RIPE Address Policy Working Group October 24, 2017 RIPE 75, Dubai - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

RIPE 75 APWG RIPE 75, Dubai 1

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

RIPE Address Policy Working Group

October 24, 2017 RIPE 75, Dubai

WG Chairs: Gert D¨

• ring & Sander Steffann

please remember: this session is webcast

RIPE 75 APWG Agenda

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

APWG Agenda 09:00-10:30

• A. administrative matters

– approving the minutes from RIPE 74 (Budapest)

• C. current policy topics - Marco Schmidt, NCC PDO

– RIPE policy and PDP update, worldwide look

• D. Feedback from NCC Registration Services - Andrea Cima

– discussion with the group

• E. outdated references in policy documents - (Marco Schmidt)

– update on non-progress from the chair

2

RIPE 75 APWG Agenda

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

APWG Agenda 09:00-10:30 II

• F. Discussion of open policy proposals

– 2017-01 Publish statistics on Intra-RIR Legacy updates - withdrawn – 2017-03 Reducing Initial IPv4 Allocation, . . . - withdrawn – 2016-04 IPv6 PI Sub-assignment Clarification

• Y. Open Policy Hour
• Z. AOB

– early warning: Sander Steffan stepping down at RIPE 76

3

RIPE 75 APWG Agenda

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

Agenda Bashing

• do you want to see anything changed?
• is something missing?

4

RIPE 75 APWG administrative matters

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

• A. minutes from RIPE 74 (Budapest)
• have been circulated on the mailing list
• no comments received yet
• feedback? Any inaccuracies that need correcting?

5

RIPE 75 APWG current policy topics

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

• C. current policy topics
• presentation by Marco Schmidt, NCC PDO

6

RIPE 75 APWG current policy topics

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

• D. Feedback From NCC Registration Service
• presentation by Andrea Cima
• feedback from the room?
• followup actions?

7

RIPE 75 APWG current policy topics

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

• E. outdated references in policy documents
• this came up during the AS number cleanup discussion
• WG chairs asked NCC to look into size of the issue
• presentation by Marco Schmidt at RIPE 74 / Budapest
• combine with cleanup for (now-)unused Status: values

(such as “allocated PI” and “NOT SET”)?

• action on the chairs to decide how to move forward
• will take it to the list “really soon now”

8

RIPE 75 APWG

• pen policy proposals

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

• F. Discussion of (open) policy proposals (1)
• 2017-01

– “Publish statistics on Intra-RIR Legacy updates” – withdrawn – not enough support, especially from legacy space holders

9

RIPE 75 APWG

• pen policy proposals

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

• F. Discussion of (open) policy proposals (2)
• 2017-03

– “Reducing Initial IPv4 Allocation, Aiming to Preserve a Minimum of IPv4 Space for Newcomers” – withdrawn – little support – lots of opposition – gist of the proposal unlikely to reach consensus, so no use in tweaking words or numbers

10

RIPE 75 APWG

• pen policy proposals

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

• F. Discussion of open policy proposals (3)
• 2016-04

– “IPv6 PI Sub-assignment Clarification” – new version 2.0 in review phase, reworded criteria – impact analysis posted last week – proposer cannot be here – new version text proxied by WG chairs (next slide) – ... then, feedback

11

RIPE 75 APWG please participate

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

before entering the more interactive part...

• No decisions are made here(!).
• This is to get feedback to the proposers and to get a feel for

the Working Group’s opinions.

• Consensus based process based on the open and public mailing

list.

• please remember to speak into the microphone
• please speak your name, so the scribes can properly attribute

what you said

• the session is webcast, so people who couldn’t come to Dubai

can still be participate

• remote feedback can be provided by IRC

12

RIPE 75 APWG

• pen policy proposals

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

2016-04 v2.0

• 2.6. Assign

... Providing another entity with separate addresses (not prefixes) from a subnet used on a link operated by the assignment holder is not considered a sub-assignment. This includes for example letting visitors connect to the assignment holder’s network, connecting a server or appliance to an assignment holder’s network and setting up point-to-point links with 3rd parties.

• 7. IPv6 Provider Independent (PI) Assignments

... The PI assignment cannot be further sub-assigned to other

• rganisations.

13

RIPE 75 APWG

• pen policy hour

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

• Y. Open Policy Hour
• “The Open Policy Hour is a showcase for your policy ideas. If you

have a policy proposal you’d like to debut, prior to formally submitting it, here is your opportunity.”

14

RIPE 75 APWG creaky chairs again

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

• Z. AOB - WG Chair Selection Procedure
• process defined by consensus on the AP WG mailing list
• one chair stepping down every year (taking turns)
• Sander Steffan to step down at RIPE 76
• . . . done the job since RIPE 54 in Tallinn, May 2007 . . .
• Sander is not volunteering to serve another term
• a new chair is sought...
• decision made by the working group, evaluated by Gert
• Sander and Gert are there to help getting started

15

RIPE 75 APWG what really matters

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

coffee break!

• please be back at 11:00
• and we change over to the side room!

16

RIPE 75 APWG what really matters

✬ ✫ ✩ ✪

coffee break!

• APWG ends here for RIPE 75 - NO second slot
• thanks for your input
• thanks for your help in forming policies in the RIPE region
• . . . enjoy your coffee!
• . . . and we hope to see you all @RIPE76

17