embedding evaluation into the national fish wildlife
play

Embedding Evaluation into the National Fish & Wildlife - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Embedding Evaluation into the National Fish & Wildlife Foundations Conservation Initiatives Christina Kakoyannis, Evaluation Officer Matt Birnbaum, Evaluation Officer Anthony Chatwin, Director of Marine & Coastal Conservation Tim


  1. Embedding Evaluation into the National Fish & Wildlife Foundation’s Conservation Initiatives Christina Kakoyannis, Evaluation Officer Matt Birnbaum, Evaluation Officer Anthony Chatwin, Director of Marine & Coastal Conservation Tim Male, Director of Wildlife & Habitat Conservation June 8, 2008

  2. The National Fish & Wildlife Foundation � Congressionally chartered in 1983 � Mission: Conserve & restore nation’s wildlife & habitats � Match public with private dollars � 10,000 grants to ~3,500 grantees � $635 million invested in projects nationwide & > 50 countries

  3. Traditional Role of NFWF Evaluation � Retrospective assessment of existing programs � 12 evaluations; ~1/3 of NFWF programs � Data limitations

  4. NFWF’s New Strategic Direction

  5. Shift in Selection of Conservation Initiatives SPECIES PLACES ISSUES Places of greatest Species of conservation Issues driving declines national ecological concern in species of concern importance NFWF ability to make a difference/“move the needle” � Measured as percent change toward population goals for indicator species � Preferred time frame 5– 10 years Cost-effectiveness HUMAN CONSIDERATIONS INITIATIVES

  6. Wildlife & Habitat Initiatives Grasslands Prairie Coteau Water flow/alpine wetlands Early Successional Bog Turtle New England Wildlife Corridors Cottontail Grizzlies Path of the Pronghorn Sky Islands

  7. Shift in Initiative Design & Implementation Act Check Plan Adjust

  8. Initiative Design & Implementation • Convene partners • ID & prioritize key threats • Define conservation targets

  9. Sky Islands Grasslands

  10. Land Predator & Ag practices conversion Varmint for farming control Rangeland & Ranchland Mgmt Practices Subdivision & Mining Development Chytrid fungus Invasive River Herring Poaching aquatic species Fire suppression Fences

  11. Sky Islands Grasslands Initiative Conservation Targets • Convene partners • ID & prioritize key threats • Define conservation targets

  12. Initiative Design & Implementation • Define goals • ID priority geographies • ID priority strategies • Assess risk • ID priority metrics

  13. NFWF Involved Current Trend

  14. • Define goals • ID priority geographies • ID priority strategies • Assess risk • ID priority metrics

  15. $24.5 million in Mitigation

  16. • Define goals • ID priority geographies • ID priority strategies • Assess risk • ID priority metrics

  17. Mapping the Logic—Klamath Initiative

  18. Risk Assessment � Risk : An uncertain event or condition which (if it occurs) has a • Define goals negative effect on the ability to meet the initiative goal. • ID priority geographies • ID priority strategies � Categories of Risk : • Assess risk • ID priority metrics • Regulatory • Financial • Environmental • Scientific • Social • Economic • Institutional “We’ve considered every • Project Management potential risk except the risk of avoiding all risks”

  19. Risk in the Klamath Basin Initiative Economic Risk: Lack of economic incentives

  20. Metrics • Define goals � Identifying and selecting key metrics: • ID priority geographies � Scale up from project-level monitoring of • ID priority strategies outputs to initiative goals/species change • Assess risk • ID priority metrics � Scientifically valid � Feasible considering available resources � Data needed to answer evaluation questions � Monitoring: � Protocols, Baseline, Comparison groups

  21. Fish Klamath Basin Initiative—Metrics abundance & age/size/ class in selected reaches # or % of landowners Amount along priority and timing sites of flow participating (cfs) into in projects Klamath Decreased amount lake and of water diverted at by reach the project scale

  22. Initiative Design & Implementation • Draft business plans

  23. Challenges to Address � Scale & Responsibilities: � Project/Grantee � Initiative/Foundation � Uncertainty of estimations � Selective implementation of adaptive mgmt principles recognizing resource constraints & planning fatigue

  24. NFWF Conservation Directors’ Perspectives

Recommend


More recommend