1
Study of Active Mainbelt Object through Sample Acquisition
Summer School Alpbach 2008 BLUE TEAM
2
Outline
- Scientific Background
- Payload
- Mission Profile
- Planetary Protection
- Budgets
- Critical Issues
- Conclusions
Outline Scientific Background Payload Mission Profile - - PDF document
Study of Active Mainbelt Object through Sample Acquisition Summer School Alpbach 2008 BLUE TEAM 1 Outline Scientific Background Payload Mission Profile Planetary Protection Budgets Critical Issues Conclusions
1
Summer School Alpbach 2008 BLUE TEAM
2
3
– Sample return mission to a main belt comet (MBC) – Return a sample of ~50g – In-situ investigation and remote sensing
– MBC are unusual objects and not well understood – They may give us information about:
– Equipment on earth is more precise – More answers could be found – More questions will emerge
176P/ LINEAR
limation of volatiles on the surface:
consecutive apparitions (1996, 2002, 2008), inactivity at
5
It must have been stored below the surface for some 109 a An impact must have exposed it to sunlight recently The crater surface is young (<103 a?) There is no regolith in the crater area
The Themis Family
The MBCs are members of the Themis Family of asteroids:
and TNOs
to an orbit in the Main Belt
The MBC are former members of a now disrupted protoplanet still containing volatiles They are still close to their formation region in the pre-solar disk
The Themis Family
elements and similar spectroscopic properties
body (protoplanet)
8
What to do at the MBC?
What to do on the way to the laboratory?
avoid analysis of terrestrial organics
9
What to do at the MBC?
What to do on the way to the laboratory?
avoid analysis of terrestrial organics
10
Modelling Results for the pre-planetary disk:
Si in minerals as a function of distance from the proto-Sun Concentration of hydrocarbons as a function
the abundance of materials as a function
constrain the conditions in the pre-planetary disk
parameters (turbulence, initial mass, diffusion,...) A sample from a MBC (volatiles and non-volatiles, well
constrained formation region) allows to constrain the
conditions in the pre-planetary disk
11
Temperature versus time in a 20 km-size body.
long times (order Ga): Formation distance from proto-Sun well constrained
Size and nature of the protoplanet parent body is constrained
The time of formation can be determined
temperature regime Maximum temperature/pressure in history can be determined
The burial depth during formation can be constrained
No other object provides such a large number
Modelling Results for Planet Formation:
Correlation between distance from Sun, accretion time, protoplanet diameter, and temperature.
12
available on Earth
bodies of the carbonaceous chondrites A sample from a MBC provides the first link between the meteorite collections on Earth and astronomical objects It is possible to correlate isotopic and elemental composition of different minerals and volatiles (water) in the parent body
13
material properties (internal energy, equation of state,...)
are present in fragments The volatile compostion can constrain the maximum temperature in the body during impact The understanding of the conditions during impacts is important for the history of Earth: What material (water, organics) delivered to Early Earth survives the impact? What is available for the formation of life?
14
D/H in SMOW : 15.6 x 10-5 D/H in water in the cometary coma is twice that value
What organic material was present on the Early Earth? Isotopic analysis in the volatile sample can determine the origin of terrestrial water The laboratory analysis allows to make an inventory of organic matter that came to Earth in Impacts
15
Why return a sample?
Planet Formation Dating Isotopic composition Planet Formation Cooling rate Elemental composition on microscale Origins of Life Organic composition high precision & sensitivity Planet Formation, Protoplanetary disk Microscopic mineral composition high spatial resolution Origins of Life Isotopic ratios in minor volatile species high accuracy and sensitivity
This implies:
The required analysis needs:
16
Imaging
Sample microstructure Optical Microscopy, SEM Sample topography AFM Elemental distribution SEM-EDX, TEM-EELS Cooling rate SEM-EDX, TEM
Bulk and Mineral Composition
Bulk elemental composition ICP-AAS, X-Ray Tomography 3D elemental distribution ToF-SIMS, nano-SIMS Mineral structure TEM, RAMAN, X-ray Diffraction
Volatiles and Organic Compounds
Identification of soluble and volatile compounds GC-MS, HPLC-MS, MALDI Identification of non volatile and non soluble compounds Cluster Ion ToF-SIMS Structure investigations NMR techniques, MS-MS
Isotopic investigations (e.g. Age Dating)
Crystallization age High resolution MS (ICP-MS, nanoSIMS, solid state MS, Laser ablation MS…) Radiation age H/D ration (ice)
17
MBC
Object Radius [km] Period ∆v [km/s] Colours
Elst-Pizarro 3.0 x 2.1 3.5 h 8.8 BVRI LINEAR 2.2 n.a. 8.9 n.a. Read 1.1 n.a. 9.3 n.a.
18
What to do at the MBC?
Drilling – Core Extraction Device
(Lander)
Optical Cameras (HR, WA, stereo)
(Orbiter)
Laser Altimeter + Radio Science
(Orbiter)
Visible-Near-IR spectrometer
(Orbiter)
Mid-IR spectrometer
(Oribter)
Alpha Partice X-ray Spectrometer
(Lander)
Re-entry capsule
Microscopic Imager
(Lander)
19
High Resolution Camera (HRC) Mass: 1.2 kg Dimension: 15x10x10 cm Detector: APS (2k x 2k) Wavelength range: 400 – 900 nm FoV: 1.47 deg Power:2.5 W Data rate: 100kbit/s uncompressed Thermal constrains:
The cameras are used to provide the necessary information about the morphology and topography of the target. They will be used to:
data
Wide Angle Camera (WAC) Mass: 0.3 kg Dimension: 5x5x7 cm Detector: APS (2k x 2k) Wavelength range: 400 – 700 nm FoV: 40x40 deg Power:3 W Data rate: 100kbit/s uncompressed Thermal constrains:
20
Provides the necessary information about the distance of the MSC to the surface
is possible.
Laser Altimeter Mass: 3.3 kg Dimension: 14x12x12 cm Detector: APD diode Wavelength range: 1064 nm FoV: <20 arcsec Power: 15 W Data rate: 150kbit/orbit compressed Thermal constrains: 10 – 40°C operation
21
be obtained
Mid-IR Spectrometer Mass: 2.5 kg Dimension: 15x15x10 cm Detector: uncooled Micro- bolometer Wavelength range: 8-16 µm FoV: 4.0 deg Power:5 W Data rate: 3.6 Mbit/image Thermal constrains:
22
mineralogical and chemical composition
Vis-Near-Infrared Spectrometer Mass: 2.3 kg Dimension: 15x10x5 cm Detector: MCT Wavelength range: 0.4 – 1 µm 1 - 3 µm FoV: 0.25 mrad Power: 8 W Data rate: Close mapping 300 Mbit Thermal constrains:
23
Radio Science Antenna: Ø1.5m HGA Wavelength range: Ka-band (32GHz) X-band (8GHz)
Doppler shift of two downlink radio carrier frequencies (X-band and Ka- band) of the radio subsystem of the MSC, as well as the data of the Laser altimeter and the stereo image, will be applied for that reason
24
(In order to lower the device into the hole and investigate sideward the instrument has to be modified so that the camera has a flexible pointing direction)
Microscope Imager Mass: 0.7 kg Dimension: 10x10x7 cm Ø < 1 cm periscope Detector: APS (2k x2k) Wavelength range: 400-700 nm FoV: 31.5 x 31.5 mm Power: 3 W Data rate: ~50 Mbit/image Thermal constrains:
25
II Gravity assist to Mars
MBC Earth
I Gravity assist to Earth 26
Launcher AR5 ECB (Kourou) Launch Arrival date Transfer time 09 March 2020 15 October 2025 2056 days ( ~5.7y)
propulsion system Transfer Parameter ∆v Launcher ∆v SEP ∆v Chem Propulsion 2236.0 m/s 5311.3 m/s 1656.6 m/s
27
Approach
Sampling
28
Launch target Arrival date Transfer time 01 April 2026 02 June 2030 1523 days (~4.2y) Transfer Parameter ∆v SEP 3360.6 m/s
entry velocity (12.6 km/s)
avoidance maneuver
29
6.1 m 5.1 m 4.31 m 1.7 m 1.7 m lander
30
electric propulsion chemical propulsion antenna re-entry vehicle payload
31
Electrical propulsion ∆v = 8.7 km/s Total Thrust = 400 mN 2 HET thruster PPS500 : 200 mN
4 PPU, 2 High Pressure Flow Control 4 Low pressure Flow Control, 4 Tanks Harness
4 thruster for redundancy
Chemical propulsion Bipropellant (also for the AOCS maneuvers) ∆v = 1.66 km/s Main engine for the ∆v maneuvers EADS 400N Thrust 420±20 N Nominal Mixture ratio 1.65 Mass 3.6 kg Nominal Isp 318s
32
1.1 kW Power supplied (3.4 AU) 44 m2 Panel area 198 kg Panel mass 12.5 kW Power supplied (1 AU) 18 kg Battery Mass 16 Cells number 180 Wh Cell capacity 2.8 kWh Total capacity required
Triple junction GaAs solar cells Deployable and sun-pointing Li-ion cells (20%DoD) Charge control required Discharge control requirements depend on bus architecture Due to high power levels separated power regulation for SEP is required
33
Spacecraft is 3-axis stabilized
target
Sensor (AVGS) to track sample canister during its ascent from the lander
Bradford engineering
34
surface
– engine cooling (variable- conductance heat pipes) – spacecraft cooling (regulated by louvers)
particular instruments
35
36
produce high amount of data (sev. Mbps), which has to be processed quickly
transmitter required
– LEON III Processor (sev. Hundred MIPS, easy scalable, low power) – SpaceWire network (10 Mbit/s -> 200 Mbit/s, easy scalable) – Storage Memory as additional buffer
Lander uses similar but less complex configuration
37
payload anchor drill canister antenna rotating table
38
39
12 m2 Panel area 54 kg Panel mass 134 W Total power supplied (60°) 130 W Total power required 2.2 kg Battery Mass 2 Cells number 180 Wh Cell capacity 308 Wh Total capacity required
Triple junction GaAs solar cells Deployable (60° sun angle considered) Li-ion cells (55%DoD) Charge control required
mechanism (pulse load like) Possibility to perform one drilling attempt immediately after the landing
40
EADS Astrium
41
42
43
Return canister
44
45
46
the sample container and the table is rotated to apply the explosive seal
then transferred into the passive cooling mechanism through the sample transfer tube via a reel mechanism
rotated and sealed and ready for deployment to the return capsule
Return canister
47
Sample Sample container Volatile absorber Support / damper Lid Water/Ice jacket Explosive seal
48
49
absorption material to reduce g- loads
curation facility
Picture from study overview of the near earth asteroid sample return
50
Only remote chance to contaminate the target. → COSPAR Category II
→ COSPAR Category V
Subgroup of Catergory V. i.e. no special Containment and Handling warranted except for scientific purpose.
cleaned to a level below detection limits. i.e. drill, core, sample containment and the legs of the lander
51
Orbiter Mass Budget (Total) System Mass [kg] incl. Margin Lander Module wet mass 249.1 Return Modul wet mass 2293.8 Total Orbit dry mass (launch) 2542.9 Propellant (SEP) 714.5 Propellant (Chem.) 1793.7 Total wet mass 5051.1 Return Module Mass Budget Subsystem Mass [kg] Mass incl. 20% Margin [kg] AOCS 65.49 78.59 OBDH 19.0 22.8
58.4 70.08 Payloads 12.36 14.83 Power System 246.0 295.2 Thermal 87.6 105.1 Propulsion (SEP) 227.0 272.4 Propulsion (Chem.) 422.2 506.7 Structure 282.0 338.4 Mechanism 31.9 38.3 Harness 56.4 67.7 Return Capsule 54.2 65.1 Total dry mass 1562.6 1875.2 Propellant (SEP) 316.8 Propellant (Chem.) 101.8 Total wet mass 2293.8 Lander Mass Budget Subsystem Mass [kg] Mass incl. 20% Margin [kg] AOCS 21.89 26.27 OBDH 3.0 3.6
5.0 6.0 Payloads 2.16 2.59 Sampling System 16.2 19.44 Power System 82.5 99.0 Thermal 8.0 9.6 Structure 37.2 44.64 Mechanism 13.92 16.7 Harness 12.72 15.26 Total dry mass 202.59 243 Propellant (Hydrazine)* 6 Total wet mass 249.1
* The hydrazine is used in the lander AOCS system
52
Lander Power Budget Subs. power in light (W) power in night (W) AOCS* (68) (68) OBDH 5 5 Comm 5 5 Payloads 7 7 Sampling Mech.** (100) (100) Thermal 20 EPS Power required 17 37 Margin (%) 20 20 Total 20.4 44.4
*The power required by AOCS and sampling mechanism are provided by the batteries and considered as pulse loads ** The sampling mechanism is considered a pulse like load and supplied by the batteries Orbiter Power budget Subs. Power (W) Electrical Propulsion 10000 AOCS 129 OBDH 10 Comm. 70 Payloads 35.3 Sampling mech. 10 EPS 5 Thermal 100 Power without margin 10359.3 Margin (%) 20 Total 12431.16
53
54
missions with TRLs ranging from 4 to 9 (Marco-Polo, Exomars, Hayabusa, Bepi Colombo, Planet C, MERs)
List of critical issues for our mission: Availability of AR5 ECB Launcher Vision based guidance system for landing Sampling system Sample ejection and capture system
2009 2010 2014 2018 2020 2030 Phase A Phase B Phase C Phase D Operation Preliminary analysis Preliminary Definition Detailed definition Production and Support Design Ground Based Observation Campaign Ground Qualifcation Testing
55
56
Felix Bexkens Ludivine Boche-Sauvan Guillaume Boubin Carlo Del Vecchino Blanco Mathias Hemberg Mark McCrum Norah Patten Bernhard Schiffer Bernhard Schlappi Christian Schmid Christoph Straif Aurora Ullan Michael Weiler Jana Weise
57
58
kg 54.228 Total dry with marign kg 9.038 % 20 System margin kg 45.19 38.1 Total dry. 1.06 0.48 0.08 20 0.4 Harness 1.46 0.66 0.06 10 0.6 Power 2.55 1.155 0.055 5 1.1 Communication 12.6 5.695 0.695 13.9 5 Mechanisms 45 20.4 3.4 20 17 Thermal Control 37 16.8 2.8 20 14 Structue % kg kg % kg Fraction Total Margin Input Margin Input Mass
59
TPS thickness ~50 mm
Picture from study overview of the near earth asteroid sample return