SLIDE 1 C R E D I T M A R K E T S
MPA 612: Economy, Society, and Public Policy March 11, 2019
Fill out your reading report
SLIDE 2
P L A N F O R T O D A Y Money and time Barriers to smoothing Monopoly practice
SLIDE 3
SLIDE 4
M O N E Y A N D T I M E
SLIDE 5
What is money?
Something that stores value Something that can be converted into goods and services
SLIDE 6
S T O C K S A N D F L O W S
Wealth
Stock
Income
Flow
Depreciation
Flow
Consumption
Flow
SLIDE 7
SLIDE 8
U N E V E N F L O W S
What should we do with money when flows aren’t steady?
Consumption smoothing
SLIDE 9
SLIDE 10
U N E V E N F L O W S
What should we do with money when flows aren’t steady?
Consumption smoothing
Why do we like smooth flows?
SLIDE 11
Hyperbolic discounting
We prefer immediate payoffs more than future payoffs
SLIDE 12
F I X I N G U N E V E N F L O W S
Move future consumption to the present
Credit; borrowing
Move present consumption to the future
Saving and investing; storing
SLIDE 13
B O R R O W I N G
SLIDE 14
B O R R O W I N G
SLIDE 15
S A V I N G A N D L E N D I N G
SLIDE 16
Do we save too little? Do we spend too little?
SLIDE 17
B A R R I E R S TO S M O OT H I N G
SLIDE 18
Principal agent problems Institutional barriers
B A R R I E R S T O S M O O T H I N G
SLIDE 19
A S Y M M E T R I C I N F O R M A T I O N
Lenders face risk of non-repayment
Adverse selection? Moral hazard? Equity Collateral
SLIDE 20
W E A LT H B E G E T S W E A LT H
Having wealth makes it easy to provide equity and collateral
SLIDE 21
What happens if you don’t have enough wealth to provide equity or collateral? Credit rationing
Credit-constrained Credit-excluded
Lack of wealth begets lack of wealth
SLIDE 22
But nope. Causal arrows are backwards
SLIDE 23
SLIDE 24
SLIDE 25
SLIDE 26 Probability of reaching top 20% income if parents are in bottom 20%
SLIDE 27
SLIDE 28
M O N O P O LY P R A C T I C E
SLIDE 29
Monopolies will underproduce and overcharge Firms should set MR to MC to maximize profit (π) Under perfect competition, MR is the preexisting price Market power lets firms use their own MR curve
SLIDE 30
SLIDE 31 Demand
T H I N G S Y O U N E E D T O F I N D
Total revenue (TR) Marginal revenue (MR)
P = −0.25Q + 50
TR = PQ
TR = (−0.25Q + 50)Q TR = −0.25Q2 + 50Q TR = −0.5Q + 50
Total cost (TC)
P = 0.1Q2 + 3Q + 10
Marginal cost (MC)
MC = 0.2Q + 3
SLIDE 32
S P E C I A L P O I N T S Maximum π MR = MC Social Q and P MC = Demand Max π for monopolist Q from max π; P from demand Maximum revenue MR = 0
SLIDE 33 E L A S T I C I T Y
ε = −% %
<latexit sha1_base64="xfgnSXQJ6YrTYIPXCZP/+XF4v5U=">ACNXicbZBNS8NAEIY3flu/qh69LJaCF0sqgnoQRC9ehApGC0pm82kLm42YXdSLCG/you/w1svHlS8+hfc1h7UdmDh5X1nmJ0nSKUw6LoDZ2Z2bn5hcWm5tLK6tr5R3ty6NUmOXg8kYluBsyAFAo8FCihmWpgcSDhLni4GOZ3PdBGJOoG+ym0Y9ZVIhKcobU65Su/xzSkRshE0VO670ea8dyvUh/hEXPK75nqAhWKhAzFRbF1DVgkNRdMoVt+aOik6K+lhUyLganfKLHyY8i0Ehl8yYVt1NsZ0zjYJLKEp+ZiBl/IF1oWlYjGYdj46u6BV64Q0SrR9CunI/T2Rs9iYfhzYzpjhvfmfDc1pWSvD6LidC5VmCIr/LIoySTGhQ4Y0FBo4yr4VjGth/zpEYcGhJV2yEOr/T54U3kHtpOZeH1bOzsc0lsgO2SV7pE6OyBm5JA3iEU6eyIC8kXfn2Xl1PpzPn9YZzyzTf6U8/UNMeqr2w=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="xfgnSXQJ6YrTYIPXCZP/+XF4v5U=">ACNXicbZBNS8NAEIY3flu/qh69LJaCF0sqgnoQRC9ehApGC0pm82kLm42YXdSLCG/you/w1svHlS8+hfc1h7UdmDh5X1nmJ0nSKUw6LoDZ2Z2bn5hcWm5tLK6tr5R3ty6NUmOXg8kYluBsyAFAo8FCihmWpgcSDhLni4GOZ3PdBGJOoG+ym0Y9ZVIhKcobU65Su/xzSkRshE0VO670ea8dyvUh/hEXPK75nqAhWKhAzFRbF1DVgkNRdMoVt+aOik6K+lhUyLganfKLHyY8i0Ehl8yYVt1NsZ0zjYJLKEp+ZiBl/IF1oWlYjGYdj46u6BV64Q0SrR9CunI/T2Rs9iYfhzYzpjhvfmfDc1pWSvD6LidC5VmCIr/LIoySTGhQ4Y0FBo4yr4VjGth/zpEYcGhJV2yEOr/T54U3kHtpOZeH1bOzsc0lsgO2SV7pE6OyBm5JA3iEU6eyIC8kXfn2Xl1PpzPn9YZzyzTf6U8/UNMeqr2w=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="xfgnSXQJ6YrTYIPXCZP/+XF4v5U=">ACNXicbZBNS8NAEIY3flu/qh69LJaCF0sqgnoQRC9ehApGC0pm82kLm42YXdSLCG/you/w1svHlS8+hfc1h7UdmDh5X1nmJ0nSKUw6LoDZ2Z2bn5hcWm5tLK6tr5R3ty6NUmOXg8kYluBsyAFAo8FCihmWpgcSDhLni4GOZ3PdBGJOoG+ym0Y9ZVIhKcobU65Su/xzSkRshE0VO670ea8dyvUh/hEXPK75nqAhWKhAzFRbF1DVgkNRdMoVt+aOik6K+lhUyLganfKLHyY8i0Ehl8yYVt1NsZ0zjYJLKEp+ZiBl/IF1oWlYjGYdj46u6BV64Q0SrR9CunI/T2Rs9iYfhzYzpjhvfmfDc1pWSvD6LidC5VmCIr/LIoySTGhQ4Y0FBo4yr4VjGth/zpEYcGhJV2yEOr/T54U3kHtpOZeH1bOzsc0lsgO2SV7pE6OyBm5JA3iEU6eyIC8kXfn2Xl1PpzPn9YZzyzTf6U8/UNMeqr2w=</latexit>
ε = −∆Q ∆P × P Q
<latexit sha1_base64="yI1u1ciet4n6Jzb8tEHjz/jSXQ=">ACJXicbVBNS8NAFNzU7/pV9ehlsQheLKkI6kEQ9eAxBWuFpTN9kWXbjZh90UoIb/Gi3/Fi4cqgif/its2gloHFoaZebx9EyRSGHTdD6c0Mzs3v7C4VF5eWV1br2xs3pg41RyaPJaxvg2YASkUNFGghNtEA4sCa2gfzHyWw+gjYjVNQ4S6ETsTolQcIZW6lZO/QemITFCxoqe0n3qh5rxzL8EiYw28m/m5dRHEYEpAl6eNfJyt1J1a+4YdJrUC1IlBbxuZej3Yp5GoJBLZky7ibYyZhGwSXkZT81kDeZ3fQtlQxu7GTjc/M6a5VejSMtX0K6Vj9OZGxyJhBFNhkxPDe/PVG4n9eO8XwuJMJlaQIik8WhamkGNRZ7QnNHCUA0sY18L+lfJ7ZmtA2+yohPrfk6dJ86B2UnMbh9Wz86KNRbJNdsgeqZMjckauiEeahJNH8kyG5NV5cl6cN+d9Ei05xcwW+QXn8wu/JaTv</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yI1u1ciet4n6Jzb8tEHjz/jSXQ=">ACJXicbVBNS8NAFNzU7/pV9ehlsQheLKkI6kEQ9eAxBWuFpTN9kWXbjZh90UoIb/Gi3/Fi4cqgif/its2gloHFoaZebx9EyRSGHTdD6c0Mzs3v7C4VF5eWV1br2xs3pg41RyaPJaxvg2YASkUNFGghNtEA4sCa2gfzHyWw+gjYjVNQ4S6ETsTolQcIZW6lZO/QemITFCxoqe0n3qh5rxzL8EiYw28m/m5dRHEYEpAl6eNfJyt1J1a+4YdJrUC1IlBbxuZej3Yp5GoJBLZky7ibYyZhGwSXkZT81kDeZ3fQtlQxu7GTjc/M6a5VejSMtX0K6Vj9OZGxyJhBFNhkxPDe/PVG4n9eO8XwuJMJlaQIik8WhamkGNRZ7QnNHCUA0sY18L+lfJ7ZmtA2+yohPrfk6dJ86B2UnMbh9Wz86KNRbJNdsgeqZMjckauiEeahJNH8kyG5NV5cl6cN+d9Ei05xcwW+QXn8wu/JaTv</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yI1u1ciet4n6Jzb8tEHjz/jSXQ=">ACJXicbVBNS8NAFNzU7/pV9ehlsQheLKkI6kEQ9eAxBWuFpTN9kWXbjZh90UoIb/Gi3/Fi4cqgif/its2gloHFoaZebx9EyRSGHTdD6c0Mzs3v7C4VF5eWV1br2xs3pg41RyaPJaxvg2YASkUNFGghNtEA4sCa2gfzHyWw+gjYjVNQ4S6ETsTolQcIZW6lZO/QemITFCxoqe0n3qh5rxzL8EiYw28m/m5dRHEYEpAl6eNfJyt1J1a+4YdJrUC1IlBbxuZej3Yp5GoJBLZky7ibYyZhGwSXkZT81kDeZ3fQtlQxu7GTjc/M6a5VejSMtX0K6Vj9OZGxyJhBFNhkxPDe/PVG4n9eO8XwuJMJlaQIik8WhamkGNRZ7QnNHCUA0sY18L+lfJ7ZmtA2+yohPrfk6dJ86B2UnMbh9Wz86KNRbJNdsgeqZMjckauiEeahJNH8kyG5NV5cl6cN+d9Ei05xcwW+QXn8wu/JaTv</latexit>
Coefficient for P if demand curve is written as Q = aP + b
SLIDE 34
Social Q and P Max π Q and P Max revenue Q and P ϵ at P = 20 ϵ at P = 5 Producer/consumer surplus & DWL
: P = −2Q + 60 : P = 0.25Q2 + 10Q + 100
<latexit sha1_base64="mU3xH3IDGHxJav9DncoY1o4Sy+Q=">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</latexit>
SLIDE 35
: P = −1 3Q + 25 : P = 0.1Q2 + 3Q + 50
<latexit sha1_base64="QVKfqu4mWL+GXv9kndjd8CfK2A=">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</latexit>
Social Q and P Max π Q and P Max revenue Q and P ϵ at P = 20 ϵ at P = 5 Producer/consumer surplus & DWL