All In Webinar: Racial Equity Throughout Data Integration, Part 3 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
All In Webinar: Racial Equity Throughout Data Integration, Part 3 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
All In Webinar: Racial Equity Throughout Data Integration, Part 3 Moderated by Amy Hawn Nelson, Director of Training & Technical Assistance Actionable Intelligence for Social Policy October 14, 2020 Audience Engagement Want to ask a
Audience Engagement
- Want to ask a question to
- ur panelists?
- 1. Navigate to the Control
Panel and click on the “Raise Hand“ icon during the Q&A portion and we can unmute you; or,
- 2. Type into the question
box on the right side of your screen and click the “send” button anytime throughout the webinar
*For technical assistance, please email Miriam Castro at miriam.castro@iphionline.org
Webinar Overview
▪ Introduction to All In ▪ Opening Remarks, Sallie Milam, Network for Public
Health Law
▪ Remarks and Open Discussion with AISP, Children’s
Services Council of Broward County, and Detroit Community Technology Project
▪ Closing and Next Steps
*For technical assistance, please email Miriam Castro at miriam.castro@iphionline.org
All In: Network Mission
Data and Information Sharing Multi-sector Partners Collaborative Effort Outcome: Improved Capacity to Drive Community Health Improvement, Well-being and Racial Health Equity
Support local initiatives that focus on:
Multi-Sector Stakeholders and Data
Past Partners: Community Health Peer Learning Program, Connecting Communities and Care Pew Charitable Trusts Health Impact Project
Current Partners:
All In Learning Network
- Join the All In Online
Community to check out the discussion threads on the Open Forum, start your own, or join an All In Affinity Group
- Sign up to receive our All
In Newsletter for upcoming webinars, funding, newly published resources, and conferences
- Visit the All In website for
more information
Racial Equity and All In
- All In is a learning network: we are learning and
finding together more ways to showcase how to incorporate equitable techniques into and throughout the work
- This webinar is a part of a larger conversation
happening throughout the field and across our All In programming and opportunities
Systemic racism puts Latinx at increased risk of contracting COVID-19
- Latinx are only 18.5% of the US population, but are 29.5% of COVID-19 cases
where race is known
- Latinx are hospitalized from COVID-19 at 4.6X the rate of White people
- Several factors put Latinx at a high risk of contracting COVID-19:
- Language barriers
- Multi-generational homes
- Immigration concerns
- Large percentage of Latinx work as part of the essential workforce in agriculture; and
food manufacturing, wholesale and service
- Less likely to have access to health insurance
- Very low – around 5% - representation in the health care work force which impacts
language and cultural barriers to care
- Pandemic has made existing disparities worse for Latinx: increased food and
housing insecurity
- Source: NIHCM Foundation, Systemic Racism, Disparities & COVID-19:
Impacts on Latino Health.
Strategies for Change
Source: NIHCM Foundation, Systemic Racism, Disparities & COVID-19: Impacts on Latino Health.
Moderator + Speakers
Amy Hawn Nelson Research Faculty and Director of Training and Technical Assistance Actionable Intelligence for Social Policy Sue Gallagher Chief Innovations Officer Children’s Services Council (CSC) of Broward County Tawana Petty Director, Data Justice Project Detroit Community Technology Project
13
We ar are: We ar are no not: t:
Data evangelists Data holders or intermediaries Connectors, community builders, thought partners, cheerleaders, and data sharing therapists A vendor or vendor recommender Focused on ethical data use for policy change Focused on academic research
▪ Convene a professional network for local and state governments working on data integration to share best practices and problem-solve together ▪ Engage in advocacy on behalf of data sharing at the federal, state, and local level ▪ Provide resources and sample documents on data governance, legal considerations, data standards, and linkage technologies ▪ Offer training and technical assistance to help interdisciplinary teams increase state data capacity and use
14
15
▪ Network of 22 operational state and local integrated data systems ▪ Between our three Learning Community cohorts and other sites we support, 14 more sites well on their way
Usable data Insights that drive change People using and
- wning their
agencies data
16
Slide adapted and used with permission from RI Data Ecosystem.
17 Hawn Nelson, A., Jenkins, D., Zanti, S., Katz, M., Berkowitz, E., et al. (2020). A Toolkit for Centering Racial Equity Throughout Data Integration. Actionable Intelligence for Social Policy, University of Pennsylvania.
https: ttps:// //bi bit.ly t.ly/Ce CenterRa nterRacialEquit cialEquit y
Content Overview: Why data infrastructure + racial equity? What are promising and problematic practices in centering racial equity across the data life cycle? What does Work in Action look like? Activities for getting started Lots of resources
Expressed need from sites Learning from Broward County, FL Initial funding from AECF Began to put together workgroup Funding from Sloan and DFC In person workgroup meetings in July and October Finalizing site-based contributors Writing, editing, and review Sharing and disseminatio n Document shifts in site- based practices Learn and share and shift
19
Niiobli Armah My Brother’s Keeper, Equity Intelligence Platform Bridget Blount Baltimore’s Promise Angela Bluhm Chief Education Office, State of Oregon Katy Collins Allegheny County Department of Human Services Sheila Dugan GovEx, Johns Hopkins University Sue Gallagher Broward Data Collaborative, Children’s Services Council of Broward County Laura Jones Writer and Community Advocate based in Minnesota Chris Kingsley Annie E. Casey Foundation Ritika Sharma Kurup StriveTogether Tamika Lewis Our Data Bodies Rick Little Utah Dept of Human Services, Management Information Center Tawana Petty Detroit Community Technology Project & Our Data Bodies Raintry Salk Race Forward and Government Alliance for Racial Equity (GARE) Michelle Shevin Ford Foundation
20
Allegheny County (PA), Department of Human Services, Office of Analytics, Technology, & Planning Samantha Loaney, Brian Bell, Ellen Kitzerow, Julia Reuben, Shannon Flynn, & Jamaal Davis Allegheny County (PA) Department of Human Services, Office of Equity & Inclusion Shauna Lucadamo & Jessica Ruffin Automating.NYC Deepra Yusuf, Elyse Voegeli, Akina Younge, & Jon Truong Birth through Eight Strategy for Tulsa (BEST) Jessica England & Dan Sterba Children’s Services Council of Broward County (FL) Sue Gallagher City of Asheville (NC) Christen McNamara & Kimberlee Archie City of Tacoma (WA) Alison Beason DataWorks NC Libby McClure & John Killeen Kentucky Center for Statistics Jessica Cunningham Mecklenburg County (NC) Community Support Services Courtney LaCaria & Mary Ann Priester New York City Administration for Children’s Services & Youth Studies Programs at the CUNY School of Professional Studies Sarah Zeller-Berkman Take Control Initiative (OK) Emma Swepston, Laura Bellis, & Brandy Hammons
Racism in Data Systems
Racialized Hierarchy Social & Spatial Segregation Deficit Based Narrative
1980’s-2015
- Florida & Nation
- War on drugs-Sentencing for
Blacks results in significant disparity in prison population
- McDuffie Riots in Miami when
police were acquitted of murdering an insurance salesman, Arthur McDuffie
- Racial profiling
- Racial wealth gap due to
redlining into segregated spaces through 1960s legally (still happening today)
- Predatory lending
disproportionally affected people of color
- People of color
disproportionally live in concentrated pockets of poverty
- 20% of African-American
voters in Florida are disenfranchised (i.e., felons)
- 2005 US Senate apologizes for
not passing anti-lynching Bill
- Harvard report on school
segregation showing that 70%
- f African American students
are in segregated schools (2000)
- Community of Promise
- Grassroots Partnerships
- Broward Municipal Services
District Work Plan
- Other
1920s
- 1920s
- White leaders decided it
was bad business to mingle the races
- White tourists did not want
to see Blacks except as help.
- Use of Eminent Domain -
many Black families forced to sell houses East of US 1 for less than the value
- 1922
- Dr. James Sistrunk- Black
Physician arrived
- Planning officials created city
grid that solidified segregation
- City officials restricted
where black families could live and set curfews at 8 pm
- r needed permission from
White people
- Jim Crow practices in effect:
black & white entrances, water fountains, Blacks not able use library, hospital
- Black Beach- substandard
- pen 2 days/week, need ID
- card. Owners not wanting
to see Blacks on the beach
- White Business forced to
leave Colored Town
- The police force and White
Vigilante justice created fear and mistrust
- Black children only allowed
to go to school 3 months of the year once Black only school built in 1924
1930s
- Dillard School went up to
10th grade but had no funding for supplies.
- Black students had to
walk from Oakland Park & Dania to get to school because buses were only for White children
- Black neighborhoods had
no sidewalks and limited sanitation services
- Violence by whites
against blacks was commonplace in the 30s including hangings, shooting, cutting to death.
- Attempt to organize Ft.
Lauderdale's Black businessmen failed because there was not enough Black capital.
- 1937
- Dr. Von D. Mizell arrived
- 1938
- James L. Bass 1st Black
dentist arrived
- 1939
- Ft. Lauderdale's 1st public
housing project build
1940s
- Dr. Mizell requested Library,
park, and beach access, sanitary sewage system, increase police protection; not granted until the 1960s
- 1940
- Segregated Hospital was
created (Provident) – Black doctors were not allowed to do surgery in White hospitals and Blacks could not receive treatment in White hospitals
- 1941
- 1st year black children get 9
months of school- whites fought it wanted them to work in the fields
- 1945
- Dr. Von Mizell and Eula
Johnson founded the Ft. Lauderdale NAACP to fight against police practice of arresting black people at random and making them work in the fields when they could not pay fines.
- 1946
- Federal Government
mandated 9 month school year for Black children
- 1947
- First 2 Black cops were hired
1950s & 1960s
- 1950s Sit ins due to no access
to restaurants, libraries, and beaches.
- 1960 - Alcee Hastings sued
hotels and restaurants to integrate
- 1961
- Voting barriers were in place
for Blacks
- 1963
- Blacks had the legal right to
swim anywhere, yet it took years to integrate, not allowed in restaurants or hotels
- 1964
- Integration of hospitals was
mandated- Blacks received poorer service in White hospital, Black doctors not allowed to work in White hospital, Black doctors lost jobs
- 1966
- Confederate flag in Fort
Lauderdale flown at a protest of Blacks for poor prison conditions.
- NAACP protested "colored
men & women signs" at Fort Lauderdale middle school
- 1969 Fort Lauderdale Riot
1960s & 1970s
- Civil rights movement
prevalent in Ft. Lauderdale
- School desegregation
continues
- KKK maintained a strong
presence & responded violently to freedom rides, sit-ins, & mass demonstrations
- 1973
- Andrew DeGraffenreidt
elected 1st black City Commissioner.
- 1972
- Thomas J. Reddick
appointed 1st black Circuit Court Judge.
- 1974
- K.C.W. (Kathleen C.
Wright), first Black female, elected to the school board
- 1970s - residential
segregation increases as middle-class whites abandoned urban residential areas for new developments in suburbs.
HISTORY OF SEGREGATION & RESISTANCE IN FORT LAUDERDALE (extracted from My Soul is a Witness: A History of Black Fort Lauderdale by Deborah Work)
Child Welfare Juvenile Justice Behavioral Health
Note: Image from Free Child Institute
Community Participatory Action Research with Racial Equity Lens
Design of Anti-Racist Systems
Institutionalize Parent & Youth Feedback Share Governance Co-Research, Co-Imagine, Co-Construct Solutions Together Shared Capacity Building We are all Powerful, Knowledgeable, Compassionate Change Agents Sense of Belonging, Making Contribution
Tawana Petty Director, Data Justice Project Detroit Community Technology Project
Q&A and Discussion
Tawana Petty Detroit Community Technology Project Amy Hawn Nelson Actionable Intelligence for Social Policy Sue Gallagher Children’s Services Council
- f Broward County
Stay connected: Events, Conferences, and more!
- All In National Meeting goes Virtual: Save the date
for Dec 8 - 10!
- All In for a Shared Vision – October 22nd
- See your handout to find out what other