Single and Double Pion Photoproduction
- ff the Deuteron
Manuel Dieterle
Munich, June 13th 2011
2 Collaboration a Single 0 Photoproduction Double 0 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle Munich, June 13 th 2011 XIV International Conference on Hadron Spectroscopy 2 Collaboration a Single 0 Photoproduction Double 0 Photoproduction Outline Motivation
Munich, June 13th 2011
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
◮ Test modern hadron models by studying nucleon resonances
N∗)
γ )
N)
π0)
N) ◮ Small coupling of photons to neutral mesons
Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
◮ Test modern hadron models by studying nucleon resonances
N∗)
γ )
N)
π0)
N) ◮ Small coupling of photons to neutral mesons
Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
◮ Isospin amplitudes of the elm. transitions depend on reactions
◮ meson photoproduction from light nuclei, i.e. deuteron ◮ nuclear effects (rescattering of the mesons, FSI, ...)
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
SAID Data Base - http://gwdac.phys.gwu.edu/ Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
1 2 3 200 400 600 800
x102 γp→πop γd→πonp γd→πod
0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 500 600 700 800
◮ significant reduction in σ/A
◮ can not be explained alone by
◮ nuclear effect? FSI?
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
π0 < 0.6)
◮ can not be explained alone by
◮ nuclear effect? FSI?
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
◮ Photon beam energies up to ∼ 1.4 GeV ◮ Target: ∼ 5 cm LD2 ◮ Detectors:
◮ Crystal Ball (CB): ◮ surrounding the target ◮ Two Arm Photon
◮ placed as forward wall ◮ ∼ 4π steradian Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
Eγ>500 MeV
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
Eγ>500 MeV
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
[MeV]
γ
E
400 600 800 1000 1200 1400
b] µ [ σ
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 p) π ( σ n) π ( σ MAID folded SAID folded
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
[MeV]
γ
E
400 600 800 1000 1200 1400
b] µ [ σ
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 p) π ( σ n) π ( σ MAID folded SAID folded
[MeV]
γ
E
400 600 800 1000 1200 1400
b] µ [ σ
20 40 60 80 100 120 140 np) π ( σ p) π ( σ n) + π ( σ np) B. Krusche et al. π ( σ MAID folded SAID folded
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
γ
p) π ( σ n) π ( σ np) π ( σ 0.8*MAID folded 0.8*SAID folded
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
N*(I=1/2) N(938) ∆(1232)
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
◮ Electromagnetic excitation
◮ Electromagnetic excitation
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
◮ Asymmetry indicates strong
◮ Early results contradicted many
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
Outline Motivation Single π0 Photoproduction Double π0 Photoproduction Conclusions
◮ Cross Sections for Single π0 in good agreement with former
◮ MAID/SAID overestimate the cross sections by 25% ◮ Reduction can not only be explained by Fermi motion
◮ Same asymmetries for 2π0 on the proton as on the neutron ◮ Model predictions not yet in agreement with results, further
◮ Electromagnetic excitation of the resonances different for
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
414 MeV
423 MeV
427 MeV
431 MeV
438 MeV
444 MeV
449 MeV
455 MeV
461 MeV
468 MeV
474 MeV
478 MeV
485 MeV
491 MeV
498 MeV
504 MeV
508 MeV
515 MeV
521 MeV
527 MeV
534 MeV
538 MeV
544 MeV
551 MeV
557 MeV
564 MeV
568 MeV
574 MeV
581 MeV
587 MeV
593 MeV
600 MeV
606 MeV
610 MeV
617 MeV
623 MeV
629 MeV
636 MeV
640 MeV
646 MeV
653 MeV
659 MeV
665 MeV
672 MeV
678 MeV
682 MeV
689 MeV
695 MeV
701 MeV
707 MeV
50 100 20 10 5 5
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
714 MeV
720 MeV
724 MeV
730 MeV
737 MeV
743 MeV
749 MeV
755 MeV
762 MeV
770 MeV
774 MeV
778 MeV
784 MeV
790 MeV
797 MeV
803 MeV
809 MeV
815 MeV
821 MeV
827 MeV
833 MeV
839 MeV
845 MeV
851 MeV
859 MeV
863 MeV
869 MeV
875 MeV
881 MeV
887 MeV
893 MeV
899 MeV
905 MeV
911 MeV
917 MeV
923 MeV
929 MeV
934 MeV
940 MeV
948 MeV
954 MeV
959 MeV
965 MeV
971 MeV
977 MeV
982 MeV
990 MeV
995 MeV
1001 MeV
1007 MeV
4 6.5 4 4 4 2 4
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
1012 MeV
1019 MeV
1025 MeV
1031 MeV
1038 MeV
1043 MeV
1049 MeV
1056 MeV
1061 MeV
1067 MeV
1074 MeV
1079 MeV
1084 MeV
1091 MeV
1097 MeV
1102 MeV
1107 MeV
1114 MeV
1121 MeV
1126 MeV
1133 MeV
1139 MeV
1146 MeV
1151 MeV
1156 MeV
1162 MeV
1169 MeV
1175 MeV
1182 MeV
1188 MeV
1193 MeV
1198 MeV
1204 MeV
1210 MeV
1216 MeV
1222 MeV
1228 MeV
1234 MeV
1240 MeV
1246 MeV
1252 MeV
1258 MeV
1264 MeV
1271 MeV
1278 MeV
1284 MeV
1289 MeV
1295 MeV
1301 MeV
1306 MeV
5 5 2 4 2 2
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
1315 MeV
1320 MeV
1333 MeV
1336 MeV
1339 MeV
1345 MeV
1350 MeV
1356 MeV
1362 MeV
1368 MeV
1374 MeV
1380 MeV
1385 MeV
1391 MeV
1397 MeV 2 2 2 2 2
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
414 MeV
423 MeV
427 MeV
431 MeV
438 MeV
444 MeV
449 MeV
455 MeV
461 MeV
468 MeV
474 MeV
478 MeV
485 MeV
491 MeV
498 MeV
504 MeV
508 MeV
515 MeV
521 MeV
527 MeV
534 MeV
538 MeV
544 MeV
551 MeV
557 MeV
564 MeV
568 MeV
574 MeV
581 MeV
587 MeV
593 MeV
600 MeV
606 MeV
610 MeV
617 MeV
623 MeV
629 MeV
636 MeV
640 MeV
646 MeV
653 MeV
659 MeV
665 MeV
672 MeV
678 MeV
682 MeV
689 MeV
695 MeV
701 MeV
707 MeV
50 10 20 10 5 0.5 1.75 3
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
714 MeV
720 MeV
724 MeV
730 MeV
737 MeV
743 MeV
749 MeV
755 MeV
762 MeV
770 MeV
774 MeV
778 MeV
784 MeV
790 MeV
797 MeV
803 MeV
809 MeV
815 MeV
821 MeV
827 MeV
833 MeV
839 MeV
845 MeV
851 MeV
859 MeV
863 MeV
869 MeV
875 MeV
881 MeV
887 MeV
893 MeV
899 MeV
905 MeV
911 MeV
917 MeV
923 MeV
929 MeV
934 MeV
940 MeV
948 MeV
954 MeV
959 MeV
965 MeV
971 MeV
977 MeV
982 MeV
990 MeV
995 MeV
1001 MeV
1007 MeV
2 4 2 4 2 2 2
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
1012 MeV
1019 MeV
1025 MeV
1031 MeV
1038 MeV
1043 MeV
1049 MeV
1056 MeV
1061 MeV
1067 MeV
1074 MeV
1079 MeV
1084 MeV
1091 MeV
1097 MeV
1102 MeV
1107 MeV
1114 MeV
1121 MeV
1126 MeV
1133 MeV
1139 MeV
1146 MeV
1151 MeV
1156 MeV
1162 MeV
1169 MeV
1175 MeV
1182 MeV
1188 MeV
1193 MeV
1198 MeV
1204 MeV
1210 MeV
1216 MeV
1222 MeV
1228 MeV
1234 MeV
1240 MeV
1246 MeV
1252 MeV
1258 MeV
1264 MeV
1271 MeV
1278 MeV
1284 MeV
1289 MeV
1295 MeV
1301 MeV
1306 MeV
2 2 1 2 1 1
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
1315 MeV
1320 MeV
1333 MeV
1336 MeV
1339 MeV
1345 MeV
1350 MeV
1356 MeV
1362 MeV
1368 MeV
1374 MeV
1380 MeV
1385 MeV
1391 MeV
1397 MeV 0.85 1.5 0.85 1.5 1 1 1
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
414 MeV
423 MeV
427 MeV
431 MeV
438 MeV
444 MeV
449 MeV
455 MeV
461 MeV
468 MeV
474 MeV
478 MeV
485 MeV
491 MeV
498 MeV
504 MeV
508 MeV
515 MeV
521 MeV
527 MeV
534 MeV
538 MeV
544 MeV
551 MeV
557 MeV
564 MeV
568 MeV
574 MeV
581 MeV
587 MeV
593 MeV
600 MeV
606 MeV
610 MeV
617 MeV
623 MeV
629 MeV
636 MeV
640 MeV
646 MeV
653 MeV
659 MeV
665 MeV
672 MeV
678 MeV
682 MeV
689 MeV
695 MeV
701 MeV
707 MeV
50 10 20 10 3.5 6.5 2 4
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
714 MeV
720 MeV
724 MeV
730 MeV
737 MeV
743 MeV
749 MeV
755 MeV
762 MeV
770 MeV
774 MeV
778 MeV
784 MeV
790 MeV
797 MeV
803 MeV
809 MeV
815 MeV
821 MeV
827 MeV
833 MeV
839 MeV
845 MeV
851 MeV
859 MeV
863 MeV
869 MeV
875 MeV
881 MeV
887 MeV
893 MeV
899 MeV
905 MeV
911 MeV
917 MeV
923 MeV
929 MeV
934 MeV
940 MeV
948 MeV
954 MeV
959 MeV
965 MeV
971 MeV
977 MeV
982 MeV
990 MeV
995 MeV
1001 MeV
1007 MeV
4 2.25 3.5 2 3.5 2 2
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
1012 MeV
1019 MeV
1025 MeV
1031 MeV
1038 MeV
1043 MeV
1049 MeV
1056 MeV
1061 MeV
1067 MeV
1074 MeV
1079 MeV
1084 MeV
1091 MeV
1097 MeV
1102 MeV
1107 MeV
1114 MeV
1121 MeV
1126 MeV
1133 MeV
1139 MeV
1146 MeV
1151 MeV
1156 MeV
1162 MeV
1169 MeV
1175 MeV
1182 MeV
1188 MeV
1193 MeV
1198 MeV
1204 MeV
1210 MeV
1216 MeV
1222 MeV
1228 MeV
1234 MeV
1240 MeV
1246 MeV
1252 MeV
1258 MeV
1264 MeV
1271 MeV
1278 MeV
1284 MeV
1289 MeV
1295 MeV
1301 MeV
1306 MeV
2 2 1 2 1 1
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
1315 MeV
1320 MeV
1333 MeV
1336 MeV
1339 MeV
1345 MeV
1350 MeV
1356 MeV
1362 MeV
1368 MeV
1374 MeV
1380 MeV
1385 MeV
1391 MeV
1397 MeV 1 1 1 1 1
)
π CM,
θ cos( b/sr] µ [ Ω /d σ d
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
i (Eγ)
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
[MeV]
γ γm 100 200 300 400 500
Counts [a.u.]
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
310 × + Det.Coinc.
2χ after after Rand.Sub. after MM [MeV]
γ γm 50 100 150 200 Counts [a.u.] 20000 40000 60000
: 137.272
πm FWHM: 21.250
[MeV]
γ γm 100 200 300 400 500
Counts [a.u.]
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
310 × + Det.Coinc. 2 χ after after Rand.Sub. after MM after PID+TOF [MeV]
γ γm 50 100 150 200 Counts [a.u.] 50 100 150
310 ×
: 137.231
πm FWHM: 23.026
[MeV]
γ γm 100 200 300 400 500
Counts [a.u.]
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
310 × + Det.Coinc.
2χ after after Rand.Sub. after MM [MeV]
γ γm 50 100 150 200 Counts [a.u.] 200 400
310 ×
: 137.271
πm FWHM: 22.604
[MeV]
γ γm 100 200 300 400 500 Counts [a.u.] 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
310 × + Det.Coinc.
2χ after after Rand.Sub. after ME after Cop.Cut after strong PID+TOF [MeV]
γ γm 50 100 150 200 Counts [a.u.] 2000 4000 6000 8000
: 134.842
πm FWHM: 19.061
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
◮ Cut on invariant mass: Msecond
γγ
◮ Cut on invariant mass: Mfirst
γγ
◮ γ p → π0π0p ◮ 4 neutral and 1
◮ γ n → π0π0n ◮ 5 neutral hits ◮ γ D → π0π0X ◮ 4 neutral hits or ◮ 5 neutral hits or ◮ 4 neutral and 1
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
◮ (1) Fit signal in side bins
◮ (2) Fit background in signal-bins
◮ Calculate ratio (2)/(1) ◮ Correct online for this background ◮ Ratio (2)/(1) as
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle
π0 DXS π0 Analysis 2π0 Analysis
◮ η → π0π0π0
◮ Peak, Peak +3σ, Peak
Single and Double Pion Photoproduction off the Deuteron Manuel Dieterle