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Lateral Redesign

Update frames to resist increased lateral loads Redesign HSS braces as W-shapes so that bolted connections can be utilized Eliminate moment connections

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

North-South Frames

Redesign Original Design

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

East-West Frames

No change in frame configurations Redesign resulted in much larger members

slide-3
SLIDE 3

3

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Typical Bracing Connections

Eliminate costly field welds on braces

4 Angles 2 plates Typ Double Angles Double Angles HSS

Original Redesign

Connection Plate Typ

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Building Enclosure: Existing

7” Precast Concrete Panels

  • Economical
  • Durable
  • Fast Erection
  • High level of quality control

Disadvantages

  • Heavy
  • Could improve upon insulation

characteristics

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Building Enclosure: Redesign

Carbon Fiber Reinforced Precast Concrete Panels

  • Carbon fiber reinforcement in place of secondary

steel reinforcement and shear reinforcement

7" Rebar Carbon Fiber Shear Grid Structural or Architectural Concrete Foam Carbon Fiber Grid Reinforcement Architectural Concrete

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Carbon Fiber Reinforced Panels

Same advantages as traditional precast, Plus:

  • Lighter – lighter supporting members and save on

shipping costs

  • Requires only ¼” of concrete cover
  • Better controls shrinkage cracking
  • Non-corrosive – will not corrode, stain, or spall
  • Higher insulation values up to R-13
  • Same architectural finishes can be obtained

Disadvantages

  • Slightly more expensive, but can be recouped as

energy savings over time

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Budget Impact

Floor System: -$60,400

  • Material: -$48,500
  • Decking: +$31,700
  • Cambering & Shear Studs: +$29,600
  • Labor: -$61,200

Lateral Redesign: +$61,700

  • Member Material: +119,300
  • Moment Connections: -$57,600

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

Recommendations

Remove one beam per bay Remove moment connections in North-South frames Replace HSS braces as W-shapes Redesign frames according to ASCE 7-02 Reconfigure brace connections from welded to bolted Replace tradition precast panels with carbon fiber reinforced precast panels

slide-4
SLIDE 4

4

Introduction Background Structural Loads Gravity Lateral Connections Enclosure Budget Summary Questions

Market Square Plaza Market Square Plaza

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nicole Renno Structural Option

??? Questions ???