joint action and the emergence of mindreading
play

Joint Action and the Emergence of Mindreading - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Aug 06, 2023 •209 likes •1.34k views

Joint Action and the Emergence of Mindreading s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution or development, of sophisticated forms of mindreading. challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution or development, of

  1. What is shared intention? Functional characterisation Substantial account shared intention serves to (a) coordinate activities, (b) coordinate planning and (c) structure bargaining

  2. What is shared intention? Functional characterisation Substantial account shared intention serves to We have a shared intention (a) coordinate activities, (b) that we J if coordinate planning and (c) “ 1. (a) I intend that we J and structure bargaining (b) you intend that we J “ 2. I intend that we J in accordance with and because of la, lb, and meshing subplans of la and lb; you intend [likewise] … “ 3. 1 and 2 are common knowledge between us ” (Bratman 1993: View 4)

  3. What is shared intention? Functional characterisation Substantial account shared intention serves to We have a shared intention (a) coordinate activities, (b) that we J if coordinate planning and (c) “ 1. (a) I intend that we J and structure bargaining (b) you intend that we J { “ 2. I intend that we J in accordance with and because of la, lb, and Intentions about intentions meshing subplans of la and lb; you intend [likewise] … “ 3. 1 and 2 are common knowledge between us ” (Bratman 1993: View 4)

  4. What is shared intention? Functional characterisation Substantial account shared intention serves to We have a shared intention (a) coordinate activities, (b) that we J if coordinate planning and (c) “ 1. (a) I intend that we J and structure bargaining (b) you intend that we J { “ 2. I intend that we J in accordance with and because of la, lb, and Intentions about intentions meshing subplans of la and lb; you intend [likewise] … { Knowledge of others ' knowledge “ 3. 1 and 2 are common of intentions about intentions knowledge between us ” (Bratman 1993: View 4)

  5. What is shared intention? Functional characterisation Substantial account shared intention serves to We have a shared intention (a) coordinate activities, (b) that we J if coordinate planning and (c) “ 1. (a) I intend that we J and structure bargaining (b) you intend that we J { “ 2. I intend that we J in accordance with and because of la, lb, and Intentions about intentions meshing subplans of la and lb; you intend [likewise] … { Knowledge of others ' knowledge “ 3. 1 and 2 are common of intentions about intentions knowledge between us ” (Bratman 1993: View 4)

  6. What is shared intention? Functional characterisation Substantial account shared intention serves to We have a shared intention (a) coordinate activities, (b) that we J if coordinate planning and (c) “ 1. (a) I intend that we J and structure bargaining (b) you intend that we J “ 2. I intend that we J in accordance with and because of la, lb, and meshing subplans of la and lb; you intend [likewise] … “ 3. 1 and 2 are common knowledge between us ” (Bratman 1993: View 4)

  7. What is shared intention? Functional characterisation Substantial account shared intention serves to We have a shared intention (a) coordinate activities, (b) that we J if coordinate planning and (c) “ 1. (a) I intend that we J and structure bargaining (b) you intend that we J “ 2. I intend that we J in 'shared intentional agency accordance with and consists, at bottom, in because of la, lb, and interconnected planning meshing subplans of la and agency of the participants.' lb; you intend [likewise] … (Bratman 2011, p. 11) “ 3. 1 and 2 are common knowledge between us ” (Bratman 1993: View 4)

  8. 1. All joint actions require shared intention. 2. Shared intention requires sophisticated mindreading. Therefore: 3. Abilities to engage in joint action could play no significant role in explaining how sophisticated mindreading emerges.

  9. 1. All joint actions require shared intention. 2. Shared intention requires sophisticated mindreading. Therefore: 3. Abilities to engage in joint action could play no significant role in explaining how sophisticated (not why) mindreading emerges.

  10. 1. All joint actions require shared intention. 2. Shared intention requires sophisticated mindreading. Therefore: 3. Abilities to engage in joint action could play no significant role in explaining how sophisticated mindreading emerges.

  11. 1. All joint actions require shared intention. 2. Shared intention requires sophisticated mindreading. Therefore: 3. Abilities to engage in joint action could play no significant role in explaining how sophisticated mindreading emerges.

  12. joint What is the relation between a purposive action and the outcome or outcomes to which it is directed? wave out joint action represents out reach act out shared intention or social grasp motor representation out scratch

  13. joint What is the relation between a purposive action and the outcome or outcomes to which it is directed? wave out joint action represents out reach act out shared intention or social grasp motor representation out scratch

  14. challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution or development, of sophisticated forms of mindreading. conjecture The existence of abilities to engage in joint action partially explains how sophisticated forms of mindreading emerge in evolution or development (or both) 2 nd objection Joint action presupposes sophisticated mindreading

  15. challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution or development, of sophisticated forms of mindreading. conjecture The existence of abilities to engage in joint action partially explains how sophisticated forms of mindreading emerge in evolution or development (or both) 2 nd objection Joint action presupposes sophisticated mindreading

  16. challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution or development, of sophisticated forms of mindreading. conjecture The existence of abilities to engage in joint action partially explains how sophisticated forms of mindreading emerge in evolution or development (or both) first objection Sophisticated forms of mindreading emerge before joint action

  17. mindreading abilities are widespread

  18. mindreading abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs Southgate et al 2007)

  19. mindreading abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs Southgate et al 2007) Scrub-jays selectively re- cache their food in ways that deprive competitors of knowledge of its location (Clayton, Dally & Emery 2007)

  20. mindreading abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs Southgate et al 2007) Scrub-jays selectively re- cache their food in ways that deprive competitors of knowledge of its location (Clayton, Dally & Emery 2007) Chimpanzees conceal their approach from a competitor's (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2006) view, and act in ways that are optimal given what another (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2001) has seen

  21. mindreading abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs Southgate et al 2007) Scrub-jays selectively re- cache their food in ways that deprive competitors of knowledge of its location (Clayton, Dally & Emery 2007) Chimpanzees conceal their approach from a competitor's (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2006) view, and act in ways that are optimal given what another (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2001) has seen

  22. mindreading abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs Southgate et al 2007) In standard false belief tasks, “[t]he subject is aware that he/she and Scrub-jays selectively re- another person witness certain state cache their food in ways that of affairs x. Then, in the absence of deprive competitors of the other person the subject knowledge of its location witnesses an unexpected change in the state of affairs from x to y” Chimpanzees conceal their Wimmer & Perner (1983, p. 106) approach from a competitor's view, and act in ways that are optimal given what another has seen

  23. Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  24. Yellow Green Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  25. Yellow Green Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  26. Yellow Green Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  27. Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  28. Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  29. Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  30. Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  31. Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  32. Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  33. Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  34. Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  35. Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  36. Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

  37. Yuck Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  38. I have to clean Yuck this up Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  39. I have to clean Yuck this up Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  40. I’ll leave my toy I have to here [target clean container] Yuck this up Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  41. I’ll leave my toy I have to here [target clean container] Yuck this up E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  42. I have to clean Yuck this up This is E2. She is cleaning up E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  43. I have to clean Yuck this up E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  44. I have to clean Yuck this up E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  45. I’ll put it [the toy] in my I have to pocket clean Yuck this up E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  46. I have to clean Yuck this up E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  47. I have to clean Yuck this up E1 is coming back E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  48. I have to clean Yuck this up E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

  49. mindreading abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs Southgate et al 2007) Scrub-jays selectively re- cache their food in ways that deprive competitors of knowledge of its location (Clayton, Dally & Emery 2007) Chimpanzees conceal their approach from a competitor's (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2006) view, and act in ways that are optimal given what another (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2001) has seen

  50. mindreading abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs Southgate et al 2007) Scrub-jays selectively re- cache their food in ways that deprive competitors of knowledge of its location (Clayton, Dally & Emery 2007) Chimpanzees conceal their approach from a competitor's (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2006) view, and act in ways that are optimal given what another (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2001) has seen

  51. challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution or development, of sophisticated forms of mindreading. conjecture The existence of abilities to engage in joint action partially explains how sophisticated forms of mindreading emerge in evolution or development (or both) first objection Sophisticated forms of mindreading emerge before joint action

  52. mindreading abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs Southgate et al 2007) Scrub-jays selectively re- cache their food in ways that deprive competitors of knowledge of its location (Clayton, Dally & Emery 2007) Chimpanzees conceal their approach from a competitor's (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2006) view, and act in ways that are optimal given what another (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2001) has seen

  53. mindreading abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs Southgate et al 2007) Scrub-jays selectively re- cache their food in ways that deprive competitors of knowledge of its location (Clayton, Dally & Emery 2007) Chimpanzees conceal their approach from a competitor's (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2006) view, and act in ways that are optimal given what another (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2001) has seen

  54. mindreading abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs Southgate et al 2007) Scrub-jays selectively re- cache their food in ways that deprive competitors of knowledge of its location (Clayton, Dally & Emery 2007) Chimpanzees conceal their approach from a competitor's (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2006) view, and act in ways that are optimal given what another (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2001) has seen

  55. mindreading abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs Southgate et al 2007) Scrub-jays selectively re- cache their food in ways that deprive competitors of knowledge of its location (Clayton, Dally & Emery 2007) Chimpanzees conceal their approach from a competitor's (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2006) view, and act in ways that are optimal given what another (Hare, Call & Tomasello 2001) has seen

Download Presentation
Download Policy: The content available on the website is offered to you 'AS IS' for your personal information and use only. It cannot be commercialized, licensed, or distributed on other websites without prior consent from the author. To download a presentation, simply click this link. If you encounter any difficulties during the download process, it's possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

Recommend

Joint Action and the Emergence of Mindreading s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk challenge Explain

Joint Action and the Emergence of Mindreading s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk challenge Explain

Joint Action and the Emergence of Mindreading s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution or development, of sophisticated forms of theory of mind cognition. challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution or

1.22k views • 97 slides
Intention and Motor Representation in Joint Action s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk &

Intention and Motor Representation in Joint Action s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk &

Joint Action and the Emergence of Mindreading Intention and Motor Representation in Joint Action s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk & corrado.sinigaglia@unimi.it Joint Action and the Emergence of Mindreading Intention and Motor Representation in

1.17k views • 104 slides
Interacting Mindreaders s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution

Interacting Mindreaders s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution

Joint Action and the Emergence of Mindreading Interacting Mindreaders s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution or development, of sophisticated forms of mindreading. conjecture The existence of abilities to

774 views • 36 slides
Which Joint Actions Ground Social Cognition? s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk challenge Explain the

Which Joint Actions Ground Social Cognition? s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk challenge Explain the

Joint Action and the Emergence of Mindreading Which Joint Actions Ground Social Cognition? s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk challenge Explain the emergence, in evolution or development, of sophisticated forms of mindreading. conjecture The

1.24k views • 91 slides
Mindreading and Joint Action Theory of mind abilities are widespread Theory of mind abilities are

Mindreading and Joint Action Theory of mind abilities are widespread Theory of mind abilities are

Mindreading and Joint Action Theory of mind abilities are widespread Theory of mind abilities are widespread 18-month-olds point to (Liszkowski et al 2006) inform, and predict actions (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005; based on false beliefs

869 views • 82 slides
What are modules? & what is their role in development? s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk Outline

What are modules? & what is their role in development? s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk Outline

Joint Action & the Emergence of Mindreading What are modules? & what is their role in development? s.butterfill@warwick.ac.uk Outline Why we need a notion of modularity (0) There is a problemcurrent accounts of modularity are

951 views • 81 slides
Co-production in Action: perspectives from Emergence a service user led organisation Jane

Co-production in Action: perspectives from Emergence a service user led organisation Jane

Co-production in Action: perspectives from Emergence a service user led organisation Jane Jackson Project Manager Emergence Co-production in Action Who are Emergence? What do we do and how do we do it? Examples of Co-production

518 views • 16 slides
perspectives from Emergence a service user led organisation Jane Jackson Project Manager

perspectives from Emergence a service user led organisation Jane Jackson Project Manager

Co-production in Action: perspectives from Emergence a service user led organisation Jane Jackson Project Manager Emergence Co-production in Action Who are Emergence? What do we do and how do we do it? Examples of Co-production

601 views • 16 slides
Jake Saper, Emergence Capital @jakesaper @jakesaper, Emergence Capital 1 A Bit on Me

Jake Saper, Emergence Capital @jakesaper @jakesaper, Emergence Capital 1 A Bit on Me

Jake Saper, Emergence Capital @jakesaper @jakesaper, Emergence Capital 1 A Bit on Me @jakesaper, Emergence Capital 2 Emergence: A Track Record of Identifying Themes that Impact the Future of Work 2004 Today Horizontal Cloud Industry

746 views • 37 slides
Entrepreneurship in Action: From Idea to Opportunity {II} Means-Ends Framework in Action:

Entrepreneurship in Action: From Idea to Opportunity {II} Means-Ends Framework in Action:

Entrepreneurship in Action: From Idea to Opportunity {II} Means-Ends Framework in Action: Trajectory of New Technologies Emergence of a New Venture Through Superior Value Proposition Storage Primary Secondary storage storage

556 views • 40 slides
Action Transportation Action Team Your Move Pilot ODOT and ODH joint initiative Action

Action Transportation Action Team Your Move Pilot ODOT and ODH joint initiative Action

Action Transportation Action Team Your Move Pilot ODOT and ODH joint initiative Action Transportation Action Team Targeted pilot - 5 counties September mid October Franklin Columbus Richland Mansfield Your Move Pilot Summit

482 views • 36 slides
EMERGENCE AND REDUCTION: GO HAND IN HAND? Katie Robertson University of Birmingham 1 THE

EMERGENCE AND REDUCTION: GO HAND IN HAND? Katie Robertson University of Birmingham 1 THE

EMERGENCE AND REDUCTION: GO HAND IN HAND? Katie Robertson University of Birmingham 1 THE EVOLVING RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN REDUCTION AND EMERGENCE At first, emergence was defined to be the failure of reduction. Then emergence was shown to

748 views • 47 slides
Emergence Emergence of sus of sustainable tainable markets markets Harriet Friedmann,

Emergence Emergence of sus of sustainable tainable markets markets Harriet Friedmann,

Getting from Getting from here to resilience: here to resilience: Emergence Emergence of sus of sustainable tainable markets markets Harriet Friedmann, Professor of Sociology, Geography and Planning University of Toronto American

737 views • 32 slides
Emergence and social dynamics Nigel Gilbert University of Surrey n.gilbert@surrey.ac.uk

Emergence and social dynamics Nigel Gilbert University of Surrey n.gilbert@surrey.ac.uk

Emergence and social dynamics Nigel Gilbert University of Surrey n.gilbert@surrey.ac.uk cress.soc.surrey.ac.uk Friday, April 3, 2009 1 Overview Computational social science Agent-based models Emergence in sociology Types of emergence An

621 views • 36 slides
Gaussian complex zeros and eigenvalues: Rare events and the emergence of the forbidden

Gaussian complex zeros and eigenvalues: Rare events and the emergence of the forbidden

Gaussian complex zeros and eigenvalues: Rare events and the emergence of the forbidden region Les Diablerets, 13/02/2018 Alon Nishry - Tel Aviv University Joint work with Subhroshekhar Ghosh (NUS) Random point configurations Poisson

774 views • 53 slides
JOINT ACTION ON BEST PRACTICE IMPLEMENTATION (NUTRITION) CHAFEA INFO DAY 24 June 2019,

JOINT ACTION ON BEST PRACTICE IMPLEMENTATION (NUTRITION) CHAFEA INFO DAY 24 June 2019,

JOINT ACTION ON BEST PRACTICE IMPLEMENTATION (NUTRITION) CHAFEA INFO DAY 24 June 2019, Luxembourg C4 Unit - Health Determinants and International Relations DG SANTE EUROPEAN COMMISSION Joint Action on implementation of best practices high

218 views • 10 slides
Introduction to Machine Learning Undirected Graphical Models Barnabs Pczos Credits Many of

Introduction to Machine Learning Undirected Graphical Models Barnabs Pczos Credits Many of

Introduction to Machine Learning Undirected Graphical Models Barnabs Pczos Credits Many of these slides are taken from Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Hugo Larochelle, & Eric Xing http://www.dmi.usherb.ca/~larocheh/neural_networks

570 views • 46 slides
Renewable Gas Interconnection & Operating Agreements Proposal May 18, 2020 Energy Division

Renewable Gas Interconnection & Operating Agreements Proposal May 18, 2020 Energy Division

Renewable Gas Interconnection & Operating Agreements Proposal May 18, 2020 Energy Division Workshop The Joint Utilities: Pacific Gas and Electric Company San Diego Gas & Electric Company Southern California Gas Company Southwest Gas

341 views • 13 slides
Inverse Kinematics (part 1) CSE169: Computer Animation Instructor: Steve Rotenberg UCSD, Winter

Inverse Kinematics (part 1) CSE169: Computer Animation Instructor: Steve Rotenberg UCSD, Winter

Inverse Kinematics (part 1) CSE169: Computer Animation Instructor: Steve Rotenberg UCSD, Winter 2017 Welman, 1993 Inverse Kinematics and Geometric Constraints for Articulated Figure Manipulation, Chris Welman, 1993 Masters thesis

805 views • 63 slides
Cooperative Business Relationships 200 Contents Intergovernmental Agreements Inter-agency

Cooperative Business Relationships 200 Contents Intergovernmental Agreements Inter-agency

14 CHAPTER Cooperative Business Relationships 200 Contents Intergovernmental Agreements Inter-agency Agreements for Joint Procurement Activity Joint-venture Partners Consortia 201 Methods for Implementing Maximize

399 views • 11 slides
Product-form solutions for models with joint-state dependent transition rates Simonetta Balsamo,

Product-form solutions for models with joint-state dependent transition rates Simonetta Balsamo,

Product-form solutions for models with joint-state dependent transition rates Simonetta Balsamo, Andrea Marin Universit` a Ca Foscari - Venezia Dipartimento di Informatica Italy 2010 Introduction and Motivations Previous works The novel

278 views • 17 slides
Truss St Tru s Structures Truss Definitions and Details 1 Truss: Mimic Beam Behavior 2

Truss St Tru s Structures Truss Definitions and Details 1 Truss: Mimic Beam Behavior 2

Truss St Tru s Structures Truss Definitions and Details 1 Truss: Mimic Beam Behavior 2 Bridge Truss Details 3 Framing of a Roof Supported Truss 4 5 Common Roof Trusses 6 Buckling Calculations 2 EI = weak P cr 2 k ( L) =

509 views • 37 slides
NEURAL RENDERING MODEL (NRM): JOINT GENERATION AND PREDICTION FOR SEMI-SUPERVISED LEARNING Tan

NEURAL RENDERING MODEL (NRM): JOINT GENERATION AND PREDICTION FOR SEMI-SUPERVISED LEARNING Tan

NEURAL RENDERING MODEL (NRM): JOINT GENERATION AND PREDICTION FOR SEMI-SUPERVISED LEARNING Tan Nguyen Joint work with Nhat Ho, Ankit B. Patel, Anima Anandkumar , Michael I. Jordan, and Richard G. Baraniuk Deep Learning The Current

621 views • 25 slides
Fast and Flexible Inference of Joint Distributions from their Marginals Charlie Frogner and

Fast and Flexible Inference of Joint Distributions from their Marginals Charlie Frogner and

Fast and Flexible Inference of Joint Distributions from their Marginals Charlie Frogner and Tomaso Poggio known ? unknown wikipedia Existing work : Limited to Bernoulli marginals, or relaxes the problem, or relies on approximate

283 views • 5 slides

More recommend