Presented by: Township of Langley Green Buildings Team Mikhael Horvath – Enforma Engineering Inc Einar Halbig – E3Ecogroup
BUILDER FORUM SERIES: Heat Pumps Best Practices Air Barriers and - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
BUILDER FORUM SERIES: Heat Pumps Best Practices Air Barriers and - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
BUILDER FORUM SERIES: Heat Pumps Best Practices Air Barriers and Step Code Presented by: Township of Langley Green Buildings Team Mikhael Horvath Enforma Engineering Inc Einar Halbig E3Ecogroup Green Buildings Team Community
Green Buildings Team
Kevin Ramlu Green Buildings Manager Sarah Maleska Technical Assistant Robert Baker Assistant Chief Inspector Ajeen Surendran Buildings Energy Specialist
Permitting License and Inspection Community Development Green Buildings
- Update from Township
- Live Polling
- Heat Pump Best Practices
- Air Barriers and Step Code
- Closing
AGENDA
PART 9 – Section F of Compliance Form
- TOL is now requiring Section
F on P9 compliance form to be filled
- Help us track GHG’s and other
metrics relevant to our goals
- Helps inform policy
development
- Modeler has data
Part 3 - Part 3 Energy Design Report
- New provincial form
- Simplifies data
submission and review
- Clarifies mixed use
reporting
- Reach out for any
questions
Free Heat Pump/Forced Air Training
- Retrofit heat pump/forced air installation
training
- Comprehensive training
- FREE for contractors
- On-demand/online
- This will be a PRC requirement in the
future
- Unsure if free in the future
R E G I S T E R A T W W W . H O M E P E R F O R M A N C E T R A I N I N G . C A
A little history
2011:
Adopted the Solar Hot Water Ready Regulation
2014 - 2017: Offered builders the voluntary Green
Building Rebate Program
2018:
Industry stakeholder consultation sessions and workshops to strategize ESC adoption
2019:
Adoption of use of Energy Step Code for new residential construction projects
Onwards and upwards
2021:
Industry consultation for Part 3 non-residential Step Code adoption
2020: •
Assembled Green Buildings Team
- Committed sizeable funding to CleanBC
retrofit program
- UBC Scholar conducted study on Part 3
non-res Step Code adoption
- Monitoring Step Code results
Step Code for Residential Buildings
- 2021
- GHG DPA - Step 3 is required
- NON-GHG DPA - Step 2 is
compliant
- 2022
- GHG DPA – Step 3 is required
- NON-GHG DPA – Step 3 is
required
- 2022 – onwards
- Tracked results will inform future
adoption
Green Building Rebate Program – New Construction
- Township of Langley is a pioneer with GBRP
- GBRP supports going above and beyond
Township + CleanBC Incentives - Retrofit
- TOL + CleanBC have
teamed up
- TOL topping up
- CleanBC DOUBLE
rebate until Dec. 31st
- See CleanBC or TOL
website for details
Green Buildings Energy Specialist
New team member:
- Ajeen Surendran
- Building Permit application reviews
- Models
- Drawings
- Compliance
- Support for building community
- Answer questions etc
- asurendran@tol.ca
Polling time!
- Any internet connected device can be used for voting (if you
don’t have two screens, you may find voting on your phone more convenient)
- Go to menti.com and enter the code on the top bar of the next
screen to vote
- Cast your vote(s) and results will appear automatically on the
screen
*Polling code on next page
Today’s Speakers
Einar Halbig – B.A.Sc., Energy Advisor, Managing Partner, E3 Eco Group Inc. Einar Halbig has over 25 years of education and experience in residential
- construction. He specializes in practical solutions that make a house more
efficient, safe and comfortable. Mikhael Horvath, P.Eng., LEED AP, IDL, Enforma Engineering Inc. Mikhael Horvath is a professional engineer and the president of Enforma Engineering Inc., which specializes in energy code compliance analysis and mechanical design for both Part 9 and Part 3 buildings. QUESTIONS IN CHAT BOX PLEASE
Heat Pumps
Mikhael Horvath, P.Eng.
Heat Pump Basics (the What)
- Fundamentals
- System Variants
Heat Pumps + Step Code (the Why & When)
- Re-cap of key Step Code metrics: TEDI, MEUI, etc.
- The impact of heat pumps on Step Code metrics
Load Calculations & Mechanical System Design (the How)
- Owning the inputs
Strengthening the Case for Heat Pump
- Lessons from history – the pitfalls of over-promising and under-delivering
- Do heat pumps really save owners money?
(Footnote: you’re the Who, and wherever you are in BC can be the Where :-)
Seminar Outline
Heat Pump Fundamentals & Various Configurations
The Refrigeration Cycle Explained (Hopefully :-)
A heat pump is a device capable of moving heat energy in either of two directions. It can move heat from an external source into the controlled environment (heating – see image right) It can move heat out of the external environment into an external heat sink (cooling) NB: the ratio of heat energy moved to energy input is called the Coefficient of Performance.
- Ex. A heat pump that moves 12 kW of heat
energy with an input of 4 kW has a COP of 3.
Air-Source Heat Pumps (ASHP)
Air-to-Air ASHP – Central Air
- Many of the same components as a
furnace except the heat ‘engine’ is the refrigerant based rather than a gas-fired heat exchanger
- Very much like a furnace with AC
- Operational limits vary widely with
manufacturers
- Pros:
- Equipment is not visible
- Ventilation is integral to system
(HRV or not)
- Easily coupled with backup heat
- Cons:
- Large duct distribution req’d (typ.)
- Less readily zoned (typ.)
Air-to-Air ASHP – Ductless Split
- Indoor fancoil unit located in each room
- r connected rooms (typ. wall mounted)
- Operational limits & number of zones
per system vary widely with manufacturer and model
- Simultaneous heat/cool availability
dependent on system type
- Pros:
- Intrinsically highly zoned
- Cons:
- Equipment is visible
- Requires ventilation to be provided
separately
- Backup heat if provided is separate
Air-to-Air ASHP – Ducted Split
- One indoor fancoil unit per zone – recessed
in ceiling and ducted to one or more rooms
- Operational limits & number of zones per
system vary widely with manufacturer and model
- Simultaneous heat/cool availability
dependent on system type
- Pros:
- Intrinsically well zoned
- Equipment is not visible
- Cons:
- Requires ventilation to be provided
separately
- Backup heat if provided is separate
Air-to-Water ASHP
- HP unit in mechanical room supplies hydronic
heating and cooling for distribution by various means
- Operational limits vary widely with mfr.
- Simultaneous heat/cool not available
- Pros:
- Lotsa options – forced air, in-floor, etc.
- Highest efficiencies (COPs)
- Equipment need not be visible
- Easily coupled with backup heat, solar, etc.
- Cons:
- Less readily zoned (typ.)
- Requires ventilation to be provided
separately
- Backup heat if provided is separate
- Simultaneous heat/cool not available
Split DX – Most Any Climate
Air-to-Water ASHP – Dedicated to DHW Heating
Ducted Non-Ducted
Heat Pumps + the BC Energy Step Code
Step Code Performance Criteria
Performance Criteria – Envelope - TEDI
Performance Criteria – Systems - % < ERS
Systems & Equipment Criteria – Option 1
Performance Criteria – Systems - MEUI
Systems & Equipment Criteria – Option 2 (only option for Step 5)
MEUI wrt Mechanical Systems
HVAC characteristics contributing to MEUI
- Heating Efficiency (AFUE, EF, HSPF, COP)
- Space Heating
- Domestic Hot Water
- Cooling Efficiency (EER/SEER, COP)
- Distribution energy
- Furnace fan energy
- HRV fan energy
- Pumping energy
- AC unit fan energy
- Domestic Hot Water Heating Energy
Step Code Performance Criteria - Recap
Load Calculations & Mechanical Design
“If you fail to plan, you are planning to fail.”
~ Benjamin Franklin
Critical: Heating & Cooling Load Calculations
You Own the Inputs (Garbage In = Garbage Out)
- Contractor is Responsible for carrying out load
calculations properly BUT
- You, the builder are responsible for ensuring the
contractor is basing them on the correct inputs
- Key parameters:
- Building envelope assemblies (no brainer)
- Accurate window data <- very important
- Intentional ACH assumption <- very
important
- ‘Conservative assumptions’ are not appropriate
for high performance buildings and will lead to
- ver-sizing of equipment (and its subsequent
myriad of issues)
- You don’t need to be able to do the calculations
but you need to be able to verify they are based
- n the correct inputs
Load Calcs ≠ Mechanical Design
In Theory: Theory = Practice In Practice: Theory ≠ Practice
- Rather, load calcs are one of the first steps in mechanical
design process
- Load calcs + competent installer ≈ mechanical design
- Mechanical design = load calcs + installation plan
Benefits of Full Mechanical Design
- Allows for requiring mechanical
contractors to provide competitive bids with assurance of apples:apples comparison, and enhanced clarity concerning what scope of work.
- Major installation coordination issues
sorted out beforehand rather than on site – no more surprise bulkheads!
- Assurance that equipment selection is
being based on what’s right for the project rather than what may have been done previously or what is most
- profitable. This includes reliable,
- ngoing maintenance/support.
The Process
City of Richmond Step Code Project Approval Process
Design – The Timing Has Never Been Better
Strengthening the Case for Heat Pumps
Over-Promise & Under-Deliver Honesty & Success Builds Trust
Enforma’s Top Three List - Success with Heat Pumps
#3
Understand WHAT heat pump options are available and WHY it is an appropriate choice for your project. Put yourself in a position to answer the following questions:
- How does a heat pump assist with the energy
efficiency targets of the project – MEUI, EnerGuide, etc.?
- Which heat pump system type/configuration
best achieves the comfort and cost criteria of the client?
Enforma’s Top Three List - Success with Heat Pumps
#2
Understand HOW heat pumps (or at least the one you’re considering) perform with regards to energy efficiency,
- perational limitations, and cost savings. Put yourself in a
position to answer the following questions:
- What makes a heat pump so efficient? How does
it work?
- What are the operational limitations (ex. cutoff
temps, simultaneous heat/cool, etc.)
- Will a heat pump save money?
- Efficiency vs. operating cost (not always an
inverse relationship)
Enforma’s Top Three List - Success with Heat Pumps
#1
PLAN to succeed:
- Ensure that a proper load calculation is
- completed. Own the inputs.
- Consider obtaining a complete mechanical
design.
- Employ skilled installing contractors –
Understanding WHY and HOW will put you in a good position to evaluate.
- Verify that equipment being installed has proven
track record AND will have available technical/maintenance support moving forward.
Questions?
Einar Halbig
Managing Partner | E3 Eco Group Inc
- 25 years of experience in residential construction
- Energy Advisor & trainer
- Building Science trainer
- Energy Step Code, implementation committee
member
- CHBA-BC Technical Research Committee, Chair-past
- Canadian Association of Consulting Energy Advisors,
Director & Founding Member
Agenda:
1) Why airtight? 2) Basic premise of air barrier systems 3) Some different air barrier systems 4) Roles and responsibilities 5) Best practices 6) Discussion.
47
1) Recognize that Step Code requires airtightness testing, and there are levels of airtightness which MUST be met 2) Have a plan from the start: which air barrier system to use and how best to implement the details 3) Share knowledge with your Trades and collaborate 4) Have your Energy Advisor perform mid-construction testing to check your progress.
Key Take Aways: “Airtight On Purpose”
BC Energy Step Code- Moving to Net Zero Ready by 2032
Performance Compliance: Langley
Municipal Requirements
Township of Langley 2021: Step 2, or 3 if in DPA BC expected to require Step 3 end of 2021
(2.5ACH@50Pa)
Likely Step 4 by end of 2026 (1.5ACH@50Pa) Step 5 by 2032 (1.0 ACH@50Pa) What is your plan to adapt?
51
1) Typical local houses around 3.5ACH@50Pa 2) Typical rowhouse units around 4.0ACH@50Pa 3) Reminder: Step Code 2 requires 3.0ACH@50Pa, and Step 3 requires 2.5ACH@50Pa
How are we doing so far?
Surprised? What would we expect before mandatory testing?
Airtightness Testing:
Testing will determine compliance, NOT visual checks:
How to Control Air Flow (ie How to Pass your Test)?
- The air barrier system is a
combination of materials installed within a building envelope to control airflow in and out of a building.
- In multi-unit buildings such
as townhome buildings, it also controls airflow between adjacent units.
Airtightness Testing of Rowhouse Units
Each unit will be tested for airtightness. Air leakage through the boundary of each unit gets measured: envelope and party walls.
55
- Required at very end; can also
do mid-construction test
- How sure of your air barrier
details are you?
- Step Code has MANDATORY
airtightness targets
- Airtightness target will get
lower (tighter) over the years.
When to Test
Requirements of an Air Barrier System
Impermeable to air flow Continuous over the entire building
enclosure
Supported Able to withstand the forces that may
act on them during and after construction
Durable over the expected lifetime of
the building.
Source: BC Energy Step Code Builder GuideAir Barrier Components
Air barrier continuity is achieved through good details and the use of a variety of compatible components and sealants.
What are the Air Barrier Components:
What are the Air Barrier Components:
What are the Air Barrier Components:
What are the Air Barrier Components:
Air Barrier Systems (some):
- ADA: air-tight drywall approach
- EIABS: exterior insulation air barrier system
- Local “standard”: polyethylene air/vapour
barrier
- HWABS: house wrap air barrier system.
63
1) There is no single “Air Barrier Trade” 2) Portions of the air barrier are installed by different Trades 3) Trades need good drawing details to follow, and good site instruction 4) Trades people can unwittingly damage the air barrier 5) Easy to miss problems during visual checks 6) But still need to meet the airtightness target.
Challenges of Air Barrier Systems:
Integrated Design Process (IPD)- Apply it to Air Barrier Systems
“It takes a high performance design process to deliver an affordable, comfortable, healthy, sustainable, efficient high performance building.”
Roles and Responsibilities:
Architect: drawing details showing air barrier materials Envelope Engineer: reviewing drawing details, addressing
questions, checking work on site of exterior envelope
Site Superintendent/Air Boss: checking work on site,
getting questions to Architect or Envelope Engineer
Trades: knowing how your role affects the air barrier
system for this particular building; asking questions if not sure
Energy Advisor: testing the mid-construction and final
results.
Better Details:
Air barrier
materials shown and labelled
Air barrier
system shown.
Need a Plan for Continuous Air Barrier System:
Need a Plan for Continuous Air Barrier System:
Common Deficiencies in Air Barriers
Each Trade plays a crucial part in creating and maintaining the building’s air barrier.
- Framer
- Electrician
- Plumber
- HVAC Contractor
- Insulator
- Drywaller
- Sider (if exterior air barrier).
Resources to Help and Learn More:
Township of Langley funding for mid construction
testing
CHBA BC “Building Science for New Homes” course BCIT courses BC Housing Guidelines
71
Mid-Construction Airtightness Testing:
72
Engage your EA During Construction:
73
Engage your EA During Construction:
74
Engage your EA During Construction:
75
- Step 2: 3.0ACH@50Pa = 112 sq inch hole
- Step 3: 2.5ACH@50Pa = 93 sq inch hole
- Step 4: 1.5ACH@50Pa = 56 sq inch hole
Case Study House:
Measured 1.8ACH@50Pa = 65 sq inch hole
76
Only one level of rim joist NO HVAC ducts in attic/outside air barrier Master bedroom floor (over garage) spray foamed NO regular potlights with cans No basement Simple geometry.
What Makes This House Tight:
77
1) Recognize that Step Code requires airtightness testing, and there are levels of airtightness which MUST be met 2) Have a plan from the start: which air barrier system to use and how best to implement the details 3) Share knowledge with your Trades and collaborate 4) Have your Energy Advisor perform mid-construction testing to check your progress.
Key Take Aways: “Airtight On Purpose”
78
Questions? Thank you.
Take aways – Heat Pumps
- Heat pumps are amongst the most potent designs options for
facilitating achievement of Upper Steps of the BC Energy Step Code
- It is important to understand the economics and operational
limits of heat pumps
- Anticipated performance and cost savings have been over-hyped in the
past, leading to both disappointment and a lack of trust in equipment
- Proper mechanical design of a heat pump system and ongoing,
reliable technical support when needed are key to a good installations and happy home owners
Take aways – Air Tightness
- Recognize that Step Code requires airtightness testing, and
there are levels of airtightness which MUST be met
- Have a plan from the start: which air barrier system to use and
how best to implement the details
- Share knowledge with your Trades and collaborate
- Have your Energy Advisor perform mid-construction testing to
check your progress
Credits
- BC Housing CPD - We will send you the proof of attendance Your
registration/sign-in today acts as your proof
- Attendance is tracked – One credit per hour
- AIBC - No work on your part!
- Sarah will send the attendee list to AIBC and they will give you your
LUs
- Tracking attendance
We are here for the long run
The Builder Forum Series is an ongoing program
- See you again early in the new year
Next session planned for early 2021
Acknowledgements
- Mikhael Horvath - mikhael@enforma.ca
- Einar Halbig - einar@e3ecogroup.com
- BC Hydro
- FortisBC
- YOU!
Greenbuildings@tol.ca