economic approaches to research priority setting
play

Economic approaches to research priority setting Ed Wilson Health - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Feb 14, 2024 •176 likes •333 views

Health Economics Group Health Economics Group Economic approaches to research priority setting Ed Wilson Health Economics Group Introduction Lecturer in Health Economics, University of East Anglia Decision analytic modelling

  1. Health Economics Group Health Economics Group Economic approaches to research priority setting Ed Wilson

  2. Health Economics Group Introduction • Lecturer in Health Economics, University of East Anglia • Decision analytic modelling • Economic evaluation alongside clinical trials • Efficient research design

  3. Health Economics Group Plan • The cycle of evidence (economics?) based medicine • A quantitative approach to research priority setting – Value of information analysis • Methodological research questions – How can we adapt the principles to prioritise Cochrane reviews?

  4. Health Economics Group Cycle of ‘economics based medicine’ Define the decision problem Systematic review & Economic Evaluation Decision: Primary studies (RCT, • Adopt or epidemiological etc) reject new technology? Decision: • More research Value of information analysis worthwhile? End research into current decision problem Wilson & Abrams 2010

  5. Health Economics Group The adoption decision: economic evaluation • The comparison of two or more courses of − C C 2 1 ≤ λ action in terms of their − E E costs and 2 1 consequences 1 £ QALYs ICER New £1,084 1.621 Old £872 1.605 Increment £213 0.015 £14,200 1. Drummond et al. 2005

  6. Health Economics Group From ICERs to Net Benefit − C C 2 1 ≤ λ − E E 2 1 λ − − − ≥ ( E E ) ( C C ) 0 2 1 2 1 λ ∆ − ∆ ≥ E C 0 ≥ INB 0 ≥ b 0

  7. Health Economics Group Approach to economic evaluation • Decision modelling & Monte Carlo Simulation Effectiveness (probabilities) Health state Utilities Costs Decision model (Decision tree, Markov chain etc) Incremental Net Benefit E.g. Briggs, Sculpher & Claxton 2006

  8. Health Economics Group Incremental Net Benefit The research decision: Value of Information Analysis

  9. Health Economics Group The research decision: Value of Information Analysis

  10. Health Economics Group

  11. Health Economics Group Ranking alternative research projects Project Expected Net Benefit of Sampling RCT A £250,000,000 RCT B £100,000,000 RCT C £10,800,000 RCT D £7,350,000 RCT E £1,500,000

  12. Health Economics Group Prioritising Cochrane Reviews – initial thoughts • ENBS of updating a Cochrane review? Decision uncertainty Expected loss Recommendation for new trials

  13. Health Economics Group Prioritising Cochrane Reviews – initial thoughts Define the decision problem Systematic review & Economic Evaluation Decision: Primary studies (RCT, • Adopt or epidemiological etc) reject new technology? Decision: • More research Value of information analysis worthwhile? End research into current decision problem

  14. Health Economics Group Prioritising Cochrane Reviews – initial thoughts • Factors affecting the value of updating a review – Current decision uncertainty – Number of new trials • Specifically number of observations – Cost of the review • Discussion points – International transferability of results – VoI implications • What is the correct scope for a Cochrane review? (Global?) • Possible to generalise for purposes of prioritising? – How much analysis is too much?! • Technical solution vs ‘gut feeling’

  15. Health Economics Group References • Briggs, Sculpher & Claxton 2006. Ch 6, Decision making, uncertaitny and the value of information. In Decision modelling for Health Economic Evaluation . Oxford Handbooks in Health Economic Evaluation 2006. • Briggs, Sculpher & Claxton 2006. Ch 7, Efficient Research Design In Decision modelling for Health Economic Evaluation . Oxford Handbooks in Health Economic Evaluation 2006. Buxton et al. Modelling in economic evaluation: an unavoidable fact of life. Health • Economics 1997;6:217-27 • Sackett, Rosenberg et al. Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn’t. BMJ 1996;312:71-2 Willan & Briggs. Ch6.5 The Value of Information Approach in Statistical Analysis of Cost- • effectiveness Data. Statistics in Practice, Wiley, 2006. • Willan & Pinto The value of information and optimal clinical trial design. Stat Med 2005;24(12):1791-806. • Wilson & Abrams. From evidence based economics to economics based evidence: using systematic review to inform the design of future research. In Shemilt et al. (eds) Evidence- based decisions and economics. 2 nd Edition. Wiley-Blackwell, 2010. Chichester, UK.

Download Presentation
Download Policy: The content available on the website is offered to you 'AS IS' for your personal information and use only. It cannot be commercialized, licensed, or distributed on other websites without prior consent from the author. To download a presentation, simply click this link. If you encounter any difficulties during the download process, it's possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

Recommend

Practical approaches to undertaking research priority setting in health Anneliese Synnot,

Practical approaches to undertaking research priority setting in health Anneliese Synnot,

Practical approaches to undertaking research priority setting in health Anneliese Synnot, Allison Tong, Sophie Hill, Jonathan C Craig Australasian Cochrane Symposium | 25-26 November 2015 | State Library of Victoria, Melbourne Learning

668 views • 23 slides
Results from a Review of CBCRPs Support of Translational Research Priority-Setting Data for

Results from a Review of CBCRPs Support of Translational Research Priority-Setting Data for

Results from a Review of CBCRPs Support of Translational Research Priority-Setting Data for the Translation and Dissemination Program Goal October 11, 2013 Overview of 2015 Priority-Setting Process 1. Review the CBCRP mission statement and

209 views • 20 slides
Priority-Setting Data: Innovation Program Goal DRAFT 10/03/14 Overview of 2015 Priority-Setting

Priority-Setting Data: Innovation Program Goal DRAFT 10/03/14 Overview of 2015 Priority-Setting

Priority-Setting Data: Innovation Program Goal DRAFT 10/03/14 Overview of 2015 Priority-Setting Process 1. Review the CBCRP mission statement and reaffirm the programs foundation of long-term outcomes. 2. Review and revise the priority

447 views • 20 slides
+ When Should the Next CBCRP Priority-Setting Retreat be Held? December 2015 + Should CBCRP

+ When Should the Next CBCRP Priority-Setting Retreat be Held? December 2015 + Should CBCRP

+ When Should the Next CBCRP Priority-Setting Retreat be Held? December 2015 + Should CBCRP hold the next Priority-Setting Retreat in: 5 years / 2020 7 years / 2022 or 10 years / 2025? + Background 2004 Set-aside 30% of research

366 views • 12 slides
Priority-Setting Data: California Specific Program Goal 06/20/14 Overview of 2015

Priority-Setting Data: California Specific Program Goal 06/20/14 Overview of 2015

Priority-Setting Data: California Specific Program Goal 06/20/14 Overview of 2015 Priority-Setting Process 1. Review the CBCRP mission statement and reaffirm the programs foundation of long-term outcomes. 2. Review and revise the priority

834 views • 57 slides
Priority Setting Partnership for Infertility What should infertility research focus on next?

Priority Setting Partnership for Infertility What should infertility research focus on next?

Priority Setting Partnership for Infertility What should infertility research focus on next? Our partnership has brought together healthcare professionals, people with fertility problems, and others to set future priorities for infertility

363 views • 12 slides
1 Sub-brand to go here Knowledge, attitudes and skills for setting research priorities

1 Sub-brand to go here Knowledge, attitudes and skills for setting research priorities

1 Sub-brand to go here Knowledge, attitudes and skills for setting research priorities Research Agenda and Priority Setting Methods 1-2 June 2012, University of Plymouth Sandy Oliver www.ioe.ac.uk/ssru Outline Good practice for

676 views • 23 slides
Setting expectations Economic Evaluation Not possible to be an expert in economic in

Setting expectations Economic Evaluation Not possible to be an expert in economic in

10/9/17 Incorporating Setting expectations Economic Evaluation Not possible to be an expert in economic in Clinical & evaluation in one hour However, you will Translation Research 1) Understand the major types of economic

476 views • 8 slides
Local & Public Global Engagement Research Cultural Priority Plan

Local & Public Global Engagement Research Cultural Priority Plan

Local & Public Global Engagement Research Cultural Priority Plan & Setting & Updated Economic Cultural Impact Policy WE WE ARE ARE HERE HERE PHASE 1 PHASE 2 PHASE 3 SEPT-MAR APR-JUN

1.01k views • 64 slides
Common Needs IPM and organic share common goals Both use systemic approaches Organic and

Common Needs IPM and organic share common goals Both use systemic approaches Organic and

4/2/2015 Common Needs IPM and organic share common goals Both use systemic approaches Organic and IPM priority setting for Organic systems use many IPM practices research, policy and education Organic emphasizes prevention,

631 views • 4 slides
Priority-Setting Data: California Specific Program Goal DRAFT 06/05/14 Overview of 2015

Priority-Setting Data: California Specific Program Goal DRAFT 06/05/14 Overview of 2015

Priority-Setting Data: California Specific Program Goal DRAFT 06/05/14 Overview of 2015 Priority-Setting Process 1. Review the CBCRP mission statement and reaffirm the programs foundation of long-term outcomes. 2. Review and revise the

472 views • 24 slides
Priority-Setting Data for the Capacity Building Program Goal January 2014 Overview of 2015

Priority-Setting Data for the Capacity Building Program Goal January 2014 Overview of 2015

Priority-Setting Data for the Capacity Building Program Goal January 2014 Overview of 2015 Priority-Setting Process 1. Review the CBCRP mission statement and reaffirm the programs foundation of long-term outcomes. 2. Review and revise the

298 views • 17 slides
Evidence-based priority setting for dietary policies Ashkan Afshin, MD MPH MSc ScD November 17,

Evidence-based priority setting for dietary policies Ashkan Afshin, MD MPH MSc ScD November 17,

Evidence-based priority setting for dietary policies Ashkan Afshin, MD MPH MSc ScD November 17, 2016 Acting Assistant Professor of Global Health Policy 1. Defining optimal nutrition Agenda Setting Formulation 2. Quantifying the burden of

470 views • 33 slides
SOCIAL VALUES IN HEALTH PRIORITY SETTING Department of Primary Care and Public Health Sciences

SOCIAL VALUES IN HEALTH PRIORITY SETTING Department of Primary Care and Public Health Sciences

SOCIAL VALUES IN HEALTH PRIORITY SETTING Department of Primary Care and Public Health Sciences Professor Peter Littlejohns & Dr Katharina Kieslich Collaboration for Leadership in Applied Health Research and Care South London (CLAHRC

401 views • 26 slides
Priority setting treatment uncertainties in Prostate Cancer - together Sally Crowe James Lind

Priority setting treatment uncertainties in Prostate Cancer - together Sally Crowe James Lind

James Lind Alliance Priority setting treatment uncertainties in Prostate Cancer - together Sally Crowe James Lind Alliance The James Lind Alliance is funded by the Department of Health and Medical Research Council Our starting point.

243 views • 13 slides
Conclusions No one approach will work for every setting Good to remember all approaches

Conclusions No one approach will work for every setting Good to remember all approaches

Conclusions No one approach will work for every setting Good to remember all approaches involve subjectivity Specific endpoint + composites that summarize effect on multiple endpoints seems like a flexible and powerful combination

214 views • 4 slides
Agenda Background and History What is the new proposal? Why this route? Why for us?

Agenda Background and History What is the new proposal? Why this route? Why for us?

Agenda Background and History What is the new proposal? Why this route? Why for us? Why for SOA? Alternatives- Decision Tree Frequently Asked Questions- FAQs Timeline, How is it implemented etc. History and

469 views • 18 slides
Colorado Assessment Tool Project Purposes and Operationalization of the Intake & Eligibility

Colorado Assessment Tool Project Purposes and Operationalization of the Intake & Eligibility

Colorado Assessment Tool Project Purposes and Operationalization of the Intake & Eligibility Screen 1 Colorado Department of Health Care Policy and Financing Agenda Purposes of the Intake and Eligibility (I&E) Screen Approach

395 views • 14 slides
Evaluation of Park Harrison Brown for R244 Park: An Open Platform for Learning- Augmented

Evaluation of Park Harrison Brown for R244 Park: An Open Platform for Learning- Augmented

Adding the packet classification problem Evaluation of Park Harrison Brown for R244 Park: An Open Platform for Learning- Augmented Platform for researchers to experiment with RL 12 systems problems with an easy to use interface

100 views • 9 slides
Using Openstreetmap crowdsourced data and La Landsat im imagery for la land cover mapping in

Using Openstreetmap crowdsourced data and La Landsat im imagery for la land cover mapping in

Using Openstreetmap crowdsourced data and La Landsat im imagery for la land cover mapping in in th the La Laguna de Bay area of f th the Philippines Brian A. Johnson*, Kotaro lizuka, lsao Endo, Damasa B. Magcale-Macandog, Milben Bragais

389 views • 13 slides
Avenue Tree Appeal Daniel Gho dgho@cityofpacificgrove.org Recommendation Uphold decision of

Avenue Tree Appeal Daniel Gho dgho@cityofpacificgrove.org Recommendation Uphold decision of

1059 Jewell Avenue Tree Appeal Daniel Gho dgho@cityofpacificgrove.org Recommendation Uphold decision of the City Arborist for Tree Permit #19-0135 denying the removal of one Monterey Pine located at 1059 Jewell Avenue, and deny the

393 views • 14 slides
Learning for an Embedded System Decision Trees with Processing and Arduino Lucas Spicer B.S.EE

Learning for an Embedded System Decision Trees with Processing and Arduino Lucas Spicer B.S.EE

Open-Source Machine Learning for an Embedded System Decision Trees with Processing and Arduino Lucas Spicer B.S.EE spicerrobots.com http://karenswhimsy.com/tree-clipart.shtm Machine Learning (ML) A branch of Artificial Intelligence which

461 views • 16 slides
CYBER INCIDENT DETECTION AND RESPONSE DESK REFERENCE OVERVIEW Matt Masterson 1 February 4,

CYBER INCIDENT DETECTION AND RESPONSE DESK REFERENCE OVERVIEW Matt Masterson 1 February 4,

C I S A | C Y B E R S E C U R I T Y A N D I N F R A S T R U C T U R E S E C U R I T Y A G E N C Y CYBER INCIDENT DETECTION AND RESPONSE DESK REFERENCE OVERVIEW Matt Masterson 1 February 4, 2020 Cyber Incident Detection and Agenda 1

240 views • 9 slides
MacroPoint Proprietary Cargo Theft is a Global Issue MacroPoint Proprietary MacroPoint

MacroPoint Proprietary Cargo Theft is a Global Issue MacroPoint Proprietary MacroPoint

MacroPoint Proprietary Cargo Theft is a Global Issue MacroPoint Proprietary MacroPoint Proprietary Whats Needed, I n a Nutshell In-transit vi si b il i ty for every load MacroPoint Proprietary MacroPoint Proprietary Shipper Broker 3PL

534 views • 9 slides

More recommend