Food Systems Contents DFID Food Systems Learning Journey - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Food Systems Contents DFID Food Systems Learning Journey - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Food Systems Contents DFID Food Systems Learning Journey Foresight4Food Initiative South Asia Food Systems / Food Energy Water Nexus Farmers and Food Systems OSF IFSTAL Principles for Responsible Investment -WBG EU
Contents
- DFID Food Systems Learning Journey
- Foresight4Food Initiative
- South Asia Food Systems / Food Energy Water Nexus
- Farmers and Food Systems – OSF
- IFSTAL
- Principles for Responsible Investment -WBG
- EU Food Systems Interest
- EAT/WEF/WBCSD Food Systems Dialogue
Food security and stability, migration, transparency Inclusive Growth Infrastructur e and innovation key to ag Large employe r Water use,
- n farm solar
Reducing water use in ag, reducing pollution Ag is key to empowerment Food and Nutrition security Healthy Diet Paying for education Sustainably feeding cities Ag impact on biodiversity and soils Demand on fisheries, healthy diets Food waste Climate resilient ag, reducing agifood emissions Inclusive Growth Governance
- f food
systems
Food Systems
DFID
- Purchased food, urbanization and nutrtion
- Food systems in areas of protracted crises
- Realising the inclusive economic value of agri-food systems
- Impact of food crisis on most vulnerable
- Impact of climate and resource decline on food systems
Foresight4Food
Foresgiht4food.net
Food Systems include a set of ‘Activities’ …
Source: The Institute of Medicine & The National Research Council of the National Academies, 2015
… and who all operate influenced a range of ‘Environments’ that drive actor motives.
Or just to attempt to integrate everything!
Migration Violence Unemployment Health costs Poor diet Disease Low productivity Degraded / overused resources Climate impacts Lower yields Erratic production levels Food shortages Price spikes Disease outbreaks Trade restrictions Poverty Competition for resources
Security
Systemic Risks
Environment Health Reduced investment Weakened economy
FOOD
Gender inequality
Mega Trends
- Population
- Urbanization
- Diet
- Climate
- Resource decline
18 29 16 30 37 25 60 54 45
Rapid urbanization & rising middle class…
Projected urban share of global population
Urban
67% 2050
2014
Urban 54%
Source: Ruel et al. 2017
- Nearly 90% of projected urban population increase is concentrated in Asia
and Africa
- China, India, and Nigeria alone expected to add 900 million urban residents
Source: OECD 2010
20 40 60 80 2009 2020 2030 North America Europe Central and South America Asia Pacific
Share of global middle class, 2009-2030 (%)
Source: UN 2014
V
Fruits & Vegetables 49% Cereals and Starches 20% Milk & Milk Products 8% Meat, fish, eggs, beans 20%
V E G O I LOils & Fats 3% Limit
What we should be eating (Harvard's Healthy Eating Plate Model) What we are actually producing (According to 2011 FAO)
Fruits & Vegetables 11% Cereals and Starches 47%
VE G OIL
Oils & Fats 11% Sugar 16% Milk and Milk Products 4% Meat, fish, eggs, beans 11%
WHO< 5% Evan Fraser, Guelph, FBS analysis, 2015
The Lancet Volume 387, Issue 10026, Pages 1377-1396 (April 2016)
Very very obese Very obese Obese Overweight Normal Low normal Underweight Trends in age-standardised prevalence of BMI categories in women, global
Global malnourishment: the food system doesn’t deliver health through diets
Bajzelj et al (2013)
Supply chain logistics
11% cereals trade 60% US grain export 26% cereals trade ~20% fertilisers 14% cereals trade 14% cereals trade ~25% fertilisers (50% China’s soy and wheat)
Global markets affect local events
Knowledge Base to Inform Analysis and Dialogue (5) eg Actors - their Values and Interests (2) Understanding the System of Analysis (7) Trends & Drivers in the System (8) Scenarios (9) Visions (10) Influencing Change (11)
Stakeholder Engagement(4)
Participatory Methods and tools (6)
Quantitative Modelling Qualitative analysis and insight from actors Stakeholder analysis Empirical Evidence
Framework for Understanding Foresight and Scenario Analysis
Real World Situation (1)
Systems analysis
Purpose and Motivation for Foresight (3)
Note: Numbers are for textual description of the framework and are not a series of
- steps. The elements of foresight may be implemented concurrently and/or iteratively
Game Theory (how actors may respond) Data Sets
Woodhill 2018
Rubics Cube of Food Systems Transformation
South Asia Food energy water nexus
Farmers and Food Systems Project
- 12 month project funded by Open Society Foundation
- Updated perspective on long term future for small-scale agriculture in
global food system
- What are the systemic risks?
- What are the transformational opportunities?
- Case studies in Zambia and Ghana
- Exploring foresight, scenario and systems methodology with OSF
partners
- Providing analysis for OSF on future programming
Taking a System View
Smallholder Production value adding and Marketing Systems Rural Livelihoods Policy Influences & Natural Resources & Climate Change Consumption Food Market Systems Global Regional National Local Drivers Trends Issues Opportunities Large Scale farming
How will population, urbanization and diet change Who will produce? What will be traded? How will business models change? What is a living income? What are non-farm incomes? Living income
Transformation of Small-Scale Agriculture
Stepping Up Hanging-In Moving-out
Policies to support small-scale farmers to be commercial and competitive Policies to help farmers trade-up
- r move out
Social protection to help those in poverty Policies to create decent jobs and provide skills Social protection to help those in poverty
What scale of change over what period makes sense ?
Getting the Policy Mix Right Living income
Principles for Responsible INvestment
Implementation Pathways
Institutional Embedding Mobilizing Understanding, Commitment and Capacity
3) Support by Development and Multi- Lateral agencies 6) Embedding in Standards for Private and Public Financing 5) Embedding in Government Policy, Regulation, Programmes and Funding 1) Promotion by Business and Multi-stakeholder Platforms and Round Tables 2) Advocacy by Civil Society and Consumer Groups 4) Embedding in Public and Private Standards for Sourcing and Trade
Application in Business Operations
9) Integration into Business Operations
- f Regional and
Domestic Firms / SMEs / Producers 7) Integration into Business Operations
- f Global Firms
8) Integration into Coordinated Supply Chain and Sector Initiatives
Know How Incentives Know How Incentives Know How Incentives
Conditions and Processes for Implementation
Principles Stakeholder Engagement Capability
for Policy Development And for Technical Implementation
Embedding
in Policies, Standards, and Processes
Use in Decision Making and Operations Monitoring Use and Impacts Incentives
- Profitability
- Access to finance
- Reputational
- Reliability of supply
- Competitive
- Legal
Governance
- Global transparency and
accountability
- International commitments
and agreements
- Stakeholder consultation
- Regional collaboration
- National decision making
- Private sector processes
EU Food systems
EAT/WEF/WBCSD Food Systems Dialogue
V
Fruits & Vegetables 49% Cereals and Starches 20% Milk & Milk Products 8% Meat, fish, eggs, beans 20%
V E G O I LOils & Fats 3% Limit
What we should be eating (Harvard's Healthy Eating Plate Model) What we are actually producing (According to 2011 FAO)
Fruits & Vegetables 11% Cereals and Starches 47%
VE G OIL
Oils & Fats 11% Sugar 16% Milk and Milk Products 4% Meat, fish, eggs, beans 11%
WHO< 5% Evan Fraser, Guelph, FBS analysis, 2015
Rapid urbanization & rising middle class…
Projected urban share of global population
Urban
67% 2050
2014
Urban 54%
Source: Ruel et al. 2017
- Nearly 90% of projected urban population increase is concentrated in Asia
and Africa
- China, India, and Nigeria alone expected to add 900 million urban residents
Source: OECD 2010
20 40 60 80 2009 2020 2030 North America Europe Central and South America Asia Pacific
Share of global middle class, 2009-2030 (%)
Source: UN 2014
The Lancet Volume 387, Issue 10026, Pages 1377-1396 (April 2016)
Very very obese Very obese Obese Overweight Normal Low normal Underweight Trends in age-standardised prevalence of BMI categories in women, global
Global malnourishment: the food system doesn’t deliver health through diets
Bajzelj et al (2013)
Supply chain logistics
11% cereals trade 60% US grain export 26% cereals trade ~20% fertilisers 14% cereals trade 14% cereals trade ~25% fertilisers (50% China’s soy and wheat)
Global markets affect local events
Emerging Issues
- Food safety
- Health costs
- Antimicrobial resistance
- Disease and pest outbreaks
- Food Crises
Technological innovations
Scale-up new, multiple-win technologies
Source: WEF 2018
Blockchain-enabled traceability
- Enhances transparency & traceability of the
food supply chain, land tenure, payments, etc.
- Reduces transaction costs
At the same time, need to consider the impact of these technologies
- n smallholders, children’s nutrition, jobs, etc.
Food-sensing technology
- Contributes to reducing domestic food waste
- Identifies pathogens to improve food safety &
prevent costly product recalls
Alternative proteins
- Can help reduce agricultural GHG emissions
and fresh water withdrawals
- Also alleviate health risks associated with meat
consumption
Gene editing for seed improvements
- Can help produce more crops and increase
farmer incomes
- Also improve nutrition outcomes
What is a Small-Scale Farmer?
- Different land size
- Different assets
- Different incomes
- Different locations
- Different access to markets
- Different skills
- Different livelihoods (sources of income)
- Different interests and motivations
Business models
If Ghana is heading to a population of over 50 million that is 80% urbanized what different business models will emerge for small-scale farmers?
From Production Needs to Business Model Thinking
Business Model Canvass
Question
- In groups of three discuss what you see as different business models
that could emerge over the next 20 years that would benefit smale- scale farmers?
- Who would they be selling to?
- How would the market be organized?
- How would aggregation to achieve economies of scale be organized?