CSET09 Statistics PC Chairs: Angelos Stavrou, GMU Jelena Mirkovic, - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

CSET’09 Statistics

PC Chairs: Angelos Stavrou, GMU Jelena Mirkovic, USC/ISI

Program Committee

• Paul Barford, University of Wisconsin
• Andy Bavier, Princeton University
• Matt Bishop, University of California, Davis
• Thomas Daniels, Iowa State University
• Sonia Fahmy, Purdue University
• Carrie Gates, Computer Associates
• Alefiya Hussain, SPARTA Inc.
• Brent Kang, The University of North Carolina at Charlotte
• Vern Paxson, ICSI
• Sean Peisert, University of California, Davis
• Peter Reiher, University of California, Los Angeles
• Rob Ricci, University of Utah
• Mark Stamp, San Jose State University
• Kashi Vishwanath, Microsoft Research
• Vinod Yegneswaran, SRI International

Thanks!

Papers

• 27 submitted 9 accepted
• 3 papers clearly off topic, received 1 review
• Remaining papers received at least 3 reviews, 1 received 4

– Telecon PC meeting, all decisions reached via a concensus between reviewers – Common problems in papers: novelty or timeliness for research papers, lessons learned/teaching experience for education papers

• 4 more found off topic
• 13 submissions about experimentation - 4 accepted
• 5 submissions about testbeds/tools - 3 accepted
• 4 submissions about education - 2 accepted
• Eliminated COI by assigning reviews to PC members unrelated

to any coauthor (no close collaborators, no same employer)

– 2 submissions had a PC member as coauthor, these members stepped out of the PC meeting during their paper’s discussion – 1 was accepted, 1 was rejected

• Confident that we selected best quality papers for the workshop

Program At a Glance

9:15 - 9.45 Keynote address: Michael Van Putte, DARPA 9:45 - 10:00 Break 10:00 - 11:00 2 papers on security education 11:00 - 12:00 2 papers on security experimentation 12:00 - 1:00 Lunch 1:00 - 2.30 3 papers on testbeds 2:30 - 2:45 Break 2:45 - 3.45 2 papers on experimentation tools 3:45 - 4:00 Break 4:00 - 5:30 Panel on science of security experimentation:

• John McHugh, Dalhousie University
• Jennifer Bayuk, Jennifer L Bayuk LLC
• Minaxi Gupta, Indiana University
• Roy Maxion, Carnegie Mellon University

Future of CSET

• The number of submissions increased from last year

– We expect this trend to continue, true for past three years – This should improve the acceptance rate

• 25 out of 27 submissions were from people unrelated

to DETER

– We expect this ratio to increase, or stay the same

• Testbeds are still not as widely used as we’d like

– Many researchers are not aware of them, we expect this to change (GENI, NCR)

• Ideally we’d like more submissions about:

– Education, tools, experimental methodology, validating testbed results (but this greatly improved since last year)

• Likely with USENIX Security again next year