A Comparison of Analysis Techniques for Systematic Instructional - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

▶
a comparison of analysis techniques for systematic
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

A Comparison of Analysis Techniques for Systematic Instructional - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Jul 02, 2023 569 likes •709 views

A Comparison of Analysis Techniques for Systematic Instructional Design BY RICHARD RD THRI RIPP, M M.A. FEBRUARY 15, 2017 PRESENTED IN EME 7634: ADVANCED INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN AT UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL FLORIDA ASSI SIGNMENT NT 3: A ANAL

slide-1
SLIDE 1

A Comparison of Analysis Techniques for Systematic Instructional Design

BY RICHARD RD THRI RIPP, M M.A. FEBRUARY 15, 2017 PRESENTED IN EME 7634: ADVANCED INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN AT UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL FLORIDA ASSI SIGNMENT NT 3: A ANAL ALYSI SIS P S PORTF TFOLIO PRESENT NTATI TION

slide-2
SLIDE 2

Instructional Situation

Calculating your net worth Part of a financial literacy course Objective and subjective

slide-3
SLIDE 3
slide-4
SLIDE 4

Instructional Situation

Learners should be able to calculate their net worth by estimating and tallying the values of their real assets and liabilities.

slide-5
SLIDE 5

Procedural Analysis Overview

  • Overt steps
  • Observable
  • Measurable
  • Antecedents?
  • “Covert” tasks?
  • Complexity?

Source: Jonassen, Tessmer, and Hannum (1999)

slide-6
SLIDE 6

Case-Based Reasoning Overview

  • Stories
  • Real-world (ideally)
  • Captivating
  • Biases?
  • Inappropriate reuse?
  • Novices pick inapplicable cases?

Source: Jonassen, Tessmer, and Hannum (1999)

slide-7
SLIDE 7

Critical Incident Analysis Overview

  • Critical elements
  • Real-world data
  • Stories from SMEs (subject matter experts)
  • Organization?
  • Biases? Omissions?
  • Importance?

Source: Jonassen, Tessmer, and Hannum (1999)

slide-8
SLIDE 8

Net Worth: Procedural Analysis

  • Overt: Listing assets / debts
  • Covert: Remembering them
  • Overt: Appraisal of value
  • Covert: Ideal conditions or fire sale?
  • Overt: Data and formula entry in Excel

Source: Jonassen, Tessmer, and Hannum (1999)

slide-9
SLIDE 9

Net Worth: Case-Based Reasoning

  • Source: Jonassen, Tessmer, and Hannum (1999)
slide-10
SLIDE 10

Net Worth: Case-Based Reasoning

  • Cases can work well
  • Narratives + spreadsheets
  • Engaging
  • Need a good mix of cases
  • Teaches what to include in spreadsheets

Source: Jonassen, Tessmer, and Hannum (1999)

slide-11
SLIDE 11

Net Worth: Critical Incident Analysis

  • Stories show where people go wrong
  • Addresses “what-ifs?”
  • Information on judgments (e.g., car value)
  • Elucidates consequences

Source: Jonassen, Tessmer, and Hannum (1999)

slide-12
SLIDE 12

Net Worth: Comparison of Analyses

  • Procedural: Addresses overt steps;
  • mits covert elements
  • CBR: Humanizes; provides

benchmarks; learners may misinterpret

  • CIA: Provides deeper info from SMEs;

may be incomplete or biased

Source: Jonassen, Tessmer, and Hannum (1999)

slide-13
SLIDE 13

Net Worth: Comparison of Analyses

  • Net worth seems procedural at first
  • But, subjectivity lurks below
  • CBR and CIA may address this
  • Procedural analysis appropriate too—

for the basic steps

Source: Jonassen, Tessmer, and Hannum (1999)