SLIDE 1 Fundamental brain theory:
the MAIN challenge to theoretical physics and mathematics of the brain Konstantin Anokhin
Institute for Advanced Brain Studies Lomonosov Moscow State University
“Theoretical physics and mathematics of the brain: Bridges across disciplines and applications”
4-5 December 2019, Moscow
SLIDE 2
Current situation
₋ A burst of neuroscience research ₋ Leads to huge amount of data ₋ Is accompanied by lack of understanding ₋ And desperate need for a fundamental brain theory (FBT)
Theoretical physics and mathematics of the brain
SLIDE 3 What are the requirements for FBT?
FBT
General requirements Specific requirements
maximum (all) data
principles
major biological questions
problem
SLIDE 4 General requirements
“When we say that we understand a group of natural phenomena, we mean that we have found a constructive theory that embraces them.“
"The following requirement for a complete theory seems to be a necessary one: every element of physical reality must have a counterpart in the physical theory"
- A. Einstein, B.Podolsky, N.Rosen. Can quantum-
mechanical description of physical reality be considered complete? Physical Review 47 (1935): 777f
SLIDE 5 Specific requirements: major biological questions
“Biologists ask only three questions of a living organism: − How is it built? − How does it work? − And how did it get that way?” Sydney Brenner
evolution
development
development (unique for brain)
SLIDE 6
Specific requirements: the MAIN problem
“More is different”
Philip Anderson (1972)
SLIDE 7
Specific requirements:
The MAIN problem for FBT is Mind-brAIN problem
Explanatory gap
SLIDE 8 Attempts (among physicists)
Chapter 1. The Physical Basis of Consciousness “A Tentative Answer I would summarize my general hypothesis thus: consciousness is associated with the learning of the living substance.”
SLIDE 9 Attempts (among physicists)
"You, your joys and your sorrows, your memories and your ambitions, your sense of personal identity and free will, are in fact no more than the behavior of a vast assembly of nerve cells and their associated molecules. As Lewis Carroll's Alice might have phrased it: "you're nothing but a pack of neurons."
- F. Crick “The Astonishing Hypothesis”, 1993
SLIDE 10 Attempts (among physicists)
Orchestrated objective reduction (Orch OR) theory
(R.Penrose and S. Hameroff)
Consciousness is based on non-computable quantum processing performed by qubits formed collectively on cellular microtubules, a process significantly amplified in the neurons.
SLIDE 11 Attempts (among physicists)
Integrated information theory
(G.Tononi)
“IIT postulates that conscious experience is a fundamental aspect of reality and is identical to a particular type of information—integrated
- information. Tononi’s theory offers a scientific,
constructive, predictive and mathematically precise form of panpsychism for the 21st
- century. It is a gigantic step in the final
resolution of the ancient mind-body problem.”
SLIDE 12 CURRENT KNOWLEDGE
- Revolution in techniques
- Brain facts
- MAIN facts
SLIDE 13
Revolution in techniques
SLIDE 14
Brain facts
SLIDE 15
Natural neural networks
SLIDE 16
Natural neural networks
SLIDE 17
Natural neural networks
SLIDE 18
Natural neural networks
SLIDE 19
Hippocampal neural network
SLIDE 20 Hippocampal neural network channels information from and to the cortex
cortex (2-3) cortex (4-6)
from Lichtman et al.
SLIDE 21 Hippocampal neural network
c-Fos whole-mount immunohistochemistry
- f the mouse hippocampus after fear conditioning A.Lazutkin et al., 2008
SLIDE 22 “To understand the functioning of a network, one must know its elements and their interconnections. The purpose of this article is to discuss research strategies aimed at a comprehensive structural description of the network of elements and connections forming the human brain. We propose to call this dataset the human “connectome”.”
Sporns et al., (2005), ”The Human Connectome, a structural description of the human brain”
Any brain is connectome
SLIDE 23 Bullmore E. and Sporns O., Nature Reviews, Vol.10, 2009
Analysis of connectomes
SLIDE 24 MAIN facts
“In any field find the most unusual fact and then explore it” J.A. Wheeler
Cognitive specialization of neurons
SLIDE 25 From Quiroga et al., 2009
Implantation sites in the patient brain
SLIDE 26 “Bill Clinton neuron"
Kreiman et al., Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2002. 99(12):8378-83.
Cognitive specialization of neurons in the human brain
SLIDE 27 “Saddam Hussein neuron"
Kreiman et al., Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2002. 99(12):8378-83.
Cognitive specialization of neurons in the human brain
SLIDE 28 From: R.Q. Quiroga (2012) Nat.Rev. Neurosci
“Luke Skywalker neuron"
Cognitive specialization of neurons in the human brain
SLIDE 29 “Jennifer Aniston neuron"
Quiroga et al., Nature. 2005. 435 (7045) 1102-7
- J. Aniston alone
- J. Aniston with a
Husband – Brad Pitt
Cognitive specialization of neurons in the human brain
SLIDE 30 Quiroga et al., Nature. 2005. 435 (7045) 1102-7
LT LT LT SO SО SО SО SО SО SО Sydney Opera LT Lotus Temple New Delhi
Cognitive specialization of neurons in the human brain
SLIDE 31
Cognitive specialization of neurons in the human brain
SLIDE 32
- It is extremely difficult to study these processes in the human brain.
V.B.Shvyrkov, "Systems determination of neuronal activity during behavior" Adv.Physiol.Sci, 14 (1983) 1-27.
- However, similar phenomena exists in the animal brain.
Cognitive specialization of neurons in the animal brain
SLIDE 33 Averkin et al., 2002
SLIDE 34
Summary of requirements
FBT should: ▪ account for plethora (all) neuroscience facts, ▪ AND explain consciousness, ▪ using minimal basic assumptions.
SLIDE 35
Three tentative first principles:
Global Integrative Network
GIN FUS NEM
Functional Systems Network Memory
Repeat… Mind
SLIDE 36
Thank you for attention!